بررسی تاثیر الگوهای آموزش تلفیقی با روش آموزش سنتی بر خلاقیت دانش‌آموزان

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی (کمی )

نویسندگان

1 کارشناسی ارشد مدیریت آموزشی، گروه مدیریت، دانشکدۀ مدیریت، دانشگاه خوارزمی، تهران، ایران.

2 استادیار مدیریت آموزشی، گروه مدیریت، دانشکدۀ مدیریت، دانشگاه خوارزمی، تهران، ایران.

چکیده

هدف از پژوهش حاضر بررسی تأثیر آموزش تلفیقی در مقایسه با تدریس سنتی در درس فارسی بر خلاقیت دانش آموزان بود. این پژوهش ازلحاظ هدف کاربردی و به روش نیمه آزمایشی با طرح پیش‌آزمون- پس‌آزمون با گروه کنترل انجام شد. جامعه آماری شامل 1012 نفراز دانش آموزان دختر پایه سوم ابتدایی که در سال تحصیلی 1400-1399 مشغول تدریس در مدارس غیردولتی شهرستان سیرجان بودند که 20 نفر به‌عنوان نمونه به‌صورت تصادفی انتخاب شدند که تعداد 10 نفر به‌طور تصادفی و برابر در دو گروه آزمایش و کنترل قرار گرفته‌اند. ابزار جمع‌آوری داده‌ها با استفاده از پرسش‌نامه بوده خلاقیت عابدی بوده که روایی محتوایی آن مورد تأیید متخصصین از جمله استاد راهنما و استاد مشاور قرار گرفت. بررسی مقادیر آلفای کرونباخ نشان می‌دهد که میزان پایایی از حداقل 77/0 برای قابلیت سیالی تا حداکثر 89/0 برای خلاقیت کل به‌دست‌آمده است. نتایج پژوهش نشان داد که روش آموزش تلفیقی بر خلاقیت تأثیر معنادار دارد. سطح معنی‌داری مفروض در این پژوهش مقدار 0.05 انتخاب شد که سطح معنی‌داری آزمون کمتر از 0.05 (0.001>p) به دست آمد و نشان از تفاوت میانگین‌ها و اثربخشی مداخله داشت. میزان خلاقیت بین دانش‌آموزانی که به روش تلفیقی آموزش‌دیده بودند بیشتر از دانش‌آموزانی بود که به روش سنتی آموزش‌دیده بودند. بنابراین پیشنهاد می‌گردد که معلمان مدارس از این روش در خصوص ارتقاء سطح خلاقیت دانش آموزان بهره ببرند.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Investigating the effect of integrated teaching patterns with traditional teaching methods on students' creativity

نویسندگان [English]

  • hoda arabi makiabadi 1
  • hossein abbasiane 2
1 Master of Educational Management, Department of Management, Faculty of Management, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor, Department Of Educational Management, Faculty Of Management, University Of Kharazmi, Tehran, Iran.
چکیده [English]

Extended Abstract
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of integrated education in comparison with traditional teaching, in Persian lessons, on students' creativity. This research was conducted in terms of applied purpose and quasi-experimental method with pre-test-post-test design with control group. The statistical population includes 1012 female students in the third grade of elementary school who were educating in non-governmental schools in Sirjan in the academic year 2020-2021, and 20 students among whom were selected randomly, divided randomly in two and placed in the test group and control group. The data collection tool was Abedi's creativity questionnaire, the content validity of which was approved by experts, including the tutor and the consultant. Examination of Cronbach's alpha values shows that the reliability is obtained from a minimum of 0.77 for fluidity to a maximum of 0.89 for total creativity. The results showed that the method of integrated education has a significant effect on creativity. The assumed significance level in this study was 0.05 and the significance level of the test was less than 0.05 (p <0.001) and showed the difference between the averages and the effectiveness of the intervention. The level of creativity among students who were trained in the integrated method was higher than students who were trained in the traditional method. Therefore, it is suggested that school teachers use this method to promote the level of creativity of students.



 



Introduction
Primary school children are often naturally curious and like to learn things creatively rather than learning information prepared in advance by parents and teachers (Sortiji Okrekaii & Rastegaropur, 2012). Children need curricula that provide them with unpredictable and exciting experiences, and the implementation of such curricula requires creative teachers. It is often thought that creativity is not teachable; but in the absence of evidence that it is inherited, teachers must accept that this skill can be developed in the classroom environment and generalized to the living environment (Darras, 2019). Unfortunately, our teachers are not well-familiarized with the creation of the right atmosphere in the classroom to flourish creativity. Furthermore, there are serious weaknesses in the training of creative and thoughtful people by educational institutions, especially the education system. The system with which students and most students around the world engage is perhaps the main reason for their creativity to be destroyed (HUI, A. N, & HE, M. W, 2021). Integrated learning is a combination of traditional face-to-face learning and online learning, so that teaching takes place both in the classroom and online, and the online section is an extension and continuation of traditional classroom learning (Ahmady & Nakhostin-Ruhi, 2014: 21). In today's world, special attention should be paid to learning creativity, so in schools, a special place has been considered for this to develop creative thinking (Esnaashari, FooladChang & Daryapour, 2017: 25). Teaching patterns are actually learning patterns. Teachers use these patterns to teach students how to learn while helping students acquire information, ideas, skills, ways of thinking, and tools of expressing ideas. (Brahuei Moghadam & Kahrazehi, 2020: 45).
Considering the teachability of creativity and the opportunities that integrated education provides for self-learning, exploratory learning, personal independence, application of constructivist and multisensory curriculum (Amiri, 2020: 43), also considering the importance of deep learning in the primary schools, a single teaching model based on the cognitive learning cycle is suggested, which can be used to teach all courses; this cycle is derived from the E5 method. Teaching in the cognitive learning cycle is a stage of integratd description and explanation and developement, so the cognitive learning cycle consists of four steps (Fluid capacity growth, expansion, flexibility and initiative capability). (Ganji, 2005: 134). Assessment as an acquired skill can be perceived as a measure that has become a student's mental habit and has made him an assessor of his behavior. Self-assessment tools, checklists, and workbooks can be used for assessment in part-time school (online, which is the basis of judgment of students (Malmir & et al., 2019: 189). Considering the above issues and the urgent need of the country's educational system for new developments in lesson planning, it seems that the integrated teaching method is a suitable alternative to traditional teaching methods to be effective in cognitive and applied learning of Persian literature. Therefore, in this study, we intend to pay attention to the importance of the theoretical foundations of creativity and innovation and one of the practical solutions to achieve a significant impact of integrated education on creativity and its components (fluidity growth, expansion, flexibility and initiative), to produce many of the socio-cultural contexts tied to it in order to produce knowledge, which is the main strategy for the progress and development of society. Therefore, the researcher tries to address the main goal of investigating the effect of integrated education patterns with traditional education methods on the creativity of female third grade elementary students in non-governmental schools in Sirjan.
Theoretical framework
Integrative education uses new ways of thinking in conjunction with lesson design to adapt traditional values and activities by absorbing technological possibilities and expectations that provide a combination of face-to-face and online components. Nowadays, learning based merely on either online or face-to-face has lost its fans, and the third view, called combined education, believes that this method of teaching carries satisfactory results (Wehlburg, 2010: 23). Curriculum integration is a way of organizing shared learning materials or life skills for all citizens and aims to help students learn how to participate in a democratic life (Mehrmohammadi & Abedi, 2001: 47). The traditional approach to education consideres the learner as passive. In the new educational approach, there is interaction between teacher and student and an opportunity to assess the level of student perception is provided, and appropriate and meaningful issues are suggested in the classroom (Adib, & et al., 2015: 117). The new perspective emphasizes the integration of information and perception. As a facilitator of learning, the teacher tries to strike a logical balance between classroom teaching and work teaching, and between intuitive thinking and analytical thinking. This perspective emphasizes the integration of knowledge through its application in meaningful situations, innovation, creativity and knowledge production. (Brahuei Moghadam, Kahrazehi, 2020: 50).
Methodology
The present study is an applied research in terms of purpose and in terms of method is a quasi-experimental design of pre-test post-test with a control group. The statistical population included 1012 female students in the third grade of non-governmental primary schools in Sirjan in the academic year 2020-2021. The statistical sample of this study includes 20 students from the third grade who were selected randomly and were divided into two groups of 10 people in the experimental and control groups. The integrated training sessions were performed in 10 sessions of 45 minutes for the experimental group and the control group did not receive any training. Total sessions were held during the academic year for 2 months and 15 days (equivalent to 10 weeks) until the first half of Aazar, the productive period carried out for 50 days (Dey 25, the time of descriptive-functional evaluation). In pre-test and post-test, both groups answered the research tool, Creativity Questionnaire (Abedi 1993). Findings collected using paired t-test and analysis of covariance including ANCOVA and MANCOVA Were performed and analyzed in SPSS software.
The educational content of the selected courses was considered in the third grade according to the education decree. In the traditional group, Persian literature courses were taught separately from each other. The integrated curriculum in the experimental group includes teaching patterns of rhetoric, pre-organizers, brainstorming, concept perception, inductive thinking in the content of each lesson of Persian literature by combining the teaching model of distance learning E5 online, and at the end, Abedi's creativity questionnaire was used as the post-test. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to analyze the data. The descriptive statistics section describes the sample data. In the inferential section, t-test was used for continuous groups to analyze the research hypotheses, and independent groups' t-test was used to test the hypotheses. The effect of pre-test on post-test was investigated by univariate analysis of covariance. SPSS software was used for data analysis.
Discussion and Results
The results of statistical analysis showed that no significant difference was observed in the average of creativity and its components in the traditional teaching group, and the average of the pre-test and post-test stages of the traditional teaching group was almost equal (p <0.05). But in the integrated education group, the average of creativity and all its components in the post-test stage compared to the pre-test has changed significantly (p <0.05). The results showed that in the integrated training group, the average of creativity and all its components in the post-test stage had a significant increase compared to the pre-test. Also, the effectiveness of integrated training on creativity is confirmed (p <0.05) and integrated training has significantly increased the creativity of the subjects.
Wilkes's multivariate Lambda test showed that the intervention was effective in general and integrated training was able to affect the components of creativity (p <0.05). Also, the study of components showed that the effect of integrated training on all four components of creativity including fluidity, expansion, initiative and flexibility has been confirmed (p <0.05).
Conclusion
The purpose of this study was to compare the effect of integrated teaching methods in comparison with traditional education on students' creativity. The results showed a significant effect of integrated teaching, compared to traditional teaching, on creativity and its components. Specifically, research on the integrated curriculum of teaching patterns of rhetoric, pre-organizers, brainstorming, concept perception, and inductive thinking in the content of each lesson of Persian literature by combining the teaching model of distance learning E5 has not been done online, but the results of this study are consistent with the findings of Banihashemi. Et al (2020), Kadkhodaii & soleimani (2015), Kazemi (2016), Emadi.et al (2018), Rahmatzehi.et al (2018), Ahmadi.et al (2014), Chamaro (2006) and Darras (2019), all of which show the impact of e-learning and integration on increasing students' creativity and learning. Explaining the effect of rhetorical method on increasing students' creativity, it can be said that since this teaching model has been developed with the aim of creating innovation; it has features that, directly and indirectly, teaches metaphorical thinking, motivates learners to use a variety of direct, personal and intensive (contrast) analogies, all of which are aimed at strengthening creative thinking and innovation skills.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Integrated education
  • Traditional Education
  • students' creativity
Adib, Y., Fathi Azar, I., Einipour. (2015). Teachers' perception of the characteristics of effective teaching; A phenomenological study. Research in curriculum planning. 12(44), 110-122. (In Persian).
Afrooz, GhA.,Kalantari, F., Nosrati, F. (2006). Investigating the effect of pre-organizers on student learning, Journal of Psychology and Educational Sciences. 72(16), 1-16. (In Persian).
Ahmady, G., & Nakhostin-Ruhi, N. (2014). Investigation of the differentiation of blended learning with electronical learning and traditional learning (face to face) in teaching mathemats. Journal of school psychology3(2), 7-26.‌
Ahmady, Gh, Nakhostin-Ruhi, N. (2014). Investigation of the differentiation of blended learning with electronical learning and traditional learning (face to face) in teaching mathemats, Journal of psychology and institution, 3(2), 7-26. doi: 93-3-2-1. (In Persian).
Amiri, A. (2020). The role of school atmosphere and emotional intelligence in the entrepreneurial self-efficacy of female students in Mashhad vocational schools. Management and Educational Perspective, 1(2), 15-36. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2020.227912.1010. (In Persian).
Bahramzadeh, S. (2020). Explaining the relationship between creativity and empowerment of human resources in education in Kashan. Management and EducationalPerspective,1(2),71-86. doi: https://dx.doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2020.227901.1009. (In Persian).
Banihashem, K., Farokhi Tirandaz, S., Shahalizadeh, M., & Mashhadi, M. (2020). The effect of e-learning on students’ creativity. Interdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences, 5(4), 53-61. (In Persian).
Brahuei Moghadam, NM., Kahrazehi,H. (2020). A Comparative Study of Teaching Methods Used for Teaching Science in the Elementary Schools in Iran and the United Kingdom. Teacher professional Development, 5(2), 41-58. (In Persian).
Chamorro‐Premuzic, T. (2006). Creativity versus conscientiousness: Which is a better predictor of student performance?. Applied Cognitive Psychology: The Official Journal of the Society for Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 20(4), 521-531.
Cloney, D. (2009). The matrix ate my baby. (Educational futures: Rethinking theory and practice. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 41(5).
Darras, B. (2019). Creativity and Creative Communities. The International Encyclopedia of Art and Design Education, 1-12.
Emadi, SR., Vakilifard, AR., Farkhondeh, Y. (2018). The effect of teaching in a conventional and combined way on creativity, motivation and learning of non-Iranian Persian students, Scientific-Research Quarterly of Al-Zahra University. 10(2), 110-146. (In Persian).
Esnaashari, N.,FooladChang,M.,Daryapour, E. (2017).Effectiveness of creativity training using Lego on self-confidence and problem solving of 4-6 year old children, Cognitive and Behavioral Sciences Research, 7(2), 23-38. doi: 10.22108/cbs.2017.86870.0. (In Persian).
Ganji, H., Pasha Sharifi, H., Mirhashemi, M. (2005).The effect of brainstorming method on increasing students' creativity. Journal of Education. 21(1), 112-156. (In Persian).
HUI, A. N., & HE, M. W. (2021). 5 A Life-Span Developmental Approach to Creativity. Creativity: An Introduction, 67.
Kadkhodai, M., Soleimani, A. (2015). Comparison of rhetorical education and lecture method on increasing the creativity of female and male students in the third grade of elementary school in Zarrinshahr, Research in Curriculum Planning, 2(12), 119-130. (In Persian).
Kazempour, I. (2016). The effect of integrated art education in mathematics on learning and creativity, Journal of Initiative and Creativity in Humanities, 21(6), 112-114. (In Persian).
Khoshneshin, Z. (2017). An analytic review on blended learning effects on students achievements in learning science. Technology of Education Journal (TEJ)12(3), 231-238.
khashi jamalzehi, E. (2021). The effect of visual teaching method using PowerPoint, video and photo based on educational management model on conceptual learning. Management and Educational Perspective, 2(4), 1-16. Doi: https://dx.doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2021.261432.1044. (In Persian).
Malmir.A., Ismaili, AR., Madadi, V.. (2019). Investigating the effect of using educational media on academic achievement and students' creativity, management on the education of organizations. 8(1), 185-201. (In Persian).
 Matin Far, N., & Kian, M. (2021). Effectiveness of The Implementation of an Integrated Social Studies Curriculum With art, on the Academic Performance of Students in Social Studies. Journal of Curriculum Research10(2), 66-83.
Mehrmohammadi,M.,&Abedi,L. (2001). The nature of teaching and its aesthetic dimensions. Quarterly Journal of Teacher, 5(3), 45-69. (In Persian).
Nourabadi, S., Ahmadi, P, Dabiri Esfahani, A, Farasatkhah, M. (2014), The necessityand possibilityof changing Higher Education Approved Curriculum in Iran to integrated curriculum (A case study on educational management domain, undergraduate course), Instaction and evaluation, 7 (25), 101-121.
Pakizeh, A. (2015). An Investigation on the Effectiveness of the Arts Synthetic Training Method on Learning and Creativity of Elementary Male Students.
poloie, L. (2021). Comparison between learning of students trained by the management model method and students trained in the method of teaching a second language. Management and Educational Perspective, 3(1), 31-54. doi: https://dx.doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2021.276285.1050. (In Persian)
Rahmat Zehi,Kh.,Fatehi, N. (2018). The Role of Teaching Methods in Fostering the Creativity of Elementary Students, National Conference on New World Achievements in Education, Psychology, Law, and Socio-Cultural Studies.. 1(1), 1-10. (In Persian).
Sternberg, R. J. (2012). The assessment of creativity: An investment-based approach. Creativity research journal, 24(1), 3-12.
Wehlburg, C. M. (2010). Integrated general education: A brief look back. New Directions for Teaching and Learning,2010 (121), 3-11.