The effectiveness of using web quest strategies and digital stories in the development of critical thinking, higher level thinking skills, and the progress of fifth grade history literature students in Karbala city

Abbashassan Nasrolah, Reza; Hassani, Mohammad

doi:10.22034/jmep.2024.417771.1249

The effectiveness of using web quest strategies and digital stories in the development of critical thinking, higher level thinking skills, and the progress of fifth grade history literature students in Karbala city

Document Type : Original Article (Quantified)

Authors

Reza Abbashassan Nasrolah ¹

Mohammad hassani ²

¹ PhD student, Department of Educational Management, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran

² Professor, Department of Educational Management, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2024.417771.1249

Abstract

Abstract
The purpose of this research is the effectiveness of using web quest strategies and digital stories in developing critical thinking, higher level thinking skills, and student progress. The current study is a quasi-experimental study along with a pre-test-post-test design with a control group. The statistical population of the research is 860 fifth grade literature students, 45 of whom were selected by multi-stage cluster sampling and randomly divided into three groups of 15 (a control group of 15 and two experimental groups of the rest 30). Data collection was done based on Ritex critical thinking questionnaire (2003), higher level thinking by Abdi et al., (2013), and academic progress by Salehi (2014). The face and content validity of the questionnaire was approved by professors and experts in management and educational sciences and was confirmed through factor analysis. The reliability of the questionnaire based on Cronbach's alpha coefficient was obtained 0.90 for critical thinking, 0.84 for higher level thinking, and 0.79 for academic achievement. Analysis of the information obtained from the tests was done through SPSS software. The results of the research showed that the effect of using web quest and digital storytelling strategies on the development of critical thinking, higher level thinking and academic progress of students is positive and significant. It was also found that there is not any significant difference in the effect of using web quest strategies and digital storytelling on critical thinking, higher level thinking and academic achievement of students.
Extended abstract
Introduction
Tendency to critical thinking is the factor of the reasoning process in a person's personality, which motivates him to use critical thinking (Facione, 2016). This shows the importance of critical thinking. Therefore, any conceptualization of critical thinking that only focuses on critical thinking skills is not complete, and in any discussion of critical thinking, the tendency towards this thinking should also be considered. In confirmation of this issue, many experts have emphasized the importance of tending to critical thinking in the creation and development of this type of thinking (Noshadi, 2015). Today's students are very different from the students of the past decades, because today's students are looking for deeper thinking about issues and involvement in decision-making; they want to participate in various dimensions of society; one of the ways of which is their development in creating new information, which is possible by equipping them with higher level thinking skills (Shafiei, 2015). For this reason, educational systems should not be limited to teaching knowledge and subjects, but in order to respond as much as possible, students should be given the tools to acquire the necessary strategies to adapt to changes, and in this way, the necessary motivation and ability for lifelong learning in them be created (Petrovska & Veselinovska, 2013). Based on the idea of search and research as well as the theory of constructivism, web quests engage learners in collaborative learning and group projects. In addition, there is a strong connection between web quests and multimedia techniques that provide important opportunities for using Internet resources in teaching and learning (Awada et al, 2020). A strategic web quest based on searching and building concepts forces learners to think at a higher level, so that they can analyze and apply complex information and create an exciting online teaching and learning strategy (Badeleh & Sabeti, 2017). Also web quest helps learners integrate their knowledge and meanings by applying information available on the Internet. Researchers believe that the ability of web quests in designing activities is unlimited, and it engages the learners by satisfying the intuition and curiosity of them (Sanford et al, 2010). According to the issues raised in this research, an attempt is made to answer the question of whether the use of web quest strategies and digital stories is significant in the development of critical thinking, higher level thinking skills, and the progress of fifth grade history literature students.
Theoretical Framework
Web Quest
Web Quest is a question-oriented platform or a model in which students are actively involved in a learning-oriented activity or situation and use multiple resources to interact with content and build knowledge. The Web Quest approach is a learning, problem-oriented, and searching approach; opposite to the direct transfer of knowledge in a teacher-centered learning environment (Nami, 2021).
Digital storytelling
Sadik (2008) considers digital storytelling as a new and modern expression of the old art of storytelling. Since throughout history, storytelling has been a tool for exchanging knowledge, wisdom and values, it has had different forms; this time by integrating with technology, it has been able to be used as a powerful tool to better explain the concepts of the problem.
Critical Thinking
Critical thinking, as a form of wise judgment or thoughtful decision-making, is truly pervasive. That is, it is hard to find a time or place where critical thinking does not seem to have potential value (Facione, 2016).
Higher level thinking
Higher level thinking includes analysis, synthesis and evaluation and requires mastery of previous levels such as applying normal rules in relation to similar or new issues and problems. Higher level thinking skills include changing and transforming information and ideas. This change in shape and transformation happens when students experience and analyze opinions, ideas and facts, and combine, generalize, explain or achieve some results and interpretations (Brookhart, 2017).
Academic progress
The academic progress is measuring the performance of learners and comparing the results with predetermined educational goals in order to decide whether the teacher's educational activities and the students' learning efforts have led to desirable results and to what extent (Mashayekh, 2014).
Sabih Mahdi & Ghalavandi (2024) investigated the effect of learning and motivational strategies on the self-efficacy of physical education and sports science students with the mediating role of academic progress and enthusiasm. The results showed that the effect of learning and motivational strategies, academic achievement goals, and academic enthusiasm on students' academic self-efficacy was positive and significant. It was also found that the mediating role of academic achievement goals and academic enthusiasm in the effect of learning and motivational strategies on academic self-efficacy was positive and meaningful.
Aibin et al, (2023) investigated the effect of different types of education outside the university on higher thinking tendencies of elementary and middle school students. They reported positive and significant impact of different types of education outside the university on the high thinking levels of elementary and middle school students.
Research methodology
The current study is a quasi-experimental study along with a pre-test-post-test design with a control group. The statistical population of the research is 860 fifth grade literature students, 45 of whom were selected by multi-stage cluster sampling and randomly divided into three groups of 15 (a control group of 15 and two experimental groups of the rest 30). Data collection was done based on Ritex critical thinking questionnaire (2003), higher level thinking by Abdi et al., (2013), and academic progress by Salehi (2014). The face and content validity of the questionnaire was approved by professors and experts in management and educational sciences and was confirmed through factor analysis. The reliability of the questionnaire based on Cronbach's alpha coefficient was obtained 0.90 for critical thinking, 0.84 for higher level thinking, and 0.79 for academic achievement.

Research findings
Analysis of the information obtained from the tests was done through SPSS software. The results of the research showed that the effect of using web quest and digital storytelling strategies on the development of critical thinking, higher level thinking and academic progress of students is positive and significant. It was also found that there is not any significant difference in the effect of using web quest strategies and digital storytelling on critical thinking, higher level thinking and academic achievement of students.

Conclusion
The current research was conducted with the aim of the effectiveness of using web quest strategies and digital stories in the development of critical thinking, higher level thinking skills, and student progress. The results of this research are in line with the findings of Nami (2021), Farjaei Bonab et al., (2021), Gharahkhan (2021), Faramarzi (2019), Aibin et al., (2023), Alsalhi et al., (2020), Liang et al., (2020), Ebadi & Rahimi (2018), Liang et al., (2020), Ebadi & Rahimi (2018), Han-Yu et al., (2015), Aibin et al., (2023), Awada et al., (2020), Mosavi et al., (2021), Badeleh & Sabeti (2017), Alsalhi et al., (2020), Kazemi (2015), Farjaei Bonab et al., (2021), Faramarzi (2019), Gharahkhan (2021), and Shabani et al., (2017). Nami (2021) examined direct classroom-based instruction versus flipped web quest-based instruction: Toward more effective writing practice. It was found that direct classroom-oriented teaching compared to reverse web quest-oriented teaching had a lower impact on students' progress.

Keywords

Web quest

Digital stories

Critical thinking

Higher level thinking

Development

Subjects

Education Management

Abdi, H., & Mirshah Jafari, S.E., & Nasr, A.R., & Ghasemi, N. (2014). The relationship between faculty members' metacognitive awareness and teaching high-level thinking to students. Iranian Journal of Education in Medical Sciences, 14 (5):371-383. URL: http://ijme.mui.ac.ir/article-1-3084-en.html. (In Persian)

Aboutalebi, H. (2021). The effect of academic motivation and academic seriousness on the academic achievement of female primary school students in District 7 of Karaj. Management and Educational Perspective, 2(4), 119-134. doi: 10.22034/jmep.2021.267311.1047. (In Persian)

Ahangaran, Z. (2017). Predicting academic progress based on self-efficacy, procrastination and exam anxiety in high school students, Congress of the Iranian Psychological Association. (In Persian)

Ahmadpour, M. (2016). The effect of storytelling with pictures of alphabets on preschool students' reading skills, master's thesis in the field of educational technology, Islamic Azad University of Kermanshah. (In Persian)

Aibin, T., & Jijun, Y., & Dawei, L. (2023). The impact of different types of off-campus training on primary and junior high students’ higher-order thinking dispositions, Thinking Skills and Creativity, 14: 1-9. DOI:10.1016/j.tsc.2023.101351

Alexander, B. (2017). The New Digital Storytelling: Creating Narratives with New Media--Revised and Updated Edition. ABC-CLIO.‏

Alsalhi, N.R., & Al-Qatawneh, S., & Aljarrah, K. (2020). The role of academic electronic books in undergraduate students' achievement in higher education, Heliyon, 6(11): 1-13. DOI: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e05550

Atmatzidou, S., & Demetriadis, S. (2016). Advancing students’ computational thinking skills through educational robotics: A study on age and gender relevant diferences. Robotics and Autonomous Systems, 75, 661–670. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.robot.2015.10.008

Awada, G., & Burston, J., & Ghannage, R. (2020). Effect of student team achievement division through WebQuest on EFL students’ argumentative writing skills and their instructors’ perceptions. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 33(3), 275-300. DOI:10.1080/09588221.2018.1558254

Badeleh, A.R., & Sabeti, A.H. (2017). The effect of the educational method based on web quest on learning and the level of student teachers' satisfaction with it in the course of educational design. Policy studies on teacher training (research on teacher training), 1(2), 9-27. (In Persian)

Baranzehi, H. (2018). Investigating the relationship between hardiness and perceptual stress and academic achievement of female boarding school students in Bandar Jask secondary school, master's thesis in clinical psychology, Islamic Azad University, Bandar Abbas branch. (In Persian)

Bazdar, B. (2013). Reviewing and analyzing the content of mathematics teaching software available in the market from the point of view of active and construction-oriented learning approach and the principles of multimedia design, master's thesis in educational technology, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah branch. (In Persian)

Biyabangard, E. (2012). Research methods in psychology and educational sciences, Tehran: Doran Publishing House. (In Persian)

Black, J. & Barnes, J. L. (2015). Fiction and social Cognition: The Effect of Viewing Award-Winning Television Dramas on Theory of Mind. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 9 (4): 423-429. DOI:10.1037/aca0000031

Brookhart, S.M. (2017). Measuring high-level thinking in the classroom, translated by Maryam Safarnavadeh, Tehran: Manadi Tarbiat Publishing. (In Persian)

Chan,N.M., & Ho,I.T., & Ku,k.Y. (2011). Epistemic beliefs and critical thinking of Chinese student. learning and individual differences, 21:67-77. 10.1016/j.lindif.2010.11.001

Clarke, J.A., & Rowe, E., & Scruggs, R. (2020). The development of students’ computational thinking practices in elementary- and middle-school classes using the learning game, Zoombinis, Computers in Human Behavior, 115: 106-113. DOI:10.1016/j.chb.2020.106587

Ebadi, S., & Rahimi, M. (2018). An exploration into the impact of WebQuest-based classroom on EFL learners’ critical thinking and academic writing skills: A mixed methods study. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 31(5-6), 617–651. DOI:10.1080/09588221.2018.1449757

Esteban, R.F.C., & Mamani-Benito, O., & Ruiz Mamani, R,C. (2022). Academic self-efficacy, self-esteem, satisfaction with studies, and virtual media use as depression and emotional exhaustion predictors among college students during COVID-19, Heliyon, 8(11): 1-9. DOI: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e11085

Facione, P. A. (2016). Critical thinking: what it is and why it counts (a resource paper). Millbrae, CA: California Academic Press.

Faramarzi, M. (2019). Online discussion forums and high-level thinking skills: a research with a mixed approach on Persian language learners, Master's Thesis of English Language Teaching, Lorestan University. (In Persian)

Farjaei Bonab, S., & Shadero, M., & Samadi, Z. (2021). Investigating the impact of digital storytelling on the critical thinking of elementary school children, the 7th National Conference on Modern Researches in the Field of Iranian Language and Literature, Tehran, https://civilica.com/doc/1371358.. (In Persian)

Gharahkhan, R. (2021). The effect of education based on digital storytelling on academic enthusiasm and ataxia of elementary school students in Pasargad city, master's thesis in educational technology, Islamic Azad University, Shiraz branch. (In Persian)

Halpern,D.F. (2008). teaching for critical thinking: sHelping college students Develop the skiils and Dispositions of a critical thinker. New directions for teaching and learning.

Han-Yu,S., & Hwang, G., & Hong-Sheng, C. (2015). An Integrated Contextual and Web-based Issue Quest Approach to Improving Students?Learning Achievements, Attitudes and Critical Thinking, Journal of Educational Technology & Society; Palmerston North, 8(4): 299-311. DOI:10.1109/IIAI-AAI.2014.82

Hashemi, A., & Sadeghifar, A., & Hemati, A. (2011). Examining the relationship between types of thinking styles with creativity and innovation of school principals in Lamard city, Research in Curriculum Planning, 8(30): 63-64. https://civilica.com/doc/464731. (In Persian)

Jeon, S. K., & Seo, Y. M., & Lee, Y. J. (2011). A study about creativity and programming education. Proceedings of Korean Association of Computer Education, 15(1): 73–77.

Kazemi, H. (2015). The effect of group work problem solving methods on critical thinking and academic progress of third grade primary school students in Qom city, Master's Thesis in Philosophy of Education, Islamic Azad University, South Tehran Branch. (In Persian)

Khosravi, Z., & Afhami, R., & Azadfalah, P. (2019). Digital Storytelling and Theory of Mind: A Media for Creative Mind Reading, Innovation and Creativity in the Humanities, 9(2):22-53.

Koroshniya, M. (2011). Presenting a causal model for students' critical thinking tendency according to the factors of cultural values, the dimensions of family-university communication patterns and the satisfaction of basic psychological needs, doctoral thesis in educational psychology, Shiraz University. (In Persian)

Li, W., Huang, J., & Wang, S. (2023). A study on the relationship between student' learning engagements and higher-order thinking skills in programming learning, Thinking Skills and Creativity, 10: 1-8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tsc.2023.101369

Liang, W., & Fung, D. (2020). Development and evaluation of a WebQuest-basedteaching programme: Students’ use of exploratory talk to exercise critical thinking. International Journal of Educational Research, 104, 101652. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijer.2020.101652

Mahdiyeh, A. (2013). The effect of storytelling on the development of moral reasoning of children in the sixth grade of primary school for boys in Sarablah city, master's thesis in educational technology, Islamic Azad University, Yazd branch.

March, T. (2004). The Learning Power of Web Quests. Educational Leadership. 61(4):42-7.

Mashayekh, M. (2014). The role of self-efficacy, happiness and involvement of parents in academic matters as predictors of academic achievement of female students in the first grade of high school in Bandar Abbas city, master's thesis in educational psychology, Islamic Azad University, Bandar Abbas branch. (In Persian)

Midani, M. (2012). The effectiveness of emotional intelligence training on the motivation and academic progress of third-grade female high school students in Yazd city (in the academic year 2011-2012), master's thesis, Yazd University. (In Persian)

Miller, M.A., & Malcolm, N.S. (2018).Critical thinking in the nursing curriculum. Nurs Health Care,11(2): 67-73.

Moharari, F. (2018). Studying and comparing the level of high-level thinking in undergraduate students of Iran and Canada, master's thesis in educational technology, Kharazmi University. (In Persian)

Mosavi, S.M., & Fallah, V., & Sattari, S., & Motaklam, A. & Aslanzadeh, H. (2021).the effect of web quest teaching on students' progress motivation, self-concept and self-regulated learning, Information and Communication Technology Quarterly in Educational Sciences, 11(3): 27-45. (In Persian)

Mosazadeh, M. (2014). Investigating the effect of digital storytelling on the rate of retention of new words in the minds of Iranian language learners at the introductory level, master's thesis, Tabran Institute of Higher Education. (In Persian)

Nami, F. (2022). Direct classroom-based instruction versus flipped web quest-based instruction: Toward more effective writing practice. Research paper on Persian language teaching to non-Persian speakers, 11(2), 53-74. https://civilica.com/doc/1749784. (In Persian)

Nazari, S. (2016). Investigating the impact of education using infographics on critical thinking in the history course of female students of the first year of secondary school in Sarpol Zahab city in the academic year 2015-2016, master's thesis in educational technology, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah branch. (In Persian)

Noh, J., & Lee, J. (2018). Design of a SW educational program using robots: Focused on computational thinking and creative problem solving abilities of elementary school students. Journal of Educational Technology, 34(1):1–37. DOI:10.17232/KSET.34.1.001

Noshadi, N. (2015). Investigating the tendency of humanities students towards critical thinking: providing a conceptual framework for developing critical thinking, National Congress of Humanities: Strategies for the Promotion of Humanities in Iran. (In Persian)

Ohler, J. (2006). The world of digital storytelling. Educational Leadership, 63(4). 44-47. https://www.learntechlib.org/p/98782/.

Partoei, O.K. (2019). Investigating the relationship between resilience and creativity with the academic enthusiasm of secondary school students, master's thesis in general psychology, East Golestan Institute of Higher Education. (In Persian)

Petrovska, S., & Veselinovska, S.S. (2013). Contemporary Pedagogical Approaches for Developing Higher Level Thinking on Science Classes, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 42(1): 89-98. DOI:10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.08.742

Ricketts, J. C. (2003). The Efficacy of Leader ship Development, Critical Thinking Dispositions, and Students Academic Performance on the Critical Thinking Skills of Selected Youth Leaders. Dissertation Presented to the Graduate School of the University of Florida in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy,

Roets, L., & Maritz, J. (2017). Facilitating the Development of Higher-Order Thinking Skills (Hots) of NoviceNursing Postgraduates in Africa. Nurse Educ Today; 49: 51-56. DOI: 10.1016/j.nedt.2016.11.005

Roline, M & Daryl, G.B, (2019). Teacher and observer ratings of Head start children’s social skills, Early childhood Research Qvarterly, 17 (4):128-139.  DOI:10.1016/S0885-2006(02)00190-4

Sabih Mahdi, F., & ghalavandi, H. (2024). Investigating the mediating role of academic self-sufficiency and basic psychological needs in the relationship of social skills and social intelligence with academic achievement. Management and Educational Perspective, 6(1), 351-372. doi: 10.22034/jmep.2024.449918.1343. (In Persian)

Sadik, A. (2008). Digital storytelling: a meaningful technology-integrated approach for engaged student learning. Education Tech Research Dev. 56. 487-506. DOI:10.1007/s11423-008-9091-8

Salehi, R. (2015). Developing an academic counseling model and investigating its impact on the academic success of first-year Shahrekord high school students, Master's thesis, Isfahan University. (In Persian)

Sanford J., & Townsend-Rocchiccioli J., & Trimmd D. & Jacobs M. (2010(. The WebQuest: Constructing Creative Learning. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing; 41(10): 473-9. DOI: 10.3928/00220124-20100503-04

Shabani, H. (2018). Skills and education, Tehran: Samt Publications. (In Persian)

Shabani, S., & Tajabadi, R., & Movahediyan, S. (2017). The application and impact of digital storytelling technology in the development of the culture of reading and learning in students (with emphasis on primary education), national conference of subject-educational knowledge (knowledge of content education): religious education and elementary Quran. https://civilica.com/doc/774200. (In Persian)

Shafiei, L. (2015). Investigating the relationship between teachers' teaching style and the development of higher level thinking skills of learners of non-profit tourism educational institutions in the Islamic Republic of Iran, Master's thesis in educational management, Shiraz University. (In Persian)

Sherry, C.V., & Satish, Kh., & Anurag, S. (2020). Why Does Technology Integration Fail? Teacher Beliefs and Content Developer Assumptions in an Indian Initiative, Educational Technology Research and Development, 68: 452-463. DOI:10.1007/s11423-020-09760-x

Sivaci, S., & Altas, B. (2022). The effect of critical thinking dispositions and democratic values of pre-service EFL teachers on their multicultural self-efficacy: A structural equation modeling approach, Thinking Skills and Creativity, 47: 2451-2460. DOI:10.1016/j.tsc.2022.101221

Soltis, R., & Verlinden, N., & Trumbo, T. (2015). Process-Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning Strategy Enhances Students’ Higher Level Thinking Skills in a Pharmaceutical Sciences Course, American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 17: 1-10. DOI: 10.5688/ajpe79111

Stasiewicz, P. R., & Bradizza, C. M., & Gudleski, G. D., & Coffey, S. F., & Schlauch, R. C., & Bailey, S. T., & Gulliver, S. B. (2012). The relationship of alexithymia to emotional dysregulation within an alcohol dependent treatment sample. Addictive behaviors, 37(4), 469-476.‏ doi: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2011.12.011. Epub 2011 Dec 27.

Tseng, T., & Guo, S., & Lo, K.W. (2022). The effect of a multidimensional teaching strategy on the self-efficacy and critical thinking dispositions of nursing students: A quasi-experimental study, Nurse Education Today, 119: 178-188. DOI: 10.1016/j.nedt.2022.105531

Valentín, A., & Mateos, P. M., & Gonz alez-Tablas, M., P & erez, L., L & opez, E., & García, I. (2013). Motivation and learning strategies in the use of ICTs among university students. Computers & Education, 61,52-58. DOI:10.1016/j.compedu.2012.09.008

Zohar, A. (2013). Challenges in wide scale implementation efforts to fosterhigher order thinking (HOT) in scienceeducation across awhole school system.Thinking Skills and Creativity. 10: 223-249. DOI:10.1016/j.tsc.2013.06.002