Journal Facts
Number of Volumes 8
Number of Issues 28
Number of Articles 360
Number of Contributors 882
Article View 7,758,913
PDF Download 8,174,468
View Per Article 21552.54
PDF Download Per Article 22706.86
Number of Submissions 719
Acceptance Rate 20
Time to Accept (Days) 124
Number of Indexing Databases 13
Number of Reviewers 57

 

The 8th World Congress on Education (WCE-2022) will be held from the 21st to 23rd of June online. WCE is an international refereed conference dedicated to the advancement of the theory and practices in education. The WCE-2022 promotes collaborative excellence between academicians and professionals from Education. The WCE-2022 main theme is Inclusive Education and Research. Special Session is on Covid-19.

 

 

Journal of Management and Educational Perspective (JMEP), is an open access double-blind peer peer-reviewed publication which is published by  Research Centre of Resources Management Studies and Knowledge-based Business concerned with new concepts in "Management, Improvement and training of Human Resources, business training and Entrepreneurship".  JMEP is a quarterly publication, which publishes original research papers related to journal scope. This journal follows of Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and complies with the highest ethical standards in accordance with ethical laws. All submitted manuscripts are checked for similarity through Hamyab software to ensure their authenticity to be assured about its originality and then rigorously peer-reviewed by the expert reviewers. This publication is based on the license registration number 85612 dated. 2019-08-5 of the Press Department of Interior, the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance published.  (Read More...)

              


Note: The Quarterly Journal of Management and educational perspective Outlook seeks to index (English) articles by authors at home and abroad. The journal also receives its articles in English. Therefore, authors from all countries are invited to submit their articles in English in the field of educational management, educational sciences and psychology to the journal.

Original Article (Mixed) management

The Impact of Ecosystem Development, Motivation, Network Orientation, and the Role Redesign of Think Tanks on Network-Based Think Tank Performance Management: The Role of Network Cohesion and Facilitation of Implementation

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.586594.1673

Iman Mansouri, Mohammad Mohammadi, Farzad Asayesh

Abstract The present study aimed to examine the effects of ecosystem development, motivation, network orientation, and the redesign of think tanks’ roles on performance management based on think-tank networks, considering the roles of network cohesion and implementation facilitation.This study was applied in terms of its purpose and employed a mixed-methods design (qualitative–quantitative) in terms of its implementation. The statistical population in the qualitative phase consisted of 19 faculty members, managers, and experts in public administration and performance management, who were selected through purposive sampling. In the quantitative phase, the statistical population comprised 173 employees working in governmental think tanks in Tehran, who were selected using simple random sampling.Data were collected through semi-structured interviews in the qualitative phase and questionnaires in the quantitative phase. For data analysis, the grounded theory approach was applied in the qualitative phase, whereas SmartPLS software was used in the quantitative phase. During the qualitative stage, 540 initial codes were extracted using the grounded theory method. These codes were subsequently categorized into 122 indicators, 32 components, and ultimately 13 dimensions.The findings revealed that the development of the think-tank network ecosystem exerted the strongest effect on network-based performance management, whereas orientation toward a network-based approach exhibited the weakest effect. Maintaining network cohesion played a mediating role in the relationships of role redesign and network orientation with network-based performance management. Moreover, facilitating the establishment of think-tank networks had a moderating effect on the relationships between ecosystem development and network orientation, on the one hand, and performance management, on the other hand.

Original Article (Mixed) Education Management

Identifying the factors affecting educational productivity in elementary schools in Fars Province

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.582306.1659

Mahsa Noroozi, Mina Rafiei, Mohammad Amin Rafiei, Mohammad Reza Ebrahimi Shahnani

Abstract The present study aimed to identify the factors affecting educational productivity in primary schools in Fars Province. In terms of purpose, this research was applied, and in terms of nature, it was descriptive; it was conducted using a mixed-methods approach (qualitative and quantitative). In the qualitative section, the statistical population consisted of 12 experts in primary education from the Ministry of Education, as well as university professors in educational management, who were selected through purposive sampling. In the quantitative section, the population included principals, assistant principals, and teachers of primary schools in Fars Province, of whom 380 individuals were considered as the sample. First, 10 counties were selected through random cluster sampling, and then the questionnaires were distributed and collected through convenience sampling. The data collection instruments consisted of semi-structured interviews in the qualitative section and a researcher-made questionnaire in the quantitative section. For data analysis, the Delphi method and SPSS version 23 and LISREL software were used. The findings showed that 38 sub-factors, within the categories of macro-level policymaking, educational planning, evaluation and supervision of productivity levels, organizational knowledge management, creativity and innovation, individual motivation, knowledge enhancement, organizational incentives, and staff training and development, affect the educational productivity of primary schools in Fars Province. It can be stated that coherent planning, increasing training courses, creating motivation among teachers, and implementing field evaluation and supervision can contribute to the improvement of educational productivity in primary schools in Fars Province.

Original Article (Qualitative) Managing change and innovation

Prioritizing antecedent factors influencing the role of artificial intelligence in human resource development

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.583227.1661

Ali Al-Buwaihi Haider wahid, Seyyed Najmuddin Mousavi, Amir Houshang Nazarpouri, Hojatollah Vahdati

Abstract The purpose of this research is to prioritize the antecedent factors influencing the role of artificial intelligence (AI) in human resource development. In terms of objective, the study is developmental; in terms of nature, it is descriptive; and regarding the data type, it is quantitative. The research population consists of 11 experts in human resource management, information technology, AI, and organizational management, selected through purposive sampling, with data collection continuing until theoretical saturation was reached. Data were gathered using a researcher-made Fuzzy Delphi questionnaire, developed based on a literature review and expert interviews. The Fuzzy Delphi method was employed for data analysis and was implemented in three rounds to identify, screen, and prioritize the antecedents. The identified antecedent factors include technical and infrastructural factors, human and organizational readiness, managerial and procedural dimensions, environmental conditions, and ethical and legal considerations. The findings revealed that “technological infrastructure and system integration” achieved the highest priority among the antecedents with a defuzzified value of 4.965, followed by “human and organizational readiness” (4.965) and “process organization and procedural factors” (4.114). Technological awareness, organizational culture, and data mining capability were also identified as influential antecedent dimensions. In contrast, “external conditions and environmental factors” received the lowest priority with a defuzzified value of 3.280.

Original Article (Mixed) Education Management

Identifying and Prioritizing Multidimensional Strategies for Maintaining the Job Motivation of Primary School Teachers

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.578049.1632

zeinab badreei, zeinab Toulabi, ali yasini

Abstract The purpose of this study is to identify and prioritize multidimensional strategies for sustaining the job motivation of primary school teachers (an integrated study). This research is applied in terms of its purpose, mixed‑method (qualitative–quantitative) in terms of implementation, and exploratory with a convergent mixed‑methods design in terms of data collection.The qualitative population consisted of 20 teachers, school principals, and educational experts in Ilam, selected through purposive sampling based on the principle of theoretical saturation. The quantitative population included 500 primary school teachers in Ilam, from which a sample size of 217 participants was determined using Cochran’s formula.Data were collected through semi‑structured interviews and a researcher‑developed questionnaire. In the qualitative phase, thematic analysis and MAXQDA 2020 software were employed, while in the quantitative phase, the Friedman test and PLS software were used.The analysis resulted in the identification of 62 basic themes and 17 organizing themes related to strategies for maintaining primary school teachers’ job motivation, which were subsequently categorized into 10 overarching themes. The findings indicate that organizational–social support and positive interactions with students exert the strongest influence on sustaining teachers’ job motivation. Moreover, significant differences were found in the prioritization of strategies based on teachers’ educational level and years of service.Overall, the results highlight the necessity of paying attention to the human, social, and meaning‑related dimensions of the teaching profession alongside structural and material factors, and can serve as a foundation for designing effective supportive policies and programs in the primary education system.

Original Article (Mixed) Human Resource Management

Designing a Human Resource Development Model for the Transformation of Iran’s Higher Education System: A Mixed-Methods Study

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.590155.1689

behrooz bahadori, syros tadbiri, Mahmood abaee koopaei, Seyed Mahdi Alvani, ali davari

Abstract This study utilized semi-structured interviews with experts in higher education and human resource management, which were analyzed using thematic analysis. In the quantitative phase, the extracted indicators were validated and refined through the Fuzzy Delphi Method (FDM) to ensure content validity and consensus among experts. Finally, the Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL) technique was employed for structural analysis and prioritization, identifying the causal relationships among the model’s dimensions and ranking the variables based on their prominence and net influence. Thematic analysis led to the identification of 289 initial codes, 63 sub-themes, and 19 basic themes, which were ultimately categorized into 9 main dimensions. These dimensions include: Human Resource Recruitment and Onboarding, Human Resource Development and Empowerment, Career and Human Capital Management, Performance Management and Intelligent Decision-Making, Governance and Organizational Structure, Organizational Culture and Social Capital, Environmental Interactions and Social Responsibility, Digital Transformation and Smart HR, and Data-Driven and HR Information Management. The Fuzzy Delphi results confirmed the optimal content validity of all indicators. Furthermore, the DEMATEL findings revealed that seven dimensions were classified as “causal/driving” factors, whereas “Career and Human Capital Management” and “Performance Management and Intelligent Decision-Making” were categorized as “effect/dependent” factors. The findings indicate that achieving the transformation goals of the higher education system requires an integrated approach to human capital development, digital transformation, data-driven management, and environmental interactions. The proposed model can serve as a strategic framework for policymaking, planning, and decision-making by higher education managers to enhance human resource effectiveness.

Original Article (Qualitative) Human Resource Management

Reconfiguring the Human Resource Development Model Based on Dynamic Capabilities in Public Organizations: A Thematic Analysis Approach

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.590939.1693

Lila babai, Javad mehrabi, Sayyedmahdi alvani, Gholamreza Memarzadeh Tehran

Abstract The present study aims to reconfigure the human resource development model based on dynamic capabilities in public organizations, with a focus on the Agricultural Bank of Iran. In terms of purpose, this research is applied, and in terms of its research paradigm, it is qualitative. The study population consisted of 16 experts in banking, human resource management, and academia. Sampling began purposively and continued until theoretical data saturation was achieved. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews. The interview data were analyzed using thematic analysis with the assistance of MAXQDA software. To assess coding reliability and ensure interpretive validity, Cohen’s kappa coefficient was calculated at 0.845, indicating excellent and reliable agreement among coders.An in-depth analysis of the interviews led to the identification and development of a thematic network comprising five global themes (main dimensions), 15 organizing themes (components), and 81 basic themes (indicators). The identified global themes included: “dynamic learning and innovation creation,” “agile and transformative reconfiguration,” “structural coordination and integration,” “empowering and future-oriented human resource management,” and “dynamic leadership and strategic decision-making.”The findings indicate that human resource development based on dynamic capabilities is the outcome of effective interactions between environmental drivers and internal strategic capacities. Its realization requires a fundamental transition from traditional and static human resource functions toward a learning-oriented, agile, data-driven, and transformative system.

Original Article (Qualitative) Human Resource Management

A Qualitative Model of AI‑Based Human Resource Management Interactions and Outcomes

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.581008.1653

Mohammad Mirzaei Khales, Alireza Rousta, Azadeh Ashrafi, Hassan Soltani

Abstract The present study aims to develop a qualitative model of the interactions and outcomes of artificial intelligence-based human resource management (AI-HRM). In terms of purpose, the research is exploratory, and in terms of implementation, it adopts a qualitative approach. The study population consisted of 18 university scholars, managers, and human resource management experts who were selected through purposive sampling. Data were collected using semi-structured interviews and analyzed through thematic analysis. The findings led to the identification of 183 codes, categorized into 28 basic themes and 27 organizing themes. The results indicated that AI-based human resource management comprises four principal dimensions: interactive algorithms in the interview screening process, including the interactive enhancement of interviews, intelligent matching of applicants with organizational competencies, and interactive analysis of résumé data; dynamic performance appraisal, including interactive evaluation of work quality, interactive prediction of long-term performance, and automated continuous feedback; employee interaction with the learning and development system, including interactive career path recommendation, adaptive learning content, and soft-skills simulation; and interactive human resource planning systems, including workforce estimation, turnover intention prediction, and improvement of HR processes. These four dimensions directly affect three major outcomes: operational productivity, with emphasis on automating administrative decrees and reducing leave-processing time; improvement in HR decision-making, with emphasis on the unbiased standardization of interviews and monitoring of behavioral data; and human resource value creation, with emphasis on shared value creation and alignment with strategic objectives.

Original Article (Quantified) Human Resource Management

Investigating the Impact of Organizational Justice on Organizational Commitment and Deviant Behavior Among Employees

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.586196.1672

Mohammad Mahmoudi Meymand, Saeed Arezoomand

Abstract The purpose of this study is to examine the effect of organizational justice on organizational commitment and deviant behavior among organizational employees. In terms of purpose, the study is applied, and in terms of method, it is descriptive-survey research. The statistical population consisted of 346 employees of Bank Mellat in Tehran Province, who were selected through stratified random sampling. A questionnaire was used as the data collection instrument. Data were analyzed using SmartPLS software.The findings indicate that interpersonal justice has a significant negative relationship with unlawful behavior, such that higher perceptions of respect and fair interpersonal treatment lead to a reduction in violations. In addition, procedural justice is positively and significantly related to interpersonal justice, and both distributive and procedural justice have a direct and positive relationship with affective commitment. On the other hand, although unlawful behavior showed a direct and significant relationship with negative behavior, no significant relationship was found between unlawful behavior and affective or normative commitment. In contrast, negative behavior had a significant negative relationship with both affective and normative commitment. These findings suggest that while organizational commitment can act as a deterrent to everyday negative behaviors, unlawful behaviors may be influenced by factors other than commitment, such as structural monitoring mechanisms.In conclusion, enhancing employees’ perceptions of justice in its distributive, procedural, and interpersonal dimensions is an effective strategy for increasing affective commitment and reducing deviant behaviors in service organizations such as banks. Managers should therefore focus on improving process transparency and the quality of human interactions in order to foster constructive behaviors.

Original Article (Qualitative) Education Management

An Integrated Framework Linking Triple-Level Organizational Learning with the Crisis Management Cycle in In-Service Education for Organizational Resilience

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.588137.1680

Manizheh Tajabadi Farahani, Mojtaba Moazami, Nazanin Baniasadi

Abstract The aim of this study is to explain and design a model linking three-level organizational learning and the crisis management cycle in in-service training with a focus on organizational resilience. Considering its objective, the research is applied, and in terms of implementation, it is qualitative and based on thematic analysis. The statistical population of the study consisted of 22 experts and specialists in the fields of educational management, organizational learning, and crisis management. The sampling method was purposive and snowball sampling. The data collection instrument was a semi-structured interview. Data analysis was conducted using thematic analysis, including open and axial coding, with the assistance of ATLAS.ti software. The findings showed that the reconfiguration of in-service training can be explained in three phases: preparedness, control, and learning. Specifically, identifying weak signals through new technologies in the preparedness phase, transforming field knowledge into training scenarios in the control phase, and decentralized management combined with a shared organizational language play key roles in strengthening learning and preventing organizational forgetting. The results indicate that existing in-service training programs, due to their emphasis on superficial learning, are not sufficiently effective in crisis conditions. To enhance organizational sustainability, these programs must move toward deep, experience-based, and scenario-based learning. Achieving this requires a managerial shift toward future-oriented approaches and the use of modern technologies in human capital management.

Original Article (Mixed) Education Management

Analyzing theories related to managing crowded classes and presenting an optimal model with a fuzzy approach

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.538106.1560

Farshid Rostamzadeh, Roghayyeh Vahdat Boorashan, Hasan Ghalavandi

Abstract The aim of the present study is to analyze theories related to the management of large classes and to present an optimal model with a fuzzy approach. This research is of applied research type in terms of purpose and nature and mixed (qualitative-quantitative) in terms of implementation. In the first part of the study, in order to develop a comprehensive model of analyzing theories related to the management of large classes, the method of comparative content analysis was used to review domestic and foreign studies over the past two decades. The samples were selected purposefully and based on theoretical saturation, and the intra-subject agreement rate was 0.92. The data were processed and analyzed using the content analysis method. In the second part of the study, which is a survey, the mathematical modeling method (fuzzy expert system) was used to present the optimal combination of model dimensions so that large classes can be managed more effectively and optimally. The results of this study showed that the proposed model of large class management, by emphasizing key factors such as creating a supportive environment, positive and constructive interactions, shaping a self-regulatory environment, developing metacognitive skills, goal setting, and accountability, can help create more effective and sustainable learning environments. The findings of this study can be used as a guide for educational policies and designing classroom management improvement programs, and in particular, help teachers and educational administrators to effectively implement appropriate strategies for optimal management of large classes.

Original Article (Qualitative) Human Resource Management

Presenting a model of flattery with Fairclough's critical discourse analysis approach

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.583983.1663

Mohadese Pour Hoseinali, Mohammad Montazeri, Shamsosadat Zahedi

Abstract The aim of this study is to develop a model of ingratiation using Fairclough’s Critical Discourse Analysis approach. In terms of purpose, the study is applied-developmental; in terms of data collection, it is descriptive; and regarding the nature of the data, it is qualitative. The statistical population consisted of 20 specialists and experts familiar with organizational behavior issues in a large mining and industrial company. Snowball sampling was employed, and sampling continued until theoretical saturation was achieved. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews. MAXQDA 2020 software was used for data analysis. Using Fairclough’s Critical Discourse Analysis method, 81 discourse codes with 116 frequencies were extracted and classified into 5 main categories, including discursive duality, discursive labeling, verbal strategies, linguistic metaphors, and lexical manipulation. In addition, 131 descriptive codes with 228 frequencies were identified and categorized into 9 main categories, including managers’ reactions, structural and discursive inequality, organizational context, verbal strategies, resistance to ingratiation, causes and drivers of ingratiation, benefits and rewards of ingratiation, organizational consequences, and the reproduction of ingratiation. The findings showed that the most important causes of ingratiation included ambiguity in evaluation criteria (5 frequencies), centralized power structure (4 frequencies), structural insecurity (3 frequencies), and fear of weakened position (3 frequencies). The dominant verbal strategies included voluntary self-censorship (3), resistant silence (3), reality softening (3), and unquestioning approval (3). The main consequences were perceived injustice (5), filtering of real information (4), weakening of horizontal and vertical trust (4), and fatigue and demotivation among staff (4).

Original Article (Qualitative) Human Resource Management

Analysis of the Dimensions and Components of the Managers’ Competence-phobia Model in Organizations

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.587315.1676

Hamidreza Emami, Amin Nikpour, Zahra Shokoh, Soheila Shamsadini

Abstract The present study aims to examine the dimensions and components of managers’ meritophobia model (case study: public and private organizations in the city of Kerman). In terms of purpose, this research is applied-developmental, and in terms of methodology, it was conducted qualitatively using thematic analysis. The statistical population consisted of 20 managers from public and private organizations in Kerman. Participants were selected through purposive sampling based on the criterion of having at least 10 years of managerial experience in public and private organizations and full familiarity with this field. Semi-structured interviews with participants continued until theoretical saturation was reached.The data collection tool consisted of two parts: review and exploration of the research literature in the library section, and semi-structured interviews in the field section. Data were analyzed using thematic analysis (basic, organizing, and overarching themes), and the process of coding and textual analysis of the interviews was carried out using MAXQDA 2018 qualitative data analysis software.The findings of the study showed that the adaptive model of managers’ meritophobia in public and private organizations in Kerman includes the following dimensions: individual-personality factors (fear of losing power, ضعف اعتماد به نفس مدیریتی مدیریتی / low managerial self-confidence, superiority complex, and narrow-mindedness); structural-process factors (lack of a succession planning system, weak performance evaluation system, absence of a clear career path, and lack of a talent bank); cultural-environmental factors (relationship-oriented culture, administrative politicization, nepotism, and weak laws); and anti-merit methods and behaviors (organizational exclusion, marginalization, discrediting, and delaying/blocking).

Original Article (Qualitative) management

Leveling organizational belonging factors based on spiritual leadership style: Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM)

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.584003.1664

Hamid Salary Saeidy, Mohammad jalal kamali, Yaser Salari, Zahra Anjomshoae

Abstract The present study aims to classify and level the factors influencing organizational commitment based on a spiritual leadership style using the Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) method. In terms of purpose, the research is applied-developmental, and regarding data collection, it is descriptive; in terms of implementation, it follows a quantitative approach. The statistical population consisted of 10 managers from Bank Sepah in Kerman province, each with over 20 years of work experience, at least 10 years of managerial experience, and a specialized academic background in management. Participants were selected using purposive sampling. Data were collected through an ISM questionnaire, which was distributed, completed, and analyzed in the field. For the leveling of factors, Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) and MICMAC software were utilized. The findings revealed that “Hope” and “Vision” occupy the fourth level, functioning as the foundation of the model and possessing the highest driving power in shaping organizational commitment, acting as a “strategic driver.” “Value Thinking and Perception,” “Sense of Purpose,” and “Meaningfulness” are positioned at the third level, serving as mediating factors. “Spirituality in the Organization,” “Job Characteristics,” “Self-Knowledge,” and “Sincere Behaviors” are located at the second level, also functioning as mediators. Finally, “Environmental Awareness,” “Self-Actualization,” and “Cultural Intelligence” are placed at the first level as the final outcomes of the model.

Original Article (Mixed) Human Resource Management

Designing a Comprehensive Human Resource Management System

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.581301.1655

Hossein Yakhkeshi, Ahmad ali Khaefelahi, Maliheh Raoof Esmaeili, Elie Moghimi Khorasani

Abstract The present study aims to design a comprehensive Human Resource Management (HRM) system in the Supreme Audit Court of Iran. In terms of implementation, the research adopted a mixed-methods (qualitative–quantitative) approach using exploratory analyses. The statistical population in the qualitative phase consisted of 12 organizational experts selected through purposive and snowball sampling methods. In the quantitative phase, the population included 210 official employees working at the headquarters of the Supreme Audit Court. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and questionnaires. Qualitative data were analyzed using coding techniques with MAXQDA 2020 software, while quantitative data were analyzed using SMARTPLS 4 and SPSS 24 software. The findings indicated that the comprehensive HRM system in the Supreme Audit Court comprises four dimensions and 26 components. The four identified dimensions include human resource planning, human resource development, human resource maintenance, and influencing behavioral variables. The planning dimension consists of six components, development includes five components, maintenance comprises four components, and influencing behavioral variables encompass eleven components. The results further revealed that the current human resource conditions in the Supreme Audit Court are not in a favorable state and require immediate attention from senior management.

Original Article (Qualitative) Human Resource Management

Patterning the Development of Human Capital Capacities, Organizational Culture, and Organizational Wisdom for Banking Governance

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.581356.1654

Hashem Shahriyari, Mohammad Reza Hamidizadeh

Abstract The purpose of this study is to model the development of capacities for human capital, organizational culture, and organizational wisdom for banking governance. In terms of purpose, this is an applied study; regarding methodology, it is qualitative, based on an interpretivist paradigm and inductive logic, and is exploratory in nature. The study population consists of 14 senior, middle, and operational managers of Shahr Bank, who were selected using non-probability, purposive sampling. Data collection was conducted through semi-structured interviews, which continued until theoretical saturation was reached. The qualitative data analysis process was carried out using grounded theory and thematic analysis methods.The results of this study indicate that the identified factors include: Ethical Leadership (including exemplary managerial behavior, active listening, and consistency between speech and action); Trust-based Learning Culture (including organizational trust, a spirit of learning, error acceptance, and healthy dialogue); Facilitating and Transparent Governance (including committee structure, staff development reporting, balance between control and agility, targeted human capital development, operational training, succession planning, multidimensional evaluation, and alignment of training with job requirements); Dynamic Organizational Wisdom (including an experience bank, experience sharing, data-driven decision-making, and learning from errors); Conflict-Inducing Factors (including centralization, informal relationships, quantitative-only evaluation, and excessive control); and Convergent Factors (including transparency, trust, targeted training, fair evaluation, as well as continuous dialogue and feedback).

Original Article (Qualitative) management

Designing a model of employee social action using a document analysis approach

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.590048.1687

Masoumeh Etemadiyan, Nasrin Khodabakhshi Hafeshjani, Hajiya Rajabi Farjad

Abstract The aim of this study was to use a document analysis approach in designing a model of employees’ social action. In terms of purpose, the study was applied research; in terms of method, it fell within descriptive studies with a correlational approach; and in terms of implementation, it was qualitative in nature. The statistical population consisted of 11 experts. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews. For data analysis, content analysis and MAXQDA 2020 software were employed.The findings showed that employees’ social action is a multidimensional phenomenon shaped by justice, trust, organizational culture, and organizational identity. Contextual conditions such as organizational structure and culture, the level of autonomy, and communication channels, as well as intervening conditions such as pressures, burnout, and institutional monitoring, play a decisive role in the emergence of social action. The proposed strategies for promoting social action include strengthening social capital, empowering employees, and institutionalizing justice and organizational transparency. The ultimate outcomes of these actions are increased job satisfaction, organizational commitment, creativity, and the organization’s cultural capital. The results of this study can serve as a practical and theoretical guide for organizations and managers in improving social interactions and responsible employee behavior.

Original Article (Mixed) Human Resource Management

Designing a Framework for the Role of Nongovernmental Organizations in the Public Welfare and Social Security Sector

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.590860.1692

Afshin Najafi Shirtari, Hamidreza Rezaee Kelidbari, Farzin Farahbod

Abstract Over the past two decades, Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) have become pivotal pillars of welfare systems in many countries; however, there remains a lack of a clear theoretical and empirical formulation of the direct and indirect functions of these institutions. The present study was conducted with the aim of providing a comprehensive model of NGO roles within Iran’s social welfare and social security system. Adopting a qualitative approach within an interpretivist paradigm, data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 12 experts, including NGO managers, legal advisors, and faculty members. Data analysis was carried out using the thematic analysis method based on the Attride-Stirling (2001) model, which ultimately led to the extraction of 29 open codes and 5 basic themes. The findings indicate that NGO roles can be categorized into two levels: first, direct service-providing and empowering roles, including health and welfare service delivery, bridging service gaps, and empowering vulnerable groups; and second, indirect advocacy and supervisory roles, such as monitoring health rights, fostering transparency, needs assessment, policy innovation, and inter-organizational networking. The study concludes that NGOs in Iran have been largely reduced to direct, executive roles and, due to significant structural barriers—such as the lack of supportive legislation, financial dependence on the government, and the absence of a unified database—have failed to perform indirect monitoring and policy-making functions. Ultimately, achieving an efficient hybrid welfare system requires a fundamental redefinition of the relationship between the government and NGOs, alongside the establishment of supportive institutional, legal, and financial frameworks.

Original Article (Qualitative) management

The process of trusting government managers and employees in intelligent systems

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.587845.1677

Gholamreza Tizfahm Fard, Vahideh taherkhani, MAHMOUD SAMADI, Seyyed Reza Mousavi Zadeh

Abstract The aim of the present study is to explain the paradigmatic model of "development of mutual trust between humans and systems" in executive agencies. This research is applied in terms of purpose and qualitative in terms of methodology with a data-based theory approach. The statistical population included experts, senior managers of information technology, and public administration specialists, who were conducted using a purposive sampling method (snowball), 17 semi-structured interviews until theoretical saturation was achieved. The data analysis process was carried out using three-stage coding (open, axial, and selective) with maxquda software. The findings show that the pivotal phenomenon of "development of mutual trust" is the result of the interaction of causal conditions (governance and legal requirements, complexity of administrative tasks, need for computational transparency), contextual conditions (digital literacy and user expertise, fear of substitution, ambiguity in the legal accountability of the system), and intervening factors (complexity of algorithm logic and fear of substitution). In the strategy phase, continuous training and empowerment, participatory design of systems plays a key role in reducing organizational uncertainties. The results of this model indicate that the deployment of intelligent systems in the public sector, beyond technical aspects, requires a mental re-creation of the role of machines in decision-making processes. By providing a comprehensive framework, this research offers operational solutions for enhancing social capital and national productivity through the transition to data-driven governance.

Original Article (Qualitative) management

Identification and Elucidation of the Thematic Network Underlying an Organization’s Public Policy-Making Model Based on the Social Construction Framework of Political Groups: A Qualitative Study

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.590046.1688

Mohamadali Jahantab, Akbar Etebariyan Khorasgani, Mehraban Hadi Peikani, Reza Ebrahimzadeh

Abstract This research aims to identify and elucidate the thematic network of an organization’s public policy-making model, grounded in the social construction framework of political groups, through a qualitative approach. Methodologically, the study is qualitative in nature and employs thematic analysis. The statistical population includes 10 professors and experts in the field of public policy. The sample size was determined using the snowball sampling technique, with interviews continuing until theoretical saturation was achieved. Semi-structured interviews were utilized for data collection, and data analysis was performed via thematic analysis using MAXQDA software.The research findings yielded a total of 717 primary codes, categorized into 59 basic themes, seven organizing themes, and one global theme. The results revealed that the thematic network comprises seven dimensions: 1) the socio-cultural context of policy formation, 2) the intellectual foundations of policymakers, 3) symbolic and meaning-making concepts, 4) the power and hegemony of political groups, 5) the construction of policy reality, 6) the ideological transformation of policymakers and political groups, and 7) the social construction of policy. This model advances Schneider and Ingram’s theory of the social construction of target populations from the level of describing outcomes to the level of explaining the components that shape social construction, providing a practical framework for mitigating the subjective biases of policymakers.

Assessing Factors Affecting the Orientation of the Cours-of-Study Selection In Students

Volume 1, Issue 1, Autumn 2019, Pages 15-30

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2019.100581

Somayeh Mokhtar Zadeh bazargani, Saeed Alizadeh

Abstract  Choosing a field of study is one of the most important decisions that students make during their studies so that it can determine their career prospects. The aim of the present study was to investigate the factors affecting students' choice of educational field in Noshahr. The research method was descriptive and the statistical population consisted of both male and female high school students studying in three fields of high school mathematics physics, empirical sciences and humanities in the academic year 2015-2016. 200 subjects were selected according to the Krejcie and Morgan table using stratified random sampling. The research instrument used in this study is a researcher-made questionnaire of factors affecting educational field choice. Data were analyzed using one-sample t-test and Friedman test. The findings of this study showed that the opinion of the educational advisor, student interest, educational background, family opinion, and academic aptitude were effective in choosing the field of study in Noshahr city (P <0.05). Also, the opinion of the family has the highest rating and the opinion of the secretary and the academic advisor is the lowest.

The role of school atmosphere and emotional intelligence in the entrepreneurial self-efficacy of female students in Mashhad vocational schools

Volume 1, Issue 2, Winter 2020, Pages 15-36

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2020.227912.1010

Azadeh Amiri

Abstract The present study was conducted to investigate the role of school atmosphere and emotional intelligence in the entrepreneurial self-efficiency of female students in Mashhad vocational schools and was descriptive-correlational. The statistical population of the study included all female students of Mashhad vocational schools in the year 1398-99; 335 students were selected as samples by cluster sampling method according to Morgan table. Data collection was performed using school atmosphere scale of Zolig et al. (2010), emotional intelligence scale of Bradbury-Graves (2005) and entrepreneurial self- efficiency scale of Wilson et al. (2007). The research hypotheses were tested using structural equations modeling. The findings of this study showed that the entrepreneurial self- efficiency of female students in Mashhad vocational schools can be explained and predicted from the school atmosphere and emotional intelligence (P <0.05). There was also a significant relationship between emotional intelligence and entrepreneurial self- efficiency and between school atmosphere and entrepreneurial self- efficiency of female students of Mashhad vocational schools (P <0.01). The results of this study showed that by reforming the school atmosphere and reviewing the academic evaluation in order to foster students' creativity and self- efficiency, their entrepreneurial ideas should be strengthened and applied to increase entrepreneurial self- efficiency.

Relationship between Teachers' Communication Skills and Students' Academic Well-being with Emphasis on the Mediating Role of Academic Adjustment in Girls' High Schools in Kashmar

Volume 3, Issue 1, Spring 2021, Pages 167-195

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2021.282353.1056

javad shalian

Abstract Extended Abstract
Abstract
The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between teachers 'communication skills and academic well-being with emphasis on the mediating role of students' academic adjustment. The research method was descriptive-survey. Teachers (143 persons) were selected based on Krejcie and Morgan table by simple random sampling method and 371 students(371 persons)  were selected by cluster random sampling method as a statistical sample. In the present study, the educational welfare questionnaires of Peternin et al. (2014), Baker and Cyriac (1984) academic adjustment questionnaires and communication skills of Queen Dam teachers (2004) were used. Their validity was confirmed by academic experts and their reliability by means of Cronbach's alpha coefficient test was obtained 0.76, 0.89 and 0.72, respectively, and approved. In order to analyze the data, structural equation technique was applied using Lisrel statistical software and Spss26 statistical software. Quantitative results obtained from hypothesis testing of the study showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between teachers 'communication skills and students' academic adjustment and academic well-being. There is a positive and significant relationship between students 'academic adjustment and their academic well-being, and academic adjustment in the relationship between teachers' communication skills and Students' academic well-being has played a mediating role.
Introduction
Today, education, specifically or generally. is an important part of every person's life, in addition, the quality and quantity of this education also plays an important role in the individual's future life. Therefore, for nearly a century, psychologists have been widely involved in Attempts to identify predictor factors of the academic achievement. Awareness of students' psychological aspects can act as a powerful teaching aid tool. For example, understanding how students behave in certain situations can lead to an increase the effectiveness of educational tools as well as teacher's teaching methods and the education system and ultimately the progress of students (hamedinasab and asgari, 2020).
Academic well-being is one of the most important and influential variables on academic performance. It is derived from the basis of positive psychological theory, and those who possess dejected behavior and negative excitements such as anger, disturbance and sorrow; more than others are subject to education drop and drop-out.(Jahani and etal, 2018). Teachers are the most important variable in students' learning. In other words, the most important factor in the educational system is not the teaching materials or teaching methods, but the teachers themselves; and due to this importance, over the years, researchers have examined the internal and external factors effective on the performance of teachers and therefore the performance of students (Teymoriyan and etal, 2018). Communication skills Refers to behaviors through which a person can communicate with others in a way that leads to positive responses and avoid negative ones (Nakagawa and etal, 2019). Given the importance of communication skills and educational adaptation in improving the academic well-being of students, recognizing its affective factors is one of the main necessities of our country's educational system.
Therefore, because the researches concern with the above-mentioned variables and their effective amount on the student's educational well-being have not much fulfilled, in the present study, the researcher decided to address the relationship between these variables in the girls' high schools in Kashmar. Therefore, this study examines the question of whether there is a significant relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic well-being by emphasizing the mediating role of academic adjustment in girls' high schools in Kashmar.
Case study
In this study, all teachers and students of girls' secondary schools in Kashmar city have been studied as a case study.
Theoretical framework
Ardalan and Hosseinchari in a study showed that communication skills can predict students' academic adjustment (Ardalan and Hosseinchari, 2010). Research results have shown that there is a direct relationship between communication skills variables with students' academic well-being and self-efficacy. Accordingly, with increasing and developing teachers' communication skills, students' well-being and self-efficacy will improve (Baezat and Rahimi, 2015). Another study on academic adjustment showed that there is a positive relationship between communication skills and academic adjustment and motivation (Bahadori Khosroshahi and Habibi Kelibar, 2017). Another study has shown that teachers 'communication skills can develop students' self-efficacy and ultimately their academic well-being (Baezat and Rahimi, 2015). Research has shown that friendly and effective communication in the classroom has an effective role in improving the academic atmosphere and academic adjustment of students. Accordingly, academic adjustment will improve academic conditions and lead to high academic performance (Cheong and etal, 2019).
Methodology
This research is of descriptive-survey type. The study population includes teachers and students of girls' secondary schools in Kashmar. Based on this, 143 teachers were selected by simple random sampling and 371 students were selected by combined cluster random sampling as the sample size. Piternin et al.'s (2014) Academic Welfare Questionnaire, Queen Dam's Teachers' Communication Skills (2004) and Baker's and Cyriac's (1984) Academic Adjustment Questionnaires were used for data collection.
Discussion and Results
The first hypothesis of the research is to measure the relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic adjustment. The strength of the relationship between communication skills and academic adjustment is calculated to be equal to (0.62), which indicates a favorable correlation. The t-test of the test was obtained (7.60), which is greater than the critical value of t at the level of error of 5% (1.96) and shows that the strength of the observed relationship is significant. Therefore, it can be said that there is a positive and significant relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic adjustment.
The second hypothesis of the research has investigated the relationship between students' academic adjustment and their academic well-being. The strength of the relationship between academic adjustment and academic well-being has been calculated equal to (0.68), which indicates a favorable correlation. The t-test of the test was obtained (7.66), which is more than the critical value of t in the error level of 5% (1.96) and shows that the strength of the observed relationship is significant. Therefore, it can be said that there is a positive and significant relationship between students' academic adjustment and their academic well-being.
The third hypothesis of the study analyzed the relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic well-being. The strength of the relationship between communication skills and academic well-being has been calculated equal to (0.39), which indicates a favorable correlation. The t-test of the test was obtained (4.37), which is more than the critical value of t at the level of 5% error (1.96) and shows that the strength of the observed relationship is significant. Therefore, it can be said that there is a positive and significant relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic well-being.
The fourth hypothesis of the study examines the relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic well-being with the mediating role of academic adjustment. In order to examine the meditative effect of the academic adjustment in the hypothesis under discussion, the direct effect of the two structures in comparison with the indirect effect when the academic adjustment variable interferes should be examined so that if the effect increases, the mediating effect of the link with the school can be considered acceptable. In the present hypothesis, the power of the direct relationship between communication skills and academic well-being is (0.39). The indirect effect if there is a mediating variable of academic adjustment is:  (0.42) = (0.68) * (0.62)
Due to the lower effect of direct path than indirect paths, therefore, the existence of the mediator variable of academic adjustment increases the strength of the relationship and the mediating role of academic adjustment in the present hypothesis is confirmed.
Conclusion
The results of the first hypothesis of the research showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic adjustment. This hypothesis is explained by the fact that students try to give more explanations to those of their classmates who are less absorbant and have difficulty in understanding the curriculum, and help them understand class topics (Yazdani and Soleimanpouromran, 2018). These results are consistent with and supported by research findings (Nakagawa and etal, 2019; Alizadeh and Jouybari, 2016; nasri and etal, 2017). Based on this, the first hypothesis of the research is confirmed.
The results of the second hypothesis of the study showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between students' academic adjustment and their academic well-being. In explaining this hypothesis, it can be said that a positive attitude intensifies the desire to continue communication and learning (Badri and etal, 2019). With high ability to distinguish emotions and improve mood in students it is exceptable that their academic engagement status will lead to a successful and evolved identity (Oinas and etal, 2021). These results are consistent and supported by the research findings (Razavi Alavi and etal, 2018, Nasri zadeh and Nargesian, 2019, Nair and etal, 2021). Based on this, the second hypothesis of the research is confirmed.
The results of the third hypothesis of the study showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between teachers 'communication skills and students' academic well-being.This hypothesis is explained by the fact that improving the learning conditions in the classroom causes Students can be satisfied with the effective teaching in the classroom and look forward to the educational content (Lebares and etal, 2021).  These results are consistent with and supported by research findings (Behroozi and etal, 2018, Hoferichter and etal, 2021). Based on this, the third hypothesis of the research is confirmed.
The results of the fourth hypothesis of the study showed that there is a significant relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic well-being with the mediating role of academic adjustment. This hypothesis is explained by the fact that students who take the initiative to learn, in comparison with the students who passively attend in class and receive instruction, learn more and better (Ghomi and etal, 2017). These results are consistent with and supported by research findings (Razavi alavi and etal, 2018, Delgado and etal, 2018). Based on this, the fourth hypothesis of the research is confirmed.

The Application of Educational Technology Components in the Main Sources of Curriculum Planning

Volume 2, Issue 1, Spring 2020, Pages 49-69

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2020.233969.1015

leila poloie, Faezeh Farhadian

Abstract The aim of the present study was to investigate the application of educational technology components in the main sources of curriculum planning. This research was of content analysis type and its statistical population included all the main sources of curriculum planning at the university level. Nine books were selected as the research sample by the deliberate sampling method. Data collection tools were the check list of educational technology components. Data analysis was performed by means of descriptive statistics. The research findings showed that in the case of each component of educational technology to some subscales such as summary; the use of color in titles, text, image, and cover, the appropriate location for visual materials, and the avoidance of visual bias are not considered in any of the nine main sources of curriculum planning. Furthermore, the use of other subscales has been different in the main sources of curriculum planning; So that in some sources they have been used and in others they have not. Therefore, there is a need for a serious overhaul of the application of educational technology components in the main sources of curriculum planning for future editions.

The effect of intellectual scaffolding on educational management in the application of new educational technologies on academic motivation and academic achievement in science courses for female students in the fifth grade of elementary school

Volume 2, Issue 1, Spring 2020, Pages 19-33

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2020.231073.1012

Atiyeh Kordloo, Mohammad Reza Behrangi

Abstract The main purpose of the present study was to investigate the "scale" of the effect of intellectual scaffolding on educational management in the application of new educational technologies on academic motivation and academic achievement in the science course for fifth grade elementary school girls. The study method was quasi-experimental. The statistical population included fifth grade elementary school girls in Districts 1 and 2 of Tehran. The sample size was 297 students based on the Morgan Curriculum Table, of which 148 in the experimental group and 149 in the control group. The measuring instrument was Harter's Educational Motivation Questionnaire (1981). After pre-test, model of management education based on the scaffold rational management of training in the use of new technologies training in science for experimental and traditional teaching methods applied to the control group, and at the end of the test both control and experimental groups were controled. The results of t-test showed that the intellectual scaffolding of educational management in the application of new educational technologies is effective on motivation and academic achievement in the science course of fifth grade elementary school girls (p <0.01). The results of this study showed that this teaching model is applicable to increase motivation and academic achievement in science.

Relationship between classroom management practices and communication skills with academic achievement motivation of primary school students in Chabaksar

Volume 2, Issue 3, Autumn 2020, Pages 113-131

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2020.243991.1030

Leila Talebi Khansari

Abstract The aim of this study was to determine the relationship between classroom management practices and communication skills with the academic achievement motivation of elementary school students in Chabaksar. The research method was descriptive-correlation. The statistical population of this study included teachers and male and female elementary school students in Chabaksar. 80 teachers and 200 students were selected using simple random sampling and cluster random sampling. Teachers answered the questions of the Communication Skills Questionnaire (Quindam, 2004) and teaching style (Gerash, 1996), and students answered the questions of the Academic Achievement Motivation Questionnaire (Walrand, 1992). Data analysis using stepwise regression method showed that the variables of classroom management practices and listening skills are the best predictors for the variable of academic achievement motivation, and there is a relationship between classroom management practices and communication skills with students' academic achievement motivation (P <0.01). As a result, teachers can benefit from effective classrooming styles and communication skills to increase motivation for academic achievement and prevent student burnout.

relationship between learning styles and language instruction skills of high school students

Volume 1, Issue 1, Autumn 2019, Pages 45-62

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2019.100583

javad solleymanpoor

Abstract Paying attention to learning styles and its determining components [determinants] for students plays a crucial role in teaching and education of today’s world. Therefore, the current study’s goal was to explore the relations between learning styles (with respect to its basic components) and language learning skills (English language). For this purpose, statistical population of this research is a total of 1260 male students from high schools in Chalous province among which 154 subjects are selected randomly, by Morgan-Krejcie’s Table. This research is conducted based on Vermont and Rijswijk’s theory (for assessment of learning styles) and language learning skills (the skills of listening, speaking, reading and writing) in English language. Main tool for data collection is standardized questionnaire of learning styles, and data analysis of current research is done by using of Pearson coefficient and stepwise regression. Results from this research indicate that all learning styles have a positive and direct relationship with language learning skills, but two types of learning styles, namely decentralized with a coefficient of 0.497 and meaning and goal based learning style with a coefficient of 0.283 has got the highest importance. Hence it can be said that for as much enhancement and comprehension as possible, if educational system considers decentralized and meaning and goal based learning styles, it will be more helpful for students to achieve the language learning skills. In the other word, importance of learning styles’ role recognition in anticipating of students’ language learning skills is confirmed.

Education Management

Presenting a fuzzy cognitive map of teachers' quantum skills using the FCM method

Volume 7, Issue 4, Winter 2026, Pages 22-46

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.529449.1524

Zahra Mardani, Nasrollah Ghashghaeizadeh

Abstract Abstract The present study was conducted with the aim of presenting a fuzzy cognitive map of teachers' quantum skills. The present study is applicable in terms of its purpose, and exploratory in terms of data collection. It also is a mixed (qualitative-quantitative) research based on the inductive deductive philosophy. The statistical population of the research is experts including secondary school teachers in Isfahan province, 26 of whom were selected using purposive sampling and based on the principle of theoretical adequacy. The data collection tool in the qualitative part is an interview, the validity and reliability of which was confirmed using content validity and theoretical validity and the intra-coder and inter-coder reliability methods. Also, the data collection tool in the quantitative part is a questionnaire, the validity and reliability of which was confirmed using content validity and test-retest reliability. Qualitative data were analyzed by content analysis method using MaxQDA software, and quantitative data were analyzed by fuzzy cognitive mapping method. The results of this study indicate that the skill and ability to act responsibly, the power to transform feelings, performance and cognition from internal to external states, maintaining a positive inner feeling regardless of external events, and exiting the limited and linear state towards students are the most important quantumnomic skills of teachers. Introduction Although the status and dignity of the teaching as a profession is obvious to everyone and the role of a teacher has always been known, the world is changing rapidly and teachers must also face this reality like other professional groups (Habibzadeh et al., 2024). Therefore, teachers, as one of the complex components of the education system ecosystem, must be able to meet the expectations and demands of different officials and stakeholders and have a deep understanding of social developments and future changes. Thus, teachers should continuously seek to update their knowledge and skills and improve their professional behaviors (Claro et al., 2024). Strengthening the teachers' quantum skills is among the factors helping them achieve this goal. Creating novel knowledge has long been one of the basic functions of educational centers, and the greatest effort of the scientific and educational community has been to develop science and strengthen intellectual capital by utilizing existing information, intellectual, and human resources (Zohar, 2021). Thus, educational centers, especially the education system, should identify, acquire, and utilize these resources by using the right management methods. In this regard, one of the new concepts of the third millennium is quantum skills (Yin, 2019). Quantum capabilities are capabilities that enable teachers to think dynamically and intuitively (Coccia et al., 2022). Quantum transforms and reverses teachers’ perspective on phenomena from top to bottom and from outside to inside, and this is possible by equipping teachers and school administrators with quantum skills (Rachmawati, 2012). It should also be acknowledged that finding order in chaos, movement in the midst of organizational noise and job stress, self-organization and focusing on tasks in a thoughtful manner, focusing on holistic approaches and avoiding detail are some of the indicators related to quantum skills that teachers can use to improve the level of strategic flexibility in schools (Greinert et al., 2024). The success or failure of educational programs and activities in any system and any nation depends on its teachers, and transformation cannot be achieved without a change in the strength of the educational system (Soltani Ahmadi et al., 2023). Having quantum capabilities allows teachers to quickly identify the educational process in schools and respond to new demands in the field of teaching (Zohar, 2021). Thus, it can be acknowledged that teachers with a high level of quantum skills have high flexibility in the face of changes necessary for schools, and this makes the education process easier. On the other hand, a review of the domestic and foreign foundations and background indicates that more extensive and comprehensive research has been conducted on quantum management; and less on quantum skills. It is obvious that research on this concept is still not comprehensive and sufficient, and the increasing surveys and research on this concept itself confirms this claim. According to the study, there is no research in the field of quantum skills of teachers that examines the types of quantum skills. Therefore, considering what has been said, the present study seeks to answer the question: What are the types of quantum skills of teachers?  Theoretical Framework Quantum Skills Quantum skills are skills that enable teachers to think dynamically and intuitively (Coccia et al., 2022). The characteristics, capabilities, and tasks of teachers must be different from the traditional type in order to be able to develop and expand the space of their organizations and guide and lead it towards success and excellence (Salimi & Javidi Porkhabaz, 2022). Types of Quantum Skills The first quantum skill is quantum seeing. The power and ability to see purposefully is based on the logic that reality is inherently mindset that emerges according to the expectations and beliefs of the observer. The second skill is quantum reasoning, which refers to the ability to think in a contradictory way, and stems from research in quantum physics, stating that the world often works in an irrational and paradoxical way (Surov & Melnikova, 2024). Another quantum skill is quantum sense, which is the ability to sense the living and vital, based on the logic that humans, like other beings in the universe, are faced with the same quanta and are therefore subject to the universal laws of energy excitation. The ability to sense quantum enables managers to have a good inner sense. Quantum understanding is another quantum skill that is derived from the ability to find creative and intuitive ways, from the field of quantum theory (Islami & Wiltsche, 2025). Quantum action, the ability to act in a responsible manner, based on the quantum content of the connection and the by-product of non-local (distributed) causes, is also a quantum skill (Hasanovic et al., 2022). Finally, the ability to establish a permanent relationship, which recognizes the relational nature of the world, is also a quantum skill that enables managers to own their own feelings and attribute them to others (Greinert et al., 2024). Consequences of developing quantum skills in teachers: The emergence of these skills in teachers can cause a change in the model of thought and, as a result, a change in the leadership model and structure of schools and the organization of the educational system, and help these organizations to develop and expand their international competition and education with appropriate efforts and improve their social cooperation (Noroozi Ziarat & Esmaeilishad, 2022). Similarly, the existence of quantum skills in teachers, by affecting the ethics and behavior of sharing knowledge, causes the creative creation of an atmosphere of knowledge and thought transfer among managers and teachers, and in turn, promotes trust and belief in the organization and management among teachers (Geok Soh Wan & Mohamad Bin, 2021). Also, the use of quantum management skills in the educational system leads to its transformation into an organization that is constantly changing and evolving, agile and free from borders, in which creativity and information flow freely. In these organizations, great emphasis is placed on connections so that through decentralization and the use of self-governing structures and the use of vertical, horizontal and diagonal organizational connections, the communication process in the organization will be facilitated and knowledge transfer and expertise promotion in the organization will be helped (Salimi et al., 2016). Research Methodology The present study is applicable in terms of its purpose, and exploratory research in terms of data collection. It is also a mixed (qualitative-quantitative) research based on the inductive deductive philosophy. The statistical population of the research consists of experts of secondary school teachers in Isfahan province, 26 of whom selected by purposive sampling and based on the principle of theoretical adequacy. The data collection tool in the qualitative part is an interview, the validity and reliability of which was confirmed by content validity and theoretical validity and the intra-coder and inter-coder reliability methods. The data collection tool in the quantitative part is a questionnaire, the validity and reliability of which was confirmed using content validity and test-retest reliability. Qualitative data were analyzed using content analysis method and MaxQDA software, and quantitative data were analyzed using fuzzy cognitive map method. Research findings In this study, the results can be presented in the quantitative and qualitative parts. The results of the qualitative part indicate the types of quantum skills of teachers. Accordingly, quantum skills of teachers include 7 types of skills: quantum thinking, quantum cognition, quantum action, quantum existence, quantum feeling, quantum seeing, and quantum trust. Also, the results of the quantitative part of the research include measuring the importance and prioritization of the types of quantum skills of teachers. Accordingly, the most important quantum skills of teachers were identified as the skill and ability to act responsibly, the power to transform feeling, performance, and cognition from an internal to an external state, maintaining a positive internal feeling regardless of external events, breaking out of a limited and linear state towards students, and using inner wisdom to discover innovative win-win solutions.  Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of identifying the types of quantum skills of teachers. Regarding the consistency of the present study with the research conducted in this field, it should be said that the results of the present study in intuitive insight dimension are consistent with the findings of the Laszlo (2020). In the communication dimension, the findings of the present study are consistent with the results of Razi & Nadi (2022). At the organizational level, the findings of the study are also consistent with the results of Hadizadeh et al. (2021). Based on the results of this study, the following suggestions are made: Providing feedback to teachers Assigning the responsibility of continuous analysis of work to all students in order to implement and develop teaching methods Holding psychological training courses for teachers in the field of recognizing and applying emotion management and maintaining real and deep positive emotions Formulating ethical principles and requirements in a precise and transparent manner by school administrators Participating in scientific seminars

Education Management

Providing a model to explain and apply coaching for school administrators

Volume 7, Issue 2, Summer 2025, Pages 159-186

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2024.461845.1376

Fatemeh Mohebbinejad, soheila Hossainpour, Majid Mohamadi

Abstract Abstract
The aim of this study is to provide a model for explaining and applying coaching for school administrators. This research is qualitative. The research population includes academic experts, experts at the management levels of education and training, and school administrators. Based on the purposive and accessible sampling method, after a semi-structured interview with 15 people, theoretical saturation was achieved and the interview was stopped. Validity in this study achieved through consultants and experts in the field of educational management; and to determine reliability, the research colleague confirmation strategy was used; and accordingly, validity and reliability were confirmed. The analysis method used in the present study was the content analysis method, which was carried out using Maxqda software version 20. Based on the results of the interviews, 25 themes were identified in the form of 8 concepts of strategic human resource management (employee participation, empowerment, etc.), organizational health (employee responsibility and organizational trust), organizational improvement (employee training, educational planning, etc.), knowledge management (sharing, dissemination, and organization of knowledge), organizational support (management of friendly relationships, organizational empathy, etc.), organizational communication management (strengthening communication skills and improving intra-organizational interactions), and organizational ambidexterity (emphasis on organizational productivity, strengthening creativity, and organizational flexibility). Accordingly, it is suggested that school administrators consider the model developed in this study as a criterion for their work in order to improve their management in schools.
Introduction
The continuity and survival of any society requires that its set of beliefs, values, behaviors, attitudes, knowledge, and skills be transferred to new generations. The mechanism of this transfer is education and training. One of the important pillars of education, which is actually the main institution for providing the necessary training, is the school (Taghiani et al, 2023). Effective school management and leadership play a vital role in improving the quality of teaching and learning in the educational environment (Blackmore et al, 2024). One of the main reasons always been raised about poor school results is the inability of principals to have the necessary skills and training to properly manage and lead the school (Matthew, 2021). One of the important variables for improving human resource management, including school management, is coaching. However, unlike training, which usually involves a group of people and has a time limit, coaching is a focused and individual method that can be implemented at any time and every day. Also, unlike some forms of training that are immediate and fleeting, coaching has a lasting and long-term impact on the individual and the organization (Jones & Newland, 2022). Organizational coaching is a process that aims to increase the profitability of the entire organization, strengthen the professional skills of managers and employees, and create job satisfaction and success in the employees of that organization (Park et al., 2020). The role of the education system in the growth and progress of societies is outstanding and undeniable (Mohammadi et al., 2024); for this purpose, education as one of the vital areas of society, given the fundamental role it plays in educating young generations and providing the country's human resources, requires the use of effective and up-to-date management systems. Therefore, developing and presenting an appropriate coaching model for school administrators seems necessary and even inevitable. Accordingly, the present study seeks to answer the basic question: what the coaching model for school administrators is like and how it can be applied in schools?

Theoretical Framework
School Management
Among educational institutions, education plays an important role in society, with a very old background; and for better education, the management system in education is of great importance. Therefore, among the types of management in education, school management is the most important, most effective and most delicate type of management (Laleh et al, 2023). School administrators face many challenges such as limited resources, diverse and extensive needs, diverse teachers and students, less applicable educational content, poor development of a participatory culture, etc. Therefore, developing the skills of school administrators is necessary and inevitable so that they can guide schools towards professional and specialized educational organizations, and pave the way for the growth and development of society (Ponsombut et al, 2014). Human resources are the most important and vital resource in today's organizations, and, compared to competing organizations, these resources can maintain and enhance the organization's position or cause it to decline. (Toyama et al, 2023) Today, education and its management are considered an important factor in the development of countries, and efficient and effective management in education and training organizations can improve teachers' job satisfaction, create a strong bond between parents and students, strengthen the parent-teacher association, reduce academic dropout, promote innovation and creativity, flourish students' talents, and achieve optimal utilization of human resources (Montecinos et al, 2018). Today, the goal of school management is not only to manage, organize, supervise, guide, and discipline, but in addition to them, the lofty goal of school management is to realize professional ethics and create an environment for growth and development. (Emamdoust et al, 2020).
Coaching
In the 1950s, coaching was first introduced to the management field by Mis (2008), who initially defined it as a management tool for guiding and developing employees (Gregory & Levy, 2016). In recent years, coaching has emerged as a significant development intervention in schools in countries such as Australia, the United Kingdom and the United States; and is used to help develop managers, teachers and students while supporting school improvement and development (Butler, 2024). The International Coaching Federation defines coaching as: “Coaching is an ongoing partnership between a coach and a client in which the coach helps the client to achieve desired outcomes in their personal or professional lives by engaging them in thought and awakening their inner creativity” (Kameron & Ebrahimi, 2017). Another goal of coaching is to draw solutions to problems from within the coach, thus enabling the coach to find appropriate solutions to the issues presented to them (Butler, 2024). A coaching manager is a manager who uses coaching methods in his daily affairs and in his communication with subordinate employees, and the key element of this is, compared to other managers, the way he communicates with employees (Unnu, 2020).
Research Methodology
This research is fundamental in terms of purpose, and exploratory in terms of data collection. The research was conducted qualitatively. Qualitative data was collected using library studies and semi-structured interviews. The statistical population of this research included academic experts, experts at the management levels of education and training, and school administrators; and the theoretical saturation index of data was used to determine the sample size. The sampling method was purposeful and accessible method. By this process, 15 experts were identified as sufficient for interviews.
Research findings
Data analysis was conducted using thematic analysis method and MAXQDA 20 software. After finalization and consensus of the participants in the final stage, the coaching model for school administrators was developed based on the answers to the research questions. This model was provided to experts and finalized after making amendments. Based on the results of the interviews, 25 themes were identified in the form of 8 concepts of strategic human resource management (employee participation, empowerment, etc.), organizational health (employee responsibility and organizational trust), organizational improvement (employee training, educational planning, etc.), knowledge management (sharing, dissemination and organization of knowledge), organizational support (management of friendly relationships, organizational empathy, etc.), organizational communication management (strengthening communication skills and improving intra-organizational interactions), and organizational ambidexterity (emphasis on organizational productivity, strengthening creativity and organizational flexibility).
Conclusion
The increasing need of organizations for organizational coaching because of reasons such as stagnation due to poor organizational performance and the importance of reducing organizational costs, the lack of responsiveness of conventional training such as face-to-face and one-sided virtual classes and the need to pay attention to feedback and student-centered training, the prevalence of coaching in organizations and the importance of expertise and analysis in them, the purification of organizations from weak forces and the increasing reliance on valuable forces, the increase in competition and speed in business and the need for change leaders in organizations and individuals adaptable to change, the influx of young and talented people into organizations and the importance of their development needs (talent management), the emergence of the sublime idea of ​​knowledge management and the importance of preserving and expanding organizational knowledge, and the increasing importance of the issue of transforming knowledge into wisdom as a management-cultural category, have led to the importance of the role of coaching in organizations. The results of this study are consistent with the results of the research of Dastgerdi et al., (2021), Qarlaqi et al., (2021), and Ellinger and Ellinger (2020).
According to the results obtained, the following suggestions are made:
- In the organizational decision-making process, the ability of employees should be used more, and a kind of organizational coaching process should be carried out with their participation in important organizational processes.
- Using the organizational coaching process, efforts should be made to increase and improve the adaptability of individuals and employees of the organization.
- Encouraging individuals to carry out activities and team work (becoming extroverted) can increase the spirit of responsibility of individuals and contribute to organizational health.
- Increasing employees' information about coaching using scientific and applicable conferences and workshops.

Human Resource Management

Analyzing the dimensions and components of the developed model of competency-based successor training in education-oriented organizations with a meta-composite approach

Volume 5, Issue 4, Winter 2024, Pages 193-220

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2024.384659.1160

mahdi khodaparast, Davood Kiakojouri, seyyed javad mortazavi amiri, Syed Ahmad Jafari Kalarijani

Abstract Abstract
The purpose of this research is to analyze the dimensions and components of the developed model of successor training based on competence in education-oriented organizations with a meta-composite approach. This research is applicable in terms of purpose, qualitative in terms of the method of data collection, and with a meta-composite approach in terms of the research implementation method. The statistical population of the research includes all studies conducted in the period of time for Latin research from 1990 to 2022, and for Persian research from 2005 to 2022. In this regard, 282 researches were evaluated in the field of the subject and ultimately 41 articles were selected purposefully. Extraction of components and indicators was obtained from background investigation and theoretical foundations, and then coding was used for analysis. To analyze the data, the meta-composite method was used, and then through open, axial, and selective coding; and MAXQDA 2020 software was used. The results showed that 7 codes, 53 concepts, and 24 categories were determined and identified, which codes include key competences and abilities, determination of successor training policy, value foundation, organizational support, strategic planning in the field of successor training, identification of talents and forming a fund of talents, training and improvement of talents.
Extended abstract
Introduction
Today, all organizations compete with each other to attract qualified human resources, and as soon as these people feel that their merits are not recognized and appreciated in an organization, they choose another organization to work; therefore, identifying, recruiting, cultivating, promoting and maintaining competent human resources with the aim of optimizing the organization's ability to face new changes is undoubtedly the main concern of today's organizations (Aref & Moradi Shirazi, 2017). Successor training as a system in the field of human resources management creates the confidence in the organization that the circulation of human resources does not have an erosive and destructive effect on the organization. In simpler terms, succession management and planning assures the organization that it will have the right and competent employees to take on the jobs they deserve and at the right time. Also, successor training planning can be seen as an attempt to design a plan for an appropriate and competent number of managers and employees with key skills in such a way that they will be suitable successors at the time of retirement, death, illness, and promotion of other employees and even new positions that are created in the future plan of the organization (Azar & Khorrami, 2020). Therefore, considering the importance of competencies in formulating the successor training system, the aim of this research is to identify the dimensions and components of the developed model of successor training based on competence in education-oriented organizations in the field of human resources management, which can cause mutual reinforcement between each of the human resource management sub-systems of education-oriented organizations based on merit, which will improve the performance of the organization and establish succession management. Therefore, according to the issues raised, the current research intends to answer the question: what are the dimensions and components of the developed model of competency-based successor training in education-oriented organizations with a meta-composite approach?
 Theoretical Framework
Succession
Successor training is not a secret strategy to quickly replace people in specific positions; it is a systematic process whereby professional and personal development is aligned with the strategic plan to ensure that there are people, with the skills and the right attitudes at the right time, ready to fill any vacant position. Organizational successor training means the transfer of an organization due to the owner's desire to retire or leave the organization for numerous reasons. Succession can include the transfer of position to family members, employees, or outside buyers. Successor training is a flexible, long-term and growing approach in future recruitment. Organizational successor training planning is a type of planning that regularly nurtures both leadership successors and the next generation (Amini Dehaghi et al, 2023).
Amini Dehaghi et al, (2023) conducted a research with the aim of analyzing the phenomenon of managerial successor training in women's championship sports. The model obtained in total included 16 components as the phenomenon of managerial successor training in women's championship sports in two stages of interactionism and structuralism. Therefore, in order to institutionalize successor training in women's sports management, the interests and mindset of women towards managerial positions should be evaluated, the managerial activities of women in sports should be monitored, people inclined to managerial positions should be identified, and finally the performance mrthod of women in managerial positions to provide positive feedback and strengthen positive image of women's management should be reviewed and reflected.
Rahimi & Sadeqiarani (2023) conducted a research with the aim of designing and explaining the successor training management system in Kashan water and sewage industry. The type of research was applicable in terms of purpose, and qualitative-quantitative in terms of measurement. This research was done in several phases; the first two of which were qualitative, and the rest were quantitative. The first phase included the identification of competencies from university scientific sources as well as water and sewage company resources, and eighty competencies were identified in this phase. In the second phase, the identified indicators were evaluated by the managers and elites of the water and sewage company, and the competency model of the managers of the water and sewage company was designed by using the Delphi research method; with 33 competency indicators, which includes individual, managerial and occupational. In the third phase, according to forty management positions in the company, the competencies identified for prioritization were polled, and prioritization was done for each position by using the TOPSIS multi-criteria technique. Also, the general situation of Kashan Abfa Company based on individual competencies and management-organizational competencies shows that Kashan Abfa has the highest score in the competencies of belonging and organizational loyalty, moral intelligence, and work commitment; and the lowest score in the competency of successor training and people management, performance management and project management.
Research Methodology
This research is applicable in terms of purpose, qualitative in terms of the method of data collection, and with a meta-composite approach in terms of the research implementation method. The statistical population of the research includes all studies conducted in the period of time for Latin research from 1990 to 2022, and for Persian research from 2005 to 2022. In this regard, 282 researches were evaluated in the field of the subject and ultimately 41 articles were selected purposefully. Extraction of components and indicators was obtained from background investigation and theoretical foundations, and then coding was used for analysis.
 
Research findings
To analyze the data, the meta-composite method was used, and then through open, axial, and selective coding; and MAXQDA 2020 software was used. The results showed that 7 codes, 53 concepts, and 24 categories were determined and identified, which codes include key competences and abilities, determination of successor training policy, value foundation, organizational support, strategic planning in the field of successor training, identification of talents and forming a fund of talents, training and improvement of talents.
Conclusion
The present research was conducted with the aim of analyzing the dimensions and components of the developed model of competency-based successor training in education-oriented organizations with a meta-composite approach. According to the obtained results, the present research is aligned with the results of Amini Dehaghi et al, (2023), Rahimi & Sadeqiarani (2023), Ismailzadeh et al, (2023), Mohammadi Dayani et al, (2022), Milaninejad & Jalalundi (2023), Janahmadigol et al, (2022), Teimouri et al, (2022), Bano et al, (2022), Ghazali et al, (2021), and Dahlan Gunawan et al, (2021). Ghazali et al, (2021) showed that the cultivation of talent along with competence in higher education institution is an important part of successor training planning. Even if an institution has a well-organized plan, successor training planning will not progress smoothly unless the institution has a willing, able, and fully prepared successor. Competency-based successor training planning models provide a blueprint for building the necessary competencies now and in the future, as well as a benchmark for assessing academic leadership requirements.
According to the obtained results, the following suggestions are provided:

Clarity and transparency of the organization's strategy regarding the successor training plan in such a way that the capabilities, skills and competence of the managers who must realize the goals of the programs can be extracted and determined, which of course requires a positive and optimistic view and understanding by the senior managers of the organization about this matter.
Using the positive and successful records and experiences of other organizations in implementing new ideas and techniques of successor training management in recent years, such as the proposal system of Kaizen problem solving teams and the appointment of middle and senior managers within the organization.

Education Management

Design and Validation of a Systems Thinking Curriculum Model for the First Year of High School Based on the Heutagogy Approach

Volume 7, Issue 3, Autumn 2025, Pages 363-384

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.544857.1571

Maysam Haji Manochehri, Nahid Shafiee, Amirhossein Mehdizadeh, Alireza Araghieh

Abstract Abstract The present study was conducted with the aim of designing a systems thinking curriculum model with the heutagogy approach in the first year of secondary education. This research was applicable in terms of its purpose, and mixed with an exploratory design in terms of its implementation method, carried out in two qualitative and quantitative parts. In the qualitative part, 8 experts in educational sciences and psychology were interviewed using purposive sampling and until theoretical saturation. The data were examined using the content analysis method, and basic and organizing themes were extracted. In the quantitative part, the statistical population included first year secondary education teachers in Alborz province in the academic year 2023-2024. Sampling was done in a multi-stage cluster manner and the data collection tool was a researcher-made questionnaire derived from qualitative findings. The validity of the tool was confirmed by the internal consistency method and reliability with Cronbach's alpha of 0.98. Descriptive indices, single-group T-test, and structural equation modeling with SPSS and Amos software were used to analyze the data. The results showed that 26 basic themes were identified in 7 organizing themes in the "curriculum" dimension, 15 basic themes were identified in 5 organizing themes in the "implementation requirements" dimension, and 23 basic themes were identified in 8 organizing themes in the "implementation effects" dimension. Also, from the teachers' perspective, the most importance was given to foresight, process management, and understanding complexity, respectively among the dimensions of the heutagogic systems thinking curriculum. The functional dimensions, understanding educational and structural relationships were the most important in the implementation requirements, and the growth of academic capabilities, promotion of students' types of thinking, and improvement of teachers' teaching competence were the most prominent results in the implementation effects. Introduction The concept of learning has changed in the information age and how learning is considered, and this new learning emphasizes the development of learners' ability to transform information into knowledge. The new era demands new education. Education appropriate to the present era must be based on customer orientation. To meet this need, a paradigm called the learning-centered paradigm is proposed in which, instead of focusing on providing educational materials, attention is focused on meeting the needs of the learner. In this approach, learning is nonlinear, multidimensional, and networked and is formed based on the needs, interests, previous experiences, and cultural and social context of the individual. From this perspective, learning focuses more on the development of capabilities rather than just skills. Capabilities are a combination of knowledge, skills, attitudes, and the ability to use them in new and complex situations (Ghalandari et al., 2023). Saeedavi et al. (2024) conducted a study titled "Identifying and Explaining the Strategic Facilitating Factors of Hyatagogy in Managerial Education" using a descriptive-analytical method and a researcher-made questionnaire. The results showed that six strategic factors including learning leadership, flexible executive-educational structures, creating an electronic infrastructure and platform, managers' ability to use electronic equipment, creating an organizational climate for knowledge sharing and feedback are among the most important factors facilitating the implementation of the hyatagogy approach, which explain 64.75% of the total variance. Nikmohammadi et al. (2023) conducted a study titled "Identifying the Dimensions and Components of Hyatagogy Curriculums in the Second Period of Secondary Education" using a descriptive-analytical method. The findings showed that the main dimensions of the heutagogic curriculum include flexibility in goals and programs, comprehensive goal-setting framework, production of applicable and skill-based content, self-determined learner, creative collaborative participation, heutagogic teacher skills, technological classroom, systems thinking, critical thinking, and heutagogic assessment. Research Method In this study, a mixed method with an exploratory design and an instrument development model was used, so that data were collected sequentially and with equal importance through a combination of qualitative and quantitative data. In the qualitative section, the research community included 8 experts and university professors in the fields of curriculum planning and educational psychology, which was done with purposive sampling. The validity of the qualitative findings was measured with the criteria of reliability, transferability, relevance, and confirmation. In the quantitative part, a questionnaire consisting of 64 items in 20 dimensions and 4 main factors was designed based on the indicators obtained from the qualitative phase and distributed online among 178 secondary school teachers. Responses were collected on a 5-point Likert scale. The validity of the questionnaires was confirmed by experts and their reliability was examined with Cronbach's alpha coefficient, which was 0.96 for the variables of the curriculum and implementation requirements and 0.97 for the implementation effects. The collected data were analyzed using SPSS software and descriptive and inferential statistics methods, and Amos software was used to draw the model. Findings The research findings showed that the curriculum model of systems thinking with a heutagogy approach includes the components of structural reform, process management, modern education, research, application of technology, foresight, and understanding of complexities; and these elements synergistically increase the quality of learning and self-management of students. Also, the implementation requirements included structural, legal, functional, holistic aspects, and understanding of educational relationships; and the effects of program implementation were identified, including the growth of students' social, psychological, and thinking capabilities. The results showed that reforming the educational structure and managing processes with student participation and self-reflection, modern education and teacher facilitation, the use of technology and a research environment, and a focus on foresight provide the basis for the realization of systems thinking. The findings are consistent with previous studies in the field of heutagogy and constructivist education and show that the combination of these approaches strengthens the agency, self-management, and analytical and systemic skills of students. Discussion and Conclusion The results showed that “educational structure reform” through decentralization, structural reengineering, and constructivist design is the main prerequisite for institutionalizing systems thinking in schools. This approach transforms the structure of education from hierarchical models to a participatory and dynamic system. The present result is consistent with the findings of Saeedavi et al. (2024) who considered structural flexibility and learning leadership as strategic factors for implementing the heutagogy approach. It is also consistent with the results of Nikmohammadi et al. (2023) who introduced “flexibility in goals and program management” as essential components of the heutagogy classroom. Therefore, structural reform not only contributes to the equitable distribution of power in decision-making, but also provides a platform for the emergence of student self-determination and agency. Managing educational processes centered on student participation, self-reflection, independence, and choice was a key element of the proposed model. This component is deeply linked to the philosophy of heutagogy, because in it the learner is responsible for his or her own learning path. The findings are in line with the results of Ebili et al. (2021), who considered self-learning and self-direction as central components in e-learning platforms. It is also consistent with Handayani et al. (2022), who showed that heutagogy increases the self-efficacy and independence of learners. As a result, managing processes in a participatory and open manner can strengthen the spirit of self-management and feedback in the teaching-learning process. Modern education in this model includes components such as teacher facilitator, holistic view, active teaching, and flexible content. This finding is consistent with the results of Alfares et al. (2024) and Alzubi et al. (2024) who introduced the role of the teacher in constructivist education as “guide and facilitator”. In this study, the emphasis on interaction, feedback, and learning design based on the real needs of the learner creates a synergistic approach between systems thinking and heutagogy. Therefore, modern education plays a fundamental role in transforming the classroom into a self-organizing, dynamic, and multidimensional environment in which the teacher is no longer just a source of knowledge, but also a facilitator of learning. The results showed that creating a digital research environment and research foresight are effective paths in realizing systems thinking. The findings are consistent with the study of Goode et al. (2023) who introduced research-based learning as a factor in increasing students’ analytical and problem-solving abilities. It also has a clear coherence with the view of Nikmohammadi et al. (2023), who considered “research and learner agency” as key components of heutagogy. In this model, research is not simply a scientific activity but also a tool for cultivating a networked and multidimensional view of phenomena. The use of mobile learning technologies and virtual scientific networking is a requirement of the systems thinking curriculum. This finding is in line with the research of Ebili et al. (2021), who emphasized the role of technology in enhancing self-learning and self-direction. In the context of heutagogy, technology is not only a teaching tool but also a platform for systemic interactions and continuous feedback. This allows students to practice thinking, analysis, and modeling through online platforms. The present model emphasizes teaching foresight skills, teachers’ capacity for future-oriented thinking, and creating developmental thinking in students. These findings are consistent with the research of Shafiey et al. (2021), who introduced a future-oriented understanding of the difficult but crucial components of learning systems thinking. In this regard, combining heutagogy with foresight allows learners to see themselves as participants in the design of their educational future, rather than simply consumers of knowledge. Teachers’ understanding of complex environments and their holistic view of relationships within the education system were important findings of the research. This is consistent with the findings of Yaylor et al. (2020), who considered systems thinking to be a multilevel process involving sensitivity, literacy, and capability.

Education Management

Designing a model for using artificial intelligence in learning for elementary school students

Volume 7, Issue 2, Summer 2025, Pages 443-467

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.547563.1574

Akram Heidarian, Hamid Shafizadeh, Narges Shariatmadari

Abstract Abstract
The present study was conducted with the aim of designing a model for applying artificial intelligence in elementary school students' learning. This study was applicable in terms of its purpose, and mixed and exploratory in terms of the type of data; in such a way that the qualitative part was conducted using the paradigmatic grounded theory method and the quantitative part was conducted using a survey method. Participants in the qualitative part included academic experts and scholars from the Ministry of Education selected through conscious sampling and the snowball method; and in the quantitative part, 319 education managers and elementary school principals in Tehran were determined based on the Cochran formula. Data collection in both parts was conducted using the field method; semi-structured interviews were used in the qualitative part and a researcher-made questionnaire was used in the quantitative part. The validity and reliability of the instruments were confirmed in both parts. Qualitative data were analyzed by theoretical coding, and quantitative data by confirmatory factor analysis. The findings showed that the AI ​​application model consists of 19 components and 106 indicators in the form of six dimensions of the paradigm model. In this model, the central phenomenon includes learning enrichment and learning individualization; causal factors include technical infrastructure, intelligent support, and technology growth in the family; contextual factors include learning management, learning content, and teacher capabilities; intervening factors include ethics, information security, and educational technology; strategies include personalization of education, feedback, intelligent evaluation, content quality, and learning assistant; and outcomes include deep learning, improving teacher efficiency, high-quality evaluation, and educational innovation. Finally, the obtained model was quantitatively evaluated with confirmatory factor analysis, and the fit indices showed that the model was confirmed.
Introduction
The rapid advancement of computing and information processing methods has accelerated the expansion of AI applications, with the aim of enabling computers to perform their tasks by simulating intelligent human behaviors such as inference, analysis, and decision-making (Duan, Edwards & Dwivedi et al., 2019).
AI in education has great potential to enhance learning, teaching, and assessment by suggesting or providing personalized or tailored learning to learners, developing teachers’ understanding of the learning process, and providing anywhere-anytime search engines and immediate feedback (Xia et al., 2022). AI in learning helps learners actively construct their own knowledge by exploring and manipulating elements of the learning environment (Randhawa et al., 2020).
AI helps to increase the quality of education and not only assists in the learning process but also provides facilities such as tutoring, grading, lesson planning, and feedback to students (Mondal et al., 2019). Timms stated that collaborative robots are used in collaboration with teachers to teach everyday tasks such as spelling, pronunciation, and adjusting students’ abilities (Timms et al., 2016). Artificial intelligence helps personalize content to meet the demand for education, so it plays a significant role in the organization of course materials (Mondal et al., 2019). Therefore, it can be said that it is one of the most important phenomena in education that will be used more in the future (Rezaei et al., 2024). According to the US Department of Education, it is estimated that artificial intelligence in education in this country will increase by 47.5% from 2017 to 2021, which is expected to see a significant growth in companies developing artificial intelligence in education (Liang et al., 2020). During the emergence of Corona, educational technologies, especially artificial intelligence, were used in many countries, but in Iran, very little of artificial intelligence has entered the field of education. Despite the fact that the use of modern educational and training equipment and technologies in line with the goals of education has been considered in the document on the fundamental transformation of education, artificial intelligence has been taken for granted; and only education and training, teachers, and students use virtual spaces as modern educational technologies; while artificial intelligence has spread around the world and provides significant help to teachers and students. Accordingly, the researcher in this study seeks to answer the question: What is the model for using artificial intelligence in learning for elementary school students in Tehran province?
Theoretical foundations
Infrastructure and technological background
Educational developments based on artificial intelligence require appropriate technical infrastructure and access to modern technologies for families. Infrastructure includes servers and network storage, educational software and applications, appropriate bandwidth, multimedia tools, and information processing equipment that enable smart education and active student interaction (Li et al., 2020). In addition, parental mental preparedness, family economic and cultural status, and the use of artificial intelligence tools in daily life are effective contexts for the acceptance and use of smart systems (Chen et al., 2020).
Smart support enables access to content at any time and place, personalized services, and active student interaction with content, complementing the teacher's role in the education process, which is in line with the active learning theory (Rezavan et al., 2022).
Learning Management and Educational Content
Learning management involves identifying student needs, continuously monitoring the learning process, providing feedback and continuous evaluation; and improves the quality of education (Tsai et al., 2019). Learning content should be in line with educational objectives, utilize interactive tools such as games and videos, and enhance students’ academic achievement. Teachers’ ability to use artificial intelligence for teaching and content production has a direct impact on the effectiveness of education (Zhu et al., 2020).
Content personalization strategies, providing immediate feedback, and intelligent assessment facilitate individual and active learning and take into account individual student differences (Popenici & Kerr, 2017).
Intervenors and Ethics in Smart Education
The use of smart technologies in education is associated with ethical and security considerations. Respecting privacy, trustworthiness in the use of content, and developing security infrastructures are critical components (Livingstone, 2012). Educational technology, including artificial intelligence tools, media, and virtual reality technology, acts as an intermediary between the student and the learning process and enables continuous and personalized learning through timely intervention and resource management.
Implications of Smart Learning
The use of artificial intelligence leads to deep learning, improved teacher efficiency, accurate evaluation, and educational innovation. Deep learning is possible by strengthening cognitive skills, increasing the ability to analyze and solve problems, active student participation, and repeating material until complete learning. By continuously monitoring student progress and utilizing smart evaluation, teachers can provide timely corrections and feedback, and improve learning outcomes by combining face-to-face and virtual methods and producing multimedia content (Li et al., 2020).
Sun (2024) examined various uses of artificial intelligence in education in a study titled "Applications of Artificial Intelligence in Education." The research method of this study was a review and analysis. The results showed that AI can improve personalized learning, adaptive learning, virtual reality technology, and teaching assessment, and change the traditional learning system by providing new teaching methods and assessment systems.
Alam et al. (2024) analyzed the future role of AI in education in a study titled "Future Applications and Prospects of AI in Education". The research method of this study was analytical and descriptive. The results showed that AI, with active participation in data analysis, virtual classrooms, adaptive assessments, and personalized learning, can create more effective and efficient educational experiences and requires the participation of educators and legislators to fully realize this potential.
Research Methodology
This research is applicable in terms of purpose, and mixed exploratory (qualitative and quantitative) in terms of data. The qualitative stage was conducted based on systematic data, and the statistical population included 19 academic experts, educational technology specialists, and education managers, of which 16 interviews were used as the basis for the analysis. The quantitative phase was conducted as a cross-sectional survey with a statistical population of 1880 school principals and educational districts in Tehran, and 319 people were selected by stratified random sampling. Qualitative data were collected through semi-structured interviews and library studies, and quantitative data were collected with a researcher-made questionnaire consisting of 19 components and 106 indicators. The validity and reliability of the tools were confirmed by test-retest methods, model reliability test, and inter-coder test, respectively, at 80–86%
Research findings
The research findings showed that the application of artificial intelligence in elementary school students' learning has several basic dimensions that interact with each other in a systematic way. On one hand, technical infrastructure and intelligent support enable active, personalized, and continuous learning, and on the other hand, teacher empowerment and content management ensure that the education process proceeds with quality and effectiveness. Ethical considerations and information security, along with educational technologies, as intervening factors, ensure the safe and sustainable use of systems. Content personalization strategies, feedback, smart assessment, and learning assistants enhance students' individual and collaborative learning, leading to outcomes such as deep learning, educational innovation, improved teacher effectiveness, and quality assessment. 
Discussion and Conclusion
The research findings show that implementing smart learning in Tehran elementary schools requires appropriate technical infrastructure and families’ access to modern technologies. Servers, bandwidth, software, and multimedia tools enable smart learning and active student interaction with content (Chen et al., 2020; Rezavan et al., 2022). The readiness and support of teachers and families, especially a positive attitude towards educational technologies, play a key role in the success of smart learning (Valeri et al., 2024; Alam et al., 2024).
In learning and educational content management, identifying student needs, providing continuous feedback, and regular evaluation improve the quality of education (Tsai et al., 2019). The use of interactive tools and multimedia content enhances students’ active participation and academic achievement (Zhu et al., 2020; Sun, 2024). Teachers’ ability to utilize AI for teaching and content production also has a direct impact on learning effectiveness (Chen et al., 2022).
Ethical and security considerations, including protecting students’ privacy and developing security infrastructure, are essential for the successful implementation of smart technologies (Wang et al., 2024; Omar et al., 2024). Educational technologies, through media, content production tools, and virtual reality, enable interactive and personalized learning and reduce teachers’ workload (Sun, 2024).
The implications of using AI in learning include enrichment, individualization, and active learning. Providing diverse examples, simulating real-world situations, and purposeful exercises facilitates deep and active learning (Valeri et al., 2024; Sun, 2024). Content personalization strategies, immediate feedback, and intelligent assessment enable effective learning that is responsive to individual differences (Chen et al., 2022; Zhu et al., 2020).
Finally, AI can help improve the quality of learning, increase student engagement, improve teacher efficiency, and innovate in education (Alam et al., 2024; Wang et al., 2024). This technology enables a more effective, efficient, and personalized learning experience for students.

Keywords Cloud

Related Journals