An Investigation into the Sociological Factors Influencing the Formation of Scientific Stagnation among Faculty Members of Universities in Mazandaran Province

Gholipour, , Majedeh

doi:10.22034/jmep.2026.385000.1167

An Investigation into the Sociological Factors Influencing the Formation of Scientific Stagnation among Faculty Members of Universities in Mazandaran Province

Document Type : Original Article (Qualitative)

Author

, Majedeh Gholipour

Department of Social Sciences, Babol Branch, Islamic Azad University, Babol, Iran.

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.385000.1167

Abstract

Abstract
The present study aims to examine the sociological factors influencing the formation of academic stagnation among faculty members of universities in Mazandaran Province. In terms of design, this research is qualitative and based on the grounded theory approach. The study population consisted of 21 faculty members from universities in Mazandaran Province, who were selected through purposive sampling using the data saturation technique. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews. Data analysis was conducted using the grounded theory method.
Following data analysis and coding across three stages—open coding, axial coding, and selective coding—the findings were categorized into 100 concepts, 12 subcategories, 6 core categories, and one central category titled “The Structure–Agency Context of Occupational Plateauing.”
Based on the central category, which represents the condition of plateauing among faculty members in universities of Mazandaran Province, it can be concluded that plateauing is a condition shaped by both individual and personal characteristics of faculty members (such as personal experience, personality traits, type of self-concept, and individual habits) and organizational characteristics of their workplace (including the dominant discourse within the university and the prevalence of self-centered attitudes), as well as, to some extent, the broader external environment surrounding the academic sphere. This condition manifests and intensifies within these contexts, assuming a particular form (structural or content-related).
Extended abstract
Introduction
The university, as a subsystem of the higher education system, is an institution with specific missions and functions defined within the broader responsibilities of higher education. Although the history of university development in Iran shows that the first model (teaching-oriented) emerged in the late nineteenth century, the second generation (research-oriented) formed in the early twentieth century with an emphasis on knowledge production, and the third generation appeared in the second half of the century after World War II, adding entrepreneurship and the application of knowledge to its missions—hence referred to as the entrepreneurial university (Hakak et al., 2018). This trajectory indicates that the university has been, and still remains, a reference institution, retaining its role as the “voice of society” (Khaniiki, 2017).
Such a transformation has resulted in the perception of the university as a mass-production factory of outputs—outputs that have acquired an identity independent of their producers, while the producers themselves have become alienated from the scientific products they create. Fazeli states: “Among faculty members, there is nearly no critical reflective perspective regarding the role of professors and the extent of their influence on the slow pace of scientific development and the fulfillment of the university’s missions. Today, numerous written discourses are published, yet authentic and innovative intellectual debate platforms are rarely observed” (Fazeli, 2014).
From a structural perspective, Bardwick (2005) distinguishes between two main types of career plateauing—structural and content plateauing—each occurring under specific conditions:
• Structural plateauing: refers to the cessation of opportunities for upward mobility within the organizational hierarchy. This trend intensifies when organizations adopt horizontal structuring, which increases structural plateauing.
• Content plateauing: occurs when individuals experience stagnation due to the nature of their job content. Low-variety, monotonous, and repetitive tasks fall into this category because employees know exactly what is expected of them each day and have nothing new to learn (Vahidi, 2014).
According to Gaines and Jermier, limited opportunities for promotion and rigid rules and regulations give individuals the impression that they are trapped in an unfair system, leading to negative perceptions about their job (Dehghani et al., 2015). Some scholars believe that personal characteristics, such as self-development, can mitigate or eliminate the harmful effects of such structural conditions. Based on the study by Rastegar et al. (2017), self-development influences cognitive and metacognitive knowledge and skills, which may dilute or neutralize the factors that create plateauing conditions. Additionally, psychological capital can reduce negative emotions among teachers.
The present study seeks to answer the following question: What are the sociological factors influencing the formation of academic stagnation among faculty members of universities in Mazandaran Province?
Theoretical Framework
Career Plateauing
Career plateauing is defined as a point in one’s job or profession where the likelihood of further hierarchical promotion becomes very low. Due to changes in organizational environments, one of the most critical issues related to career paths in the coming decade is career plateauing (Chou et al., 2022).
Darling and Cunningham (2023) examined the perceived causes of career plateauing in public service delivery. Their findings revealed that a general picture of the factors contributing to plateauing can be identified in ten themes, grouped into three categories: perceived favoritism and discrimination within the organization (two themes); lack of experience, education, skills, and training (four themes); and competitive skills (four themes).
Changya et al. (2022) conducted a meta-analytic study on career plateauing. Their research examined the correlation between two types of plateauing:

Hierarchical plateauing
Job content plateauing

According to their results, positive relationships were found between plateauing and several antecedent variables, including job adaptability, person–environment fit, psychological capital, and workplace support. Career plateauing was positively associated with counterproductive work behavior, job insecurity, psychological distress, rationality, and turnover intention. However, it was negatively associated with job satisfaction, extra-role performance, in-role performance, job involvement, job satisfaction, mentoring support, organizational commitment, and work commitment. Career plateauing also showed associations with various demographic and contextual variables, including age, gender, work experience, race, and role ambiguity.
Research Methodology
This study was conducted qualitatively using the grounded theory method. The research population consisted of 21 faculty members from universities in Mazandaran Province, selected through purposive sampling using the data saturation technique. Data were collected through semi‑structured interviews.
Research Findings
Data analysis was performed using grounded theory. After analyzing and coding the data across the three stages of open coding, axial coding, and selective coding, the findings were categorized into 100 concepts, 12 subcategories, 6 core categories, and one central category titled “The Structure–Agency Context of Occupational Plateauing.”
Based on this central category, which reflects the plateauing condition of faculty members in universities in Mazandaran Province, it can be inferred that plateauing is a condition shaped by both individual and personal characteristics of faculty members (such as personal experience, personality traits, self-concept, and individual habits) and the organizational characteristics of their workplace (including the dominant discourse within the university and the prevalence of self-centered attitudes), as well as, to some extent, the external environment surrounding the academic sphere. This condition manifests and intensifies within these contexts, taking on a specific form—either structural or content-related.
Research Methodology
This study was conducted qualitatively using the grounded theory method. The research population consisted of 21 faculty members from universities in Mazandaran Province, selected through purposive sampling using the data saturation technique. Data were collected through semi‑structured interviews.
Research Findings
Data analysis was performed using grounded theory. After analyzing and coding the data across the three stages of open coding, axial coding, and selective coding, the findings were categorized into 100 concepts, 12 subcategories, 6 core categories, and one central category titled “The Structure–Agency Context of Occupational Plateauing.”
Based on this central category, which reflects the plateauing condition of faculty members in universities in Mazandaran Province, it can be inferred that plateauing is a condition shaped by both individual and personal characteristics of faculty members (such as personal experience, personality traits, self-concept, and individual habits) and the organizational characteristics of their workplace (including the dominant discourse within the university and the prevalence of self-centered attitudes), as well as, to some extent, the external environment surrounding the academic sphere. This condition manifests and intensifies within these contexts, taking on a specific form—either structural or content-related.

Keywords

Sociological Factors

Academic Stagnation

Occupational Plateauing

University Faculty Members

Subjects

Education Management

Afshar, M. (2013) Lack of professor at university, https://www.khabaronline.ir/detail/501868/2013/11/27 (in Persian)

Abdollahi, B., & Heidari, S. (2009). Factors Related to the Faculty Members' Capacity: A Case Study of Tabriz University, Quarterly Journal of Higher Education, 2. 24-1 (in Persian)

Anthony, G. (2004). Abstract The works of Giddens, translation of Hassan Chavashian, Tehran: Phoenix Publications.

Askari, M., & Adli, F., & Golnar, M. (2016). Identifying Factors Influencing the Knowledge Creation of Faculty Members of Higher Education Institutions", Journal of Marine Science Education. 6. https://civilica.com/doc/665290 (in Persian)

Strauss, A., & Corbin, J. (1998), “ Basics of Qualitative Research ”, Second Edition, London: Sage Publications.

Ahadi, A., & Shirazi, M., & Sadr, Sh., Mojtahedzadeh, R. (2015) "Relationship between faculty members' readiness to change performance in Tehran University of Medical Sciences and their burnout", Iranian Journal of Forensic Medicine, 21(21). 100-125. (in Persian)

Changya, H., & Shihui, Zh., & Yen-Yu, Ch., & Tracy.Lambert, G. (2022). A meta-analytic study of subjective career plateaus. Journal of Vocational Behavior 132:103649. DOI:10.1016/j.jvb.2021.103649

Chou, N. W., & Hsieh, H. M., & Hung, T. K. (2022). The Impact of Person-Job Fit on Job Performance: Job Involvement as Mediator, and Career Plateau as Mediated Moderator. International Journal of Organizational Innovation (Online), 14(3), 115-133.

Clark, B. (1998). Creating entrepreneurial universities: Organizational pathways of transformati- Cox J, Simpson MD. (2016) Exploring the link between self- efficacy, workplace learning and clinical practice.Asia Pac J Cooperative Educ.17(3):215-25.

Darling, S., & Cunningham, B. (2023). "Perceived Causes of Career Plateau in the Public Service," Administrative Sciences, MDPI, vol. 13(3), 1-20, https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci13030073

Dehghani, M., & Javadipour, M., & Islamdost, S. (2015). The Relati onship between Metacognitive and Self-Efficacy of Teachers and their Professional Qualifications, Applied Psychological Research Quarterly, 5(4) 51-68(in Persian)

Farjam, S., & Allahyari, A., & Davali, M. M. (2023). The Effect of Job Adjustment on Career Plateau with Moderating Role of Job Self-Efficacy. Industrial and Organizational Psychology Studies, 9(2), 259-278. doi: 10.22055/jiops.2022.39128.1255.. (in Persian)

Farastkha, M. (2011). post-modernTheory, http://farasatkhah.blogsky.com (in Persian)

Foster P.B., & Shastri, T., & Withane, S. (2004). "The impact of mentoring on Career plateau and turnover intentions of management accountings". Journal of Applied Business Research, 20(4), 33-42.

Fazeli, N. (2014). Cultural History of Modern Iran", Tehran: Humanities and Cultural Studies Institute

Fallahi, K., & Monurian, A. (2008). Investigating the Factors of Elite Migration (Human Capital) and Providing Appropriate Strategies for Preventing this Phenomenon, Quarterly Journal of Knowledge and Development, Vol. 15, No. 24, pp. 136-107 (in Persian)

Hakak, M., & Hezani, S. A., & Shah Siah, N. (2018). Third Generation University is an indispensable necessity for health education. jmed 2018; 13 (1):77-80
URL: http://jmed.ssu.ac.ir/article-1-809-fa.html. (in Persian).

Hu, Ch., & Zhang, Sh., & Chen, Y., & Lambert, T. (2022). A meta-analytic study of subjective career plateaus. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2021.103649 Huaman-Ramirez, R., & Lahlouh, K. (2022). Understanding Career Plateaus and Their Relationship with Coworker Social Support and Organizational Commitment. Public Organization Review, 1- 22. DOI:10.1007/s11115-022-00621-0

Iranzadeh, S., & Bagherzadeh khajeh, M., & Bagernegad, S. (2022). Investigating the effect of job enrichment on reducing staff Plateau (Case study of employees of Bank Melli branches in East Azerbaijan province). Journal of Accounting and Management Vision, 4(53), 63-72.. (in Persian).

Kujala, J., & Lamsa, A.M., & Penttila, K. (2011). Managers’ moral decision-making patterns over time: a multidimensional approach. Journal of Business Ethics; 100(2): 191-207.

Khaniiki, H. (2016). "University must be the voice of civil society", Hamshahri daily. (in Persian)

Lin, Y., & Shin-yih Chin, A., & Lai, Y. (2018). Breach or bridge your career? Understanding the relationship between career plateau and internal employability?. Personnel Review, Vol. 47 Issue: 5, pp.986-1002. DOI:10.1108/PR-04-2017-0101

Mazari, E., & Zamani, M. (2016). The influence of psychological -behavioral mechanisms of self-development (self-regulation, Self-management, Self-leadership and self-directed learning) on human capital, Applied Psychological Research Q.7(3). 39-54. (in Persian)

Mehraban, J. (2021). The mediating role of organizational indifference in the relationship between job burnout and administrative health of education staff in Tabriz. Management and Educational Perspective, 3(1), 55-82. doi: 10.22034/jmep.2021.279133.1054. (in Persian)

Momolejo, F. (2006). Fostering The Development And Implementation Of Principles For Managing The Ethical In Higher Eduaction Institution: An International Comparative Perspective: General Conference, Paris: France.

Naghiloo, Z., & Kotobi, F., & namvar, M. (2022). The Effect of Quality of Work Life on the Career Plateau of Sport Teachers. Educational and Scholastic studies, 11(1), 101-119. doi: 20.1001.1.2423494.1401.11.1.4.6. (in Persian)

Nourshahi, N., & Farasatkhah, M. (2011). A study of component and effective factors on quality of academic life of university faculty members. Institute for Research and Planning in Higher Education. (in Persian)

Norouzi, Kh., & Doustar, M., & Foroughi, N., & Javadi, M. (2013). Elite recruitment strategies in the Iranian higher education system using quality performance enhancement model, 1(4). 20-1

Oppong, S. (2014). Between Bandura and Giddens: structuration theory in social psychological research?”, Psychological Thought, Vol. 7(2), 111-123.

Paryar, G., & Naghizadeh Baghi, M., & Piran Hamlabadi, M. (2022). Investigating the impact of occupational plateauing on the occupational participation of physical education teachers in Ardabil city, the first national conference of sports management with an organizational health approach, Ardabil, https://civilica.com/doc/1544381. (in Persian(

Quayle. j. (2009). teaching ethics To future psychologists:challenges and the Model of An Experience of Acollege Psychology ptofessor In A developing country jurnal of counseling psychology. 22(1). 97-104

Rastegar, A., & Seif, Mh., & Abedini, Y. (2017). Presenting a causal model of relationship between psychological capital and teaching emotions: the mediating role of emotional exhaustion, Applied Psychological Research Quarterly, 7(4), 51-71. (in Persian).

Ricoeur, P. (1976). Interpretation Theory: Discourse and the Surplus of Meaning, Fort Worth, Texas Christian University Press.

Strauss, A., & Corbin, J. (1998), “ Basics of Qualitative Research ”, Second Edition, London: Sage Publications.

Shah Mohammadi, A. (2016) "Iran's Role in the Production of Science Among the Named Countries in the Field of Production of Science and Technology Based on the Size of Articles", http://sinapress.ir/news/print/40740 (in Persian)

Tulaei, N., & Fallah Peesh, A. (2011) Study of the Effect of Inequality on Cooperation, Journal of Social Issues of Iran, Year 2, No. 2.
Saatchi, Mahmoud, 1997, Productivity Psychology, First Edition, Tehran: Publishing. (in Persian)

Talebizidi, A. A., & Rezaei, J. (2009) Investigating the Causes of Migration of Academic Elites from Mazandaran during 2001-2001. Journal of Research Management, Sixth Year, 16. 59-68. (in Persian)

Taleghani, J. (2002). Investigating the Relationship between Behavioral Styles Following the Reconciliation and Performance of Sarcheshmeh Copper Industries, Graduate Thesis, Graduate School, Islamic Azad University, Kerman. (in Persian)

Taghvain, N. (2017) Habermas: Philosophy and University, Mehr News Agency, /www.mehrnews.com/news/3962574/2017/3/6 (in Persian)

Vahidi, M., & Bashir, N, Y., & Rasouli, M. (2013). Investigation of the Impact of Job Characteristics on the Plateau in the Course of Human Capital Promotion", Journal of Management Studies (Improvement and Development), Year Twenty Second. 62-25. (in Persian).

Zibakalam, M, F., & Mohammadi, H. (2014). A Comparative Study of Critical Thinking from the Viewpoint of Robert Ennis and Henry Giroux C onsidering Its Application for the Modification of Teacher Training System, Applied Psychological Research Quarterly, 5(3).19-38. (in Persian)