Document Type: Original Article (Quantified)
Human Resource Management

Investigating the Antecedents of Knowledge Hiding Behavior in Therapeutic Environments

Volume 8, Issue 2, Summer 2026, Pages 320-342

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.557312.1595

zohre sharei, Hanie Heidari Nezhad

Abstract This study investigated the effect of colleagues' rudeness on knowledge concealment through the mediation of work involvement and intention to leave, and the moderating role of staff pessimism in Valiasr Hospital in Bafgh. This is a causal-effectual, descriptive-survey and applicable research conducted with a field method and by a standard questionnaire. Data were collected from employees of Valiasr Hospital in Bafgh and analyzed by descriptive and inferential statistical methods (including structural equation modeling based on the partial least squares method). Analyses were performed by SPSS27 software for preliminary calculations and SmartPLS4 for structural modeling. The results showed that in Valiasr Hospital in Bafgh, rudeness of colleagues significantly reduces job involvement, increases intention to leave the service, and ultimately strengthens knowledge concealment; so that job involvement and intention to leave the service play a significant sequential mediating role. The moderating role of employee cynicism was not confirmed. These findings indicate that in the small environment and close relationships of this city government hospital, rudeness of colleagues has a significant effect on reducing the motivation to share knowledge. Therefore, strengthening job involvement and improving interpersonal relationships in Valiasr Hospital in Bafgh can reduce knowledge concealment and improve the organizational performance.
Introduction
Knowledge concealment, as an intentional attempt by employees to hide all or part of their required knowledge from others, is considered one of the key challenges in organizations (Valikhani Dehaghani & Mohammadi, 2022). This behavior not only hinders knowledge sharing and undermines teamwork and organizational productivity, but in healthcare settings it can also negatively impact patient safety and lead to medical errors, treatment delays, and reduced patient satisfaction. In small and medium-sized hospitals such as Valiasr Hospital in Bafgh, which face human resource constraints and challenges in retaining expert staff, knowledge hiding is a serious issue because the clinical and empirical knowledge of employees directly affects the quality of patient care. One of the main factors associated with knowledge hiding is coworker rudeness (Mahdikhani & Elhami, 2025). Meanwhile, work engagement and turnover intention can play a mediating role, and employee cynicism can play a moderating role. The main objective of this study is to investigate the effect of coworker rudeness on knowledge concealment through the mediation of work engagement and turnover intention and the moderating role of employee cynicism in Valiasr Hospital in Bafgh.
Theoretical Framework
Knowledge Concealment:
Knowledge is divided into two types: tacit (based on individual skills) and explicit (descriptible and transferable) (Yazdipour & Sabouni, 2022). Knowledge concealment refers to a deliberate attempt to conceal requested knowledge, and its forms include fooling around, avoidance, and rational concealment (Imani et al., 2022).
Coworker incivility:
Coworker incivility refers to low-intensity disrespectful behaviors with vague intent to harm that violate norms of mutual respect. (Rahimi Koloor et al., 2023) This behavior can be verbal or nonverbal and carries high psychological costs. (Mahdikhani & Elhami, 2025).
Work engagement:
Work engagement is a positive psycho-behavioral state including high energy, focus, and a sense of belonging. (Sharei & Abbasi Darreh Bidi, 2025). This concept has cognitive, emotional, physical-psychological, social, and moral-value dimensions. (Karami et al., 2025)
Turnover intention:
Turnover intention is an individual’s subjective desire to leave the organization within a given period of time, influenced by factors such as job security and organizational justice (Sadeghi, 2023; Zamanipour et al., 2025).
Employee cynicism:
Employee cynicism is a negative attitude toward the organization, including a belief in a lack of integrity, negative emotions, and critical behaviors (Zamanipour et al., 2025).
According to the Conservation of Resources (COR) theory, coworker rudeness, as a stressor, drains employees' psychological resources and leads to reduced work engagement and increased turnover intention, and ultimately knowledge concealment. The research background shows that Agarwal et al. (2024) concluded that rudeness increases knowledge concealment by reducing work engagement and increasing turnover intention. Also, Jabbari et al. (2023) showed that organizational cynicism mediates the relationship between rudeness and organizational silence.
Research Methodology
This study is applicable in terms of purpose; quantitative in terms of data nature; and descriptive-survey of causal-effectual type in terms of implementation method. The statistical population consisted of 450 official and contractual employees of Valiasr Hospital in Bafgh. The sample size was calculated based on the Cochran formula for the limited population as 210 people (with a confidence level of 95% and an error of 5%). Sampling was done by simple random sampling. The data collection tool was a standard five-point Likert questionnaire including: the Coworker Incivility Questionnaire (Cortina et al., 2001) with 7 questions, the Knowledge Concealment Questionnaire (Badar et al., 2023) with 3 questions, the Work Involvement Questionnaire (Islam & Chaudhary, 2024) with 7 questions, the Intention to Leave Questionnaire (Badar et al., 2023) with 3 questions, and the Employee Pessimism Questionnaire (Durrah et al., 2019) with 7 questions. Content validity was confirmed by experts and the supervisor. The reliability of the tool was reported to be higher than 0.70 by calculating the Cronbach's alpha coefficient in an initial sample of 30 people for all variables (Incivility: 0.845, Concealment: 0.708, Involvement: 0.092, Intention to Leave: 0.866, Pessimism: 0.899). Data were analyzed by SPSS version 27 for descriptive analysis (mean, standard deviation, skewness, and kurtosis) and SmartPLS version 4 for structural equation modeling based on the partial least squares method (PLS-SEM). In the inferential section, the measurement model (factor loadings, composite reliability, convergent validity with AVE, and divergent validity with the Fornell and Larker matrix), the structural model (β path coefficients, R² coefficients, redundancy criterion, and t-statistics), and overall model fit (GOF) were evaluated.
Research findings
Out of 210 respondents, 133 (63.3%) were male and 77 (36.7%) were female. The modeling results showed: (1) Rudeness has a negative effect on engagement (β = -0.585, t = 7.238). (2) Involvement has a negative effect on intention to quit (β = -0.484, t = 7.058). (3) Intention to quit has a positive effect on concealment (β = 0.622, t = 13.271). (4) Pessimism did not have a moderating role (β = 0.063, t = 1.206). (5) The chain mediation of involvement and intention to quit was confirmed (β = 0.176, t = 5.011). R² for concealment (0.387), involvement (0.349) and intention to quit (0.234) was at a strong level.
Conclusion
The findings of this study showed that rudeness of colleagues reduces work engagement by draining employees' psychological resources (based on the conservation of resources theory). This decrease in engagement, in turn, increases the intention to leave the service and, ultimately, employees resort to knowledge concealment to preserve their knowledge capital. This causal chain shows that abnormal interpersonal behaviors in the healthcare environment not only drain employees' psychological resources, but also lead to defensive behaviors such as knowledge concealment by weakening job enthusiasm and creating a desire to leave. The findings of this study are consistent with the studies of Agarwal et al. (2024), Anand et al. (2023), Mahdikhani & Elhami (2025), and Jabbari et al. (2023), that have confirmed the role of rudeness, work engagement and pessimism in knowledge concealment. In this study, the moderating role of employees' pessimism was not confirmed; this finding is in contrast to the results of Agarwal et al. (2024) and Anand et al. (2023) who reported pessimism as an aggravating or mediating factor. However, it is consistent with the findings of Akhlaghimofrad & Farmanesh (2021) and Sadeghi (2023) who reported pessimism as having no moderating or mediating role. Contrary to the conservation of resources (COR) theory, pessimism did not have a moderating effect in this study. This is likely due to the low level of pessimism in the sample (mean 2.1 out of 5) and the prevalence of the medical professional culture (moral commitment to patients) that neutralizes the negative effects of rudeness.
Based on the results, practical suggestions include: holding communication skills workshops (active listening and conflict management) several times a year, developing a code of ethics and organizational behavior, creating a confidential reporting system, monthly recognition of exemplary employees with a plaque and cash bonus, developing a clear career path map, holding weekly meetings to share clinical experiences, and holding responsibility transfer meetings for knowledge transfer in the final months of employees' service. For future research, it is recommended to examine different dimensions of knowledge concealment (foolish play, avoidance, and rational concealment), consider other mediators such as emotional exhaustion and interpersonal distrust, conduct longitudinal studies in larger hospitals, and examine the role of cultural variables such as ethical leadership or organizational support as moderators. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Education Management

Evaluating the effectiveness of artificial intelligence in developing students' entrepreneurial skills

Volume 7, Issue 1, Spring 2025, Pages 340-360

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.510206.1489

Neda Tarabpur, Seyyed Mohammad Baqir Jafari, Jafar Rahmani

Abstract The aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of artificial intelligence in developing students’ entrepreneurial skills. The present study is applicable in terms of its purpose, descriptive-survey in terms of data collection, and correlational in terms of the relationships between variables. The statistical population of the present study includes 110 teachers of secondary schools in Districts 11 and 12 of Tehran, selected by purposive sampling method. The collection tool in the present study includes a questionnaire which was distributed among them. The validity of the questionnaire was confirmed by experts and its reliability was confirmed by Cronbach’s alpha coefficient. SPSS and PLS software were used to analyze the findings and test the hypotheses. The results showed that artificial intelligence has an impact on the development of entrepreneurial skills such as personal skills, creative and critical skills, interpersonal skills and practical skills. Also, the GOF criterion method was used to fit the overall model; the obtained value was 0.723, which indicates a strong fit of the model.
Extended abstract
Introduction
In the era of rapid technological and digital changes, the development of entrepreneurial skills among students has become a fundamental necessity for educational systems. Entrepreneurship education for the new generation is not only a key factor in economic growth and sustainable job creation, but also a prerequisite for adapting to technological changes, innovation, and empowering young people to successfully enter the competitive environment of the future labor market (Somia, & Vecchiarini, 2024). Meanwhile, the emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) with unique capabilities in complex data processing, decision-making, personalization of learning processes, and creation of interactive content has opened new horizons for the transformation of entrepreneurship education (Wan, 2025).
The complexity of entrepreneurship education, with its interdisciplinary nature and need for practical experience, requires new approaches to personalize education, provide interactive scenarios, and simulate real business environments; capabilities that artificial intelligence can potentially provide (Bell & Bell, 2023). However, there is a lack of credible evidence and empirical studies, especially in developing countries and school settings, on the actual effectiveness of this technology in entrepreneurship education. Many existing studies have either focused on the technological dimension or have lacked the measurement of operational and behavioral effectiveness on students. This research gap has doubled the need for scientific studies and field evaluations (Bhatt et al., 2024). Focusing on "Evaluating the Effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence in Developing Students' Entrepreneurial Skills", this research attempts to answer basic questions: To what extent and in what dimensions do AI-based technologies improve entrepreneurial capabilities (including cognitive capabilities, practical skills, and personality-behavioral characteristics) among students? Which components and contextual conditions (such as school environment, digital literacy level, gender, etc.) play a key role in realizing or failing to realize the effectiveness of this process? Can AI fill the gaps in traditional entrepreneurship education and lead to strengthening students' willingness, courage, and readiness to enter the field of entrepreneurship?
Theoretical Framework
Students' Entrepreneurial Skills
Entrepreneurship skills are a multidimensional set of capabilities, attitudes, and knowledge that enable an individual to identify opportunities, create value, and manage resources in various economic, social, and technological contexts. These skills go beyond technical capabilities to include psychological traits (such as risk-taking, independence, perseverance, and self-confidence), cognitive abilities (such as creative thinking, problem-solving, gathering, analyzing, and evaluating information), and social skills (such as effective communication, teamwork, negotiation, and networking). Recent research shows that establishing and nurturing these skills from an early age, especially in educational settings, plays a decisive role in enhancing the career prospects and enabling young people to adapt to changes in the labor market (Ngwenya, 2024).
The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Improving Entrepreneurial Skills
In the last decade, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become an unparalleled tool for reinventing the way entrepreneurship skills are taught and developed, with researchers calling it a “leapfrogging factor in the entrepreneurial empowerment of the next generation.” Integrating smart technologies into the process of educating and training entrepreneurs not only personalizes and accelerates learning, but also has a profound and constructive presence at the four main levels of entrepreneurial competencies (personal characteristics, interpersonal skills, creative/critical skills, and executive/practical skills) (Masadeh et al., 2024).
Najmabadi et al., (2025) examined the impact of artificial intelligence on the development of life skills in students. The present study, using a review approach and qualitative content analysis, examined studies published between 2022 and 2024 on the impact of artificial intelligence on teaching life skills in students. The findings of this study show that AI technology can facilitate the development of cognitive, emotional, and social skills in learners by providing smart learning environments, content personalization, enabling rapid feedback, and enhancing teacher-student interaction. On the other hand, challenges such as the lack of appropriate infrastructure in many schools, inequality in access to technology, weak technical knowledge of teachers, ethical concerns in collecting and analyzing personal data, and lack of localized educational resources are considered obstacles to the effective use of this capacity. The prospective analysis of this article indicates that AI, if properly managed, developing ethical frameworks, and empowering human resources, can play a role as a powerful tool in improving the quality of skill-based education.
Azizi (2025) studied the impact of using AI systems on learners' learning efficiency. The findings of this study show that blockchain technology, visualizations, intelligent teaching systems, adaptation and personalization systems have a positive and significant effect on the efficiency of English language learning, while the effect of assessment and evaluation and teacher robots on improving the efficiency of language learning has been rejected, and it seems that from the perspective of educators and instructors, these systems cannot directly replace the entire teaching staff.
Research Methodology
The present study is applicable in terms of its purpose, descriptive-survey in terms of data collection, and correlational in terms of the relationships between variables. The statistical population of the present study includes 110 teachers from secondary schools in Districts 11 and 12 of Tehran, selected by purposive sampling method and a questionnaire was distributed among them. The collection tool in the present study includes a standard questionnaire, the validity of which was confirmed by experts and its reliability was confirmed by Cronbach's alpha coefficient.

Research findings
SPSS and PLS software were used to analyze the findings and test the hypotheses. The results showed that artificial intelligence has an impact on the development of entrepreneurial skills such as personal skills, creative and critical skills, interpersonal skills, and practical skills. Also, the GOF criterion method was used to fit the overall model; the value obtained was 0.723, which indicates a strong fit of the model.
Conclusion
The present study was conducted with the aim of evaluating the effectiveness of artificial intelligence in developing students' entrepreneurial skills. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Najmabadi et al., (2025), Mehdizadeh Mahali (2025), Sadeghi et al., (2025), Li (2025), Wan (2025), Azizi (2025), Rostam zadeh ganji & jayervandi (2025), and Pourshahabi (2023). Najmabadi et al., (2025) showed that AI technology can pave the way for the development of cognitive, emotional, and social skills in learners by providing smart learning environments, content personalization, enabling rapid feedback, and enhancing teacher-student interaction. On the other hand, challenges such as the lack of appropriate infrastructure in many schools, inequality in access to technology, weak technical knowledge of teachers, ethical concerns in collecting and analyzing personal data, and lack of localized educational resources are considered obstacles to the effective use of this capacity. The prospective analysis of this article indicates that AI, if properly managed, developing ethical frameworks, and empowering human resources, can play a role as a powerful tool in improving the quality of skill-based education.
According to the results obtained, it is suggested that entrepreneurship education programs be designed based on blended learning and using simulated environments based on AI. These environments should represent real issues and challenges of the Iranian labor market and innovative businesses in a localized manner so that students, while interacting with realistic scenarios, practice problem solving, decision making, and analyzing real situations. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Human Resource Management

Designing a model of employee job performance quality based on job engagement factors and positive behavior

Volume 7, Issue 3, Autumn 2025, Pages 346-362

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.550917.1583

Nargessadat Mirtajadini, Abbas Babaeinejad, Reza Zeinalzadeh, Saeed Sayadi

Abstract The aim of this study is to present a model of employee job performance quality based on job attachment factors and positive behavior. The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, quantitative in terms of implementation method, and descriptive-correlational in terms of nature and method. Employees of Islamic Azad Universities in the section 8 of the country, which were 1032 people, were used as the statistical population. Also, the sample size was estimated to be 284 people using the Karaji and Morgan table, and the sampling method at this stage was simple random. A standard questionnaire based on the 5-point Likert scale was used to collect research data. The content validity of the tool was confirmed by specialists and experts, and Cronbach's alpha and composite reliability were used to measure the reliability of the tool. By distributing the questionnaire, the validity of the tool was measured by the construct validity method (external model), convergent validity (AVE), and divergent validity. The AVE value for all variables should be greater than 0.5. SPSS and PLS software were used to analyze the data. The results showed that there is a significant relationship between job commitment and positive behavior with the way of the job tasks performance and its quality with employees, there is a significant relationship between job commitment and positive behavior with the level of employee commitment to work and responsibility, and there is a significant relationship between job commitment and positive behavior with the level of employee effort to achieve the organization's goals.
Introduction
Since the ninth decade of the twentieth century, a kind of reintegration between external and internal life has been taking shape. One of the important areas in which that integration has been raised is the business environment of organizations. Studies and research also show that providing a new paradigm for working in organizations is essential for work and life. In the 1970s, a new movement that promotes positive behavior as a characteristic of employees emerged, and among the new paradigms, the positive behavior paradigm in the workplace has gained considerable popularity in recent decades. According to many researchers, this new paradigm of the workplace is derived from quantum physics, cybernetics, chaos theory, cognitive sciences, Eastern and Western religions and rituals; and is in fact a reaction to the modern dry and mechanistic paradigm and has been considered one of the main trends in the 21st century (jung et al., 2021). This paradigm serves as a confirmation that employees enter the workplace with more than just their body and mind, and bring with them personal talent and unique spirit (Hong, 2019). From a social perspective, the most interesting thing for organizations is to have employees who do their jobs well. Good performance increases the productivity of the organization, which ultimately leads to an increase in the national economy (Abdulrahman et al., 2022). Performance is a composite construct according to which successful employees are characterized by a set of behaviors, so job performance is a multiple and broad criterion in which the set of carefully defined behaviors is used to express it (Pham et al., 2024). It is also believed that job performance is a composite construct based on which successful employees can be identified from unsuccessful ones through a set of specific criteria (Abdulrahman et al., 2022). One of the key factors affecting job performance is job engagement. Job engagement is a state of energy, enthusiasm, and focus that engages an individual in work activities. Employees with high job engagement feel meaningful and purposeful toward their tasks, are more resilient in the face of difficulties, and have a strong desire to grow and progress in the workplace (Akbari et al., 2023). Such a state causes the individual to be more motivated and enthusiastic about fulfilling organizational responsibilities, and as a result, the quality of job performance increases (Razmtalab et al., 2023). Job engagement is the perception that a person shows toward their work and dedicates their body and soul to their tasks, and the individual considers their job as the most important part of their life, and job satisfaction comes from performing their tasks. Greein et al. (2020) found that employees with high job engagement responded more to items related to internal factors, while employees who chose items related to external factors showed low job engagement. On the other hand, positive behavior is a set of positive characteristics and attitudes such as optimism, hope, trust, forgiveness, altruism, and satisfaction in work interactions that lead to the creation of a healthy and dynamic atmosphere in the organization. Employees who have a positive attitude not only show resilience and flexibility in the face of problems, but also help strengthen collective morale and increase organizational productivity by creating constructive and empathetic relationships in the workplace (Abdulrahman et al., 2022).
On the other hand, the higher education and university sector is considered one of the most important areas of sustainable development in human societies due to its direct connection with humans. Achieving this requires healthy, cheerful, and motivated employees. The effectiveness of the organization requires having competent employees who are interested in their jobs. Their desire increases the effort to achieve organizational goals. Organizational commitment, which is a consequence of work attachment, is the greatest human resource of universities that has a significant impact on increasing the quality of services. Dissatisfaction and lack of feeling of belonging and loyalty of employees to the organization leads to delays, absenteeism (psychological-physical), and leaving the organization, which, in addition to numerous costs, also affects the morale of other employees. Employee performance also affects the morale of other employees. Therefore, the basic question of this research is: What is the appropriate model for explaining the quality of job performance of employees of Islamic Azad Universities in the section eight of the country based on job attachment factors and positive behavior?
Theoretical foundations
Quality of job performance
Job performance is one of the most fundamental concepts in organizational behavior and human resource management, which refers to the degree of success of employees in performing job duties and achieving organizational goals. Employee performance is not only the result of skills and abilities, but also a combination of motivation, attitude, work environment conditions and organizational interactions (Vaghari et al., 2023). Job performance quality focuses on the qualitative dimensions of task performance and is related to accuracy, creativity, teamwork, sense of responsibility and adherence to professional standards at work. In this view, performance is divided into two categories: task and contextual; task performance refers to the correct and effective execution of activities directly related to the job description, while contextual performance includes behaviors that indirectly contribute to improving the workplace and increasing productivity, such as cooperation, discipline and initiative in solving problems (Sayyed Naghavi et al., 2023).
Job Engagement
Job engagement, as one of the central concepts in positive psychology and organizational behavior, refers to a positive state of mind in which employees immerse themselves in their work with high energy, enthusiasm, and focus (Soltani et al., 2020). A job-engaged individual considers their job to be part of their personal identity and that performing tasks is not just a responsibility for them, but also a source of meaning and inner satisfaction. This concept is opposed to indifference and job burnout and makes employees feel proud, excited, and dynamic about doing their work. (Akbari et al., 2023).
Positive Behavior
Positive behavior is a concept derived from the positive psychology approach that emphasizes the growth and flourishing of human capabilities. In the workplace, positive behavior refers to attitudes and behaviors that are based on optimism, hope, trust, resilience, and altruism (Luthans et al., 2024). Employees with a positive attitude see problems as opportunities, gain energy from interacting with others, and exhibit more constructive behaviors when faced with challenges (Haji et al., 2023).
Uraon et al. (2024) in a study titled "The Effect of Perceived Justice of Performance Appraisal Methods on Job Satisfaction and Intention to Stay: The Mediating Role of Job Commitment" examined the role of perceived justice in performance appraisal processes. Data were collected through 650 structured questionnaires among employees of 50 information technology companies, and 503 samples were analyzed. The analysis method was structural equation modeling with partial least squares. The results showed that the perception of justice of performance appraisal has a positive and significant effect on job satisfaction, intention to stay, and job enthusiasm. Also, job enthusiasm partially mediates between perceived justice and job satisfaction and intention to stay.
Research Methodology
This research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-correlational in terms of method. Employees of Islamic Azad Universities in the section eight of the country, numbering 1032, were used as the statistical population. Also, the sample size was estimated to be 284 using the Karaji and Morgan table, and the sampling method at this stage was simple random. To collect data, a standard questionnaire on a five-point Likert scale was used. The findings from the Cronbach's alpha test and composite reliability to measure the reliability of the research tool are reported in Table 2. To examine the validity of the tool, content validity (expert opinion) was used and its validity was confirmed. Then, by distributing the questionnaire, the validity of the tool was measured with three methods: construct validity (external model), convergent validity (AVE), and divergent validity. The AVE value for all research variables must be greater than 0.5. In order to test the research hypotheses, structural equation modeling was used in the context of the smart pls2 statistical software.
Research findings
The research findings showed that job engagement and positive behavior play an important and synergistic role in improving the quality of performance, increasing commitment and responsibility, and strengthening employees' efforts to achieve organizational goals. Employees who feel a sense of belonging and have a positive attitude toward their jobs perform their duties with greater accuracy, creativity, and discipline, and show higher motivation to achieve goals.
Discussion and Conclusion
The research findings showed that job engagement and positive behavior play a key and synergistic role in improving the quality of performance, increasing commitment and responsibility, and strengthening employees' efforts to achieve organizational goals. In other words, employees who feel a sense of belonging and have a positive attitude toward their jobs not only perform their duties with higher accuracy and quality, but also show greater commitment and strive with greater motivation to achieve organizational goals.
Data analysis showed that employees with high job commitment and positive attitudes perform their tasks with more accuracy, order, creativity, and responsibility. This finding is consistent with the studies of Ebadi et al. (2021) and Greein et al. (2020), which have introduced job commitment as a factor in improving the quality of job performance. Also, Luthans et al. (2024) showed that positive behavior improves problem solving and professional interactions. These findings emphasize that in order to improve the quality of performance; in addition to skills and knowledge, employees' psychological resources and positive attitudes should be strengthened. The results showed that employees who are committed and positive have a higher commitment to their work and carry out their responsibilities more seriously. This result is consistent with Uraon et al. (2024), which showed the mediating role of job enthusiasm in the relationship between perceived justice and job commitment. Positive behavior also increases the level of commitment and responsibility of employees by enhancing motivation and resilience. These findings confirm the importance of creating a supportive and positive work environment to maintain commitment and reduce employee turnover. The findings showed that job engagement and positive attitude increase employees' effort to achieve organizational goals. These results are consistent with Jiang et al. (2024) and Rego et al. (2021), who showed that positive attitude and intrinsic motivation enhance employees' active participation and effort to achieve goals. Therefore, cultivating attachment and positive attitude not only affects the quality of tasks, but also the purposeful effort of employees. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

management

Analysis of key treatment indicators on the establishment of a civil participation system in the Iranian Martyr Foundation.

Volume 8, Issue 1, Spring 2026, Pages 350-375

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.485685.1432

Seifollah Zarei, Morad Rezaei Dizgah, Mehrdad Goudarzvand Chagini

Abstract The purpose of this research is to conduct a analysis of key indicators affecting the establishment of a civil participation system within Iran’s Martyrs Foundation (Boniad-e Shahid) Organization. This study is applicable in terms of its objective, and is executed quantitatively with an inductive approach, based on the philosophy of positivism. The population under study consists of articles published in scientific-research journals concerning the establishment of a civil participation system for knowledge sharing, conducted domestically from 2009 to 2023. Sampling was performed based on the necessary criteria for the analysis process, and accordingly, 22 studies were selected. For data analysis, the analysis method and CMA (Comprehensive Analysis) software were used. The findings of this review indicate that the aforementioned variables act as key indicators of the civil participation system and have a reciprocal influence on each other. Strengthening these factors can lead to an improvement in the quality of civil participation and the creation of a democratic and sustainable society. In this regard, paying attention to these variables in social and economic policies and planning is of particular importance.
Introduction
Effective business in establishing a civil participation system refers to a set of activities and processes designed to promote societal engagement and strengthen social and economic cooperation. These types of businesses can contribute to achieving civil participation goals by creating suitable platforms, facilitating communication, and increasing public awareness. Civil participation means the active and effective involvement of individuals and groups in decision-making processes, planning, and the implementation of social and economic projects. This type of participation can include volunteer activities, membership in social organizations, and cooperation with government and private entities. Businesses can help strengthen civil participation by creating job opportunities, providing financial resources, and offering the necessary infrastructure. Participation is the foundation of civil society and will never lose its vital importance for a society that aspires to progress (Dashti, 2022). Participation is a human right that, in terms of its ultimate goal, leads to liberation and self-reliance, and in terms of its instrumental value, leads to the mobilization and engagement of human masses in the practical processes of social life. Participation is an essential and fundamental aspect of human development. It is the development of self-confidence, initiative, pride, activity, responsibility, and social cooperation (Ghafari, 2012). Civil participation refers to activities undertaken by ordinary citizens aimed at influencing societal conditions that affect others, outside the family and circle of friends. Individuals participate in society in several ways: they engage in political discussions, follow political issues, make financial contributions, and more. Individuals help others through volunteer work, thereby solving local problems or creating opportunities for specific groups in society (Thelma, 2024). The term "participation" has a historical root and background, as much as the term "democracy." Participation makes it possible for implemented policies to align with the real desires of the people, thereby enhancing and improving the quality of people's lives and preventing dissatisfaction (Hosseini & Ziaei, 2023). Civil participation, which in its broad sense encompasses various individual and group actions aimed at intervening in self-determination and societal destiny and influencing decision-making processes related to public affairs, has received significant attention in recent years in such a way that almost all development strategies mention participation as a key element (Sarookhani & Amirpanahi, 2006). This analysis can help understand the reasons for discrepancies among the findings of previous research. From an applicable perspective, this research can also assist managers in establishing appropriate and integrated infrastructure and prerequisites to facilitate the establishment of a civil participation system within the organization. In this regard, the research question is posed as follows: What are the key indicators of the civil participation system in Iran's Martyrs Foundation (Boniad-e Shahid) Organization?
Theoretical Framework
Civil Participation
The phenomenon of participation is the first social behavior observed in humans. The discussion of participation can begin with the self-evident principle that any historical experience of democracy has been shaped by the presence and intervention of various civil individuals, groups, and institutions; through the fulfillment of civic duty (Abassim & Esbati, 2021). Participation, especially civil one, is a broad concept whose tangible realization requires various individual or social activities that influence the decision-making and strategies of executive bodies, from lower levels (municipalities, educational systems, etc.) to higher levels (high executive, legislative, and judicial authorities) (Edrisi & Shojai, 2012).
Thelma (2024) examined civic education and citizen participation in local government. This study showed that civic education impacts citizen participation in local governance. A point to consider is that civic knowledge enables citizens to make correct decisions about their rights, which helps them understand their role in governmental systems. Furthermore, the study explored that when civic education is absent at all levels, citizen participation in local government cannot exist because citizens are not empowered. Therefore, this study recommends that civic education should be provided at all levels, from high school to community levels, to empower citizens.
Zarei & Roayaei (24) examined the jurisprudential aspects of civil participation contracts and analyzed their jurisprudential challenges using an ijtihadi (independent legal reasoning) method. The research results indicate that the most significant and fundamental jurisprudential challenge of this contract is the transformation of the jurisprudential nature of the partnership contract from a participatory contract to an exchange contract. In critiquing the contract’s provisions, 13 jurisprudential objections were raised, the most important of which include issues such as the client’s gratuitous management of company assets, the commitment to compensate for damages, the obligation for the client to purchase the company, responsibility for compensating losses arising from judicial action, pledging before the debt is proven, guaranteeing the trustee, and undertaking to pay potential costs. The most significant executive challenges include the risk of poor selection, supervisory problems, valuation of non-cash assets, and changes in economic conditions and market risk. In this regard, to resolve the aforementioned problems and optimally utilize the capacity of the participation contract, it was proposed that, by reforming the channels through which money enters the bank via contract amendments and training and briefing staff, managers, and the public; the channels for money entering the banking system should also be differentiated. This would increase the specialization of banks in specific areas and enhance the quality of their work.
Research Methodology
This research is applicable in terms of its objective, and quantitative in terms of execution method, with an inductive approach and a positivist philosophy. The population under study for this research consists of articles published in scientific-research journals in the field of establishing a knowledge-sharing civil participation system from 2009 to 2023, which have been conducted domestically. Sampling was performed based on the criteria required for entering the analysis process, and accordingly, 22 cases were selected.
Research Findings
To analyze the data, the analysis method and CMA software were used. The findings of this review indicate that the aforementioned variables act as key indicators of the civil participation system and have a reciprocal impact on each other. Strengthening these factors can lead to an improvement in the quality of civil participation and the creation of a democratic and stable society. In this regard, attention to these variables in social and economic policies and planning is of special importance.
Conclusion
The present research was conducted with the aim of a analysis of the key indicators affecting the establishment of the civil participation system in Iran’s Martyrs Foundation (Boniad-e Shahid) Organization. The results of this research are in line with the findings of the studies by Thelma (2024), Zarei & Roayaei (2024), Gonzalez-Mohino et al. (2023), Zarei et al. (2023), Hatami Khaljan et al. (2023), Alva (2023), Meysami (2022), Noroozi & Jalali (2021), Amouzad Khaili et al. (2018), and Mahmoudnejad & Omidghani (2013). Gonzalez-Mohino et al. (2023) believe that cooperation plays a vital role in institutional arrangements to encourage citizens’ participation. Likewise, structures and guidelines that facilitate the flow of information between citizens and the government increase participation. The researcher found that local managers can increase citizen participation by creating participatory structures such as neighborhood organizations. The socio-economic base (income, education, and civic orientation) has a deep relationship with the level of participation. Those with a higher base have more access to resources, better interpersonal skills, and more social interactions. Furthermore, there is a significant relationship between civic orientation, especially the dimensions of self-efficacy and trust, and participation.
Based on the research results, the following suggestions are presented:
It is suggested to managers to implement desirable cultural changes to facilitate the implementation of programs in the Martyrs Foundation (Boniad-e Shahid) Organization and to provide a suitable platform for removing inappropriate cultural factors that are not aligned with the strategic plan. Also, in order to formulate and implement a desirable strategic plan in the Martyrs Foundation (Boniad-e Shahid), it is necessary to identify and explain the existing cultural factors, and also to make appropriate changes in the organizational culture so that it becomes a culture aligned and compatible with the new organizational requirements, thereby enhancing civil participation in the organization.

Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work.
Data Availability Statement
The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
AI Use Statement
The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript.
Funding
The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript.
Ethics Approval
All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Education Management

Investigating the impact of entrepreneurial school dimensions on students' entrepreneurial competencies with an emphasis on the mediating role of interaction with industry

Volume 7, Issue 2, Summer 2025, Pages 357-376

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.412851.1239

Neda Tarabpur

Abstract The present study has identified and prioritized indicators of unexpected actions of entrepreneurial students at Mazandaran University by means of a mixed research design (qualitative and quantitative). To collect data, interviews with experts were used in the qualitative step, and a questionnaire derived from the qualitative step of the research was used in the quantitative step. The statistical population of the research in the qualitative phase was university professors and managers of technological and entrepreneurial units at the University of Mazandaran, and in the quantitative phase, 20 entrepreneurial students at the same University. Snowball sampling was used to select research samples; and data were collected based on 15 in-depth interviews with experts related to the research topic. The Brown and Clark (2006) content and pattern analysis method was used to analyze data in the qualitative step; and in the quantitative step, the best-worst BWM method was used. The findings of the thematic analysis on the unexpected actions of entrepreneurial students at the University of Mazandaran are presented in 4 main themes: (1- Dynamics and Adaptability 2- Exploration and Empowerment 3- Learning and Innovation in Problem Solving 4- Development and Customer Relationship) and 53 sub-themes. In the quantitative step, dynamism and adaptability with a weight of 0.416 was the first priority, exploration and empowerment with a weight of 0.227 was the second priority, learning and innovation in problem solving with a weight of 0.17 was the third priority, and development and customer relationship with a weight of 0.136 was the fourth priority according to the experts. The results of the present study showed that entrepreneurs must have the ability to quickly recognize opportunities and threats, and these decisions must be based on a precise analysis of data and the current situation.
Introduction
The dimensions of an entrepreneurial school, including entrepreneurial leadership, flexible curriculum, innovative organizational culture, interactive learning environment, communication network with stakeholders, and provision of support resources, play a role as a system in promoting entrepreneurial competencies. However, most indicators and policies of traditional schools focus solely on increasing theoretical knowledge and improving GPA, and less emphasis is placed on entrepreneurial skills and attitudes; this has created a serious gap between the general education system and the real needs of society and the labor market (Iqbal et al., 2021).
Beyond the internal and structural dimensions of the school, the role of active engagement with industry as a bridge between education and practice is crucial. Engagement with industry includes visitation schemes, internships, the presence of industrial mentors, joint projects, and even real project-based learning that can make students’ learning meaningful and effective. From this perspective, engagement with industry is not only a complementary tool but also an important mediating factor that can facilitate or strengthen the impact of entrepreneurial school dimensions on students’ entrepreneurial competencies (Luo et al., 2022). Internal research has mainly focused on skill training or entrepreneurial tendencies, and has rarely linked the structure and function of the school ecosystem with real and systematic engagement with industry. While global research has empirically proven the importance of linking the school with the industrial and economic environment in promoting the effectiveness of entrepreneurship education (Chahal et al., 2024).
The dimensions of the entrepreneurial school, including entrepreneurial leadership, flexible curriculum, innovative organizational culture, interactive learning environment, communication network with stakeholders, and provision of support resources, play a role as a system in promoting entrepreneurial competencies. However, most indicators and policies of traditional schools focus solely on increasing theoretical knowledge and improving GPA, and less emphasis is placed on entrepreneurial skills and attitudes; this has created a serious gap between the general education system and the real needs of society and the labor market (Iqbal et al., 2021).
Therefore, the main question of this research is: What effect do the dimensions of the entrepreneurial school have on students' entrepreneurial competencies, emphasizing the role of mediator in interaction with industry?
Theoretical Framework
The Impact of Entrepreneurial Culture and Perspective on Students' Entrepreneurial Competencies
A school with an entrepreneurial culture and perspective not only creates an environment for entrepreneurial growth, but also plays a key role in internalizing entrepreneurial beliefs and promoting students' multidimensional competencies; so that graduates of such schools have a dynamic, flexible, and highly motivated approach to new opportunities, environmental challenges, and individual and collective development paths (Kanaan-Jebna et al., 2022).
The impact of entrepreneurial leadership and management on students' entrepreneurial competencies
A school whose management and leadership are creative and entrepreneurial, while strengthening participation and freethinking in the educational environment, fosters fundamental entrepreneurial competencies such as "innovation, problem solving, risk-taking, effective interaction, and independent decision-making" among students and prepares them for successful entry into the innovative and economic arenas of society (Kanaan-Jebna et al., 2022).
The Impact of the Entrepreneurship Curriculum and Experiential Learning on Students' Entrepreneurial Competencies
By providing a structured platform for practical experience, failure, and innovation; the entrepreneurship curriculum and experiential learning make a fundamental contribution to the formation and strengthening of competencies such as innovation, flexibility, problem solving and change management, motivation for progress, and leadership skills in students; and prepare them to actively and successfully face real-world challenges and opportunities (Obi et al., 2022).
The impact of entrepreneurial school dimensions on interaction with industry
Joint programs, the presence of industry experts and entrepreneurs in the educational environment, and the implementation of interactive projects increase the opportunity for students to benefit from current experiences and real industry needs. As a result, the more the entrepreneurial school can develop and institutionalize the aforementioned dimensions, the more students' readiness for employment and entry into the labor market will be improved, and a more effective link will be formed between the educational institution and the industry sector, which will provide a suitable arena for the growth of innovation, entrepreneurship, and economic development (Brekke, 2021).
Sadeghi et al. (2025) presented a model for empowering entrepreneurial school administrators with an artificial intelligence approach. Based on the research findings, a paradigmatic model was presented for empowering entrepreneurial school principals using artificial intelligence, the dimensions of which included causal conditions (such as optimizing decision-making, analyzing student learning behavior, strategic planning, creating a dynamic educational environment, utilizing appropriate training, and learning future skills), central phenomenon (such as empowering entrepreneurial school principals with an artificial intelligence approach), contextual conditions (such as three axes including familiarity with network leadership, educational platforms, and innovation fields), intervening conditions (such as weak infrastructure, managers' lack of sufficient mastery of artificial intelligence tools, lack of organizational data, resistance to technological changes, and lack of sufficient resources), strategies (such as the availability of artificial intelligence tools, strengthening skills in using them, institutionalizing a culture of innovative collaboration, teaching planning with smart technology, and familiarity with new feedback methods), and consequences (such as the productivity of entrepreneurial education, excellence in school performance, branding entrepreneurial schools, and improving the effectiveness of educational processes).
Li (2025) investigated the Entrepreneurship Skill-Augmented Neural Network (ESANN): deep learning approach to enhance entrepreneurship competencies in teachers. Comparative experimental results show that the proposed hybrid model significantly outperforms traditional evaluation methods in several criteria and provides a more comprehensive and accurate understanding of the effectiveness of innovation and entrepreneurship education in higher education institutions.
Research Methodology
The present study is applicable in terms of purpose and, descriptive-survey in terms of data collection, and correlational in terms of relationships between variables. The statistical population of the present study includes 95 principals and teachers of secondary schools in Districts 8 and 9 of Tehran, selected by purposive sampling method and a questionnaire was distributed among them. The collection tool in the present study is a questionnaire whose validity was confirmed by experts and its reliability by Cronbach's alpha coefficient.
Research findings
SmartPLS3 statistical software was used to analyze data and test hypotheses. The findings of this study show that the curriculum and experiential learning of entrepreneurship, entrepreneurial culture and outlook, and entrepreneurial leadership and management have a significant effect on students' entrepreneurial competencies. In indirect hypotheses, entrepreneurial leadership and management and entrepreneurial culture and outlook have a significant effect on students' entrepreneurial competencies with an emphasis on interaction with industry. However, the curriculum and experiential learning do not have a mediating role on students' entrepreneurial competencies with an emphasis on the mediating role of interaction with industry.
Conclusion
The present study was conducted to investigate the effect of dimensions of the entrepreneurial school on students' entrepreneurial competencies with an emphasis on the mediating role of interaction with industry. These results are consistent with the studies of Chlebiej (2023), Liu et al. (2024), Obi (2022), Sadeghi et al. (2025), Li (2025), Liu et al. (2024), Khalili et al. (2023), Ghafrani et al. (2022), and Luo et al. (2022). Luo et al. (2022) showed that entrepreneurial environment, entrepreneurial competence, and entrepreneurial education play a positive role in university students' entrepreneurial self-efficacy. Therefore, this paper proposes that entrepreneurship education should be promoted by creating a good innovative and entrepreneurial environment, establishing a talent education model based on the entrepreneurial competence model and establishing a high-quality entrepreneurship education system.
According to the results obtained, it is suggested: Development of leadership competencies and entrepreneurial culture: It is necessary for school administrators and teachers to take courses in the field of entrepreneurial leadership and promotion of innovation culture so that they can blend the educational environment with entrepreneurial values ​​and effective interaction with industry. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Education Management

Presenting the model of work and technology curriculum in secondary schools of Fars province

Volume 6, Issue 3, Autumn 2024, Pages 336-355

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2024.453045.1351

Hamzeh Rahpeyma, Seyedahmad Hashemi, Abbas Gholtash

Abstract Abstract The purpose of this research is to examine the presentation of the curriculum model of work and technology in secondary schools of Fars province. The current research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-survey in terms of nature and method. The statistical population of this research includes 450 people from all secondary school teachers who teach in the field of work and technology, and 210 people were selected as a sample using Morgan's table. The collection tool in the current research includes a researcher-made questionnaire derived from the qualitative method, which has 4 dimensions: goals (oriented to the educational system, attention to needs assessment, mental ability of the learner, learning time); content (curiosity, meaningful learning, learner characteristics, functional ability); teaching method (problem solving method, work unit (project), small groups, demonstration method); and evaluation (increasing skills, academic progress, increasing job skills, communication skills). The reliability of the research was checked and confirmed using Cronbach's alpha criterion in SPSS software. Lisrel software was used to fit the conceptual model of the research. The research findings showed that according to the values ​​of standard coefficients and significant t coefficients, it can be said that the goals and content component (β = 0.63) has a significant role in the model, and the teaching and evaluation method component (β = 0.22) has a significant role in the program model of curriculum work and technology in secondary school. All the indicators are very favorable, and the model has a good fit with the data, indicating that there is a linear relationship between the variables. Extended abstract Introduction Since the communication networks of various markets have connected the production and supply of services at the national, regional, and global levels, and considered competitiveness to be the key to entering the global markets, it is obvious that in this global competition, not only countries, but all institutions and people should constantly increase their competitiveness and adaptability (Klofsten et al, 2019). Meanwhile, the attention of many policymakers and political decision makers has been focused on the potential role of entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurship is a process that is known as the key factor of economic growth and development in the modern era, and at the center of international competition are entrepreneurial companies whose competitive edge is focused on organizational flexibility and the strategy of continuous change in processes, products and plans (Tehrani) et al., 2021). To achieve this goal, it seems necessary to cultivate creative ideas and entrepreneurs who can adapt themselves to the new world. The phenomenon of growth and development is serious in the societies that are dynamic and alive with educational and research centers and have a two-way relationship with them and there is movement, innovation and innovation in them. Of course, the real position of education is determined when its role in all-round development such as cultural, social, economic, and political development is also considered (Kalali & Zarkani, 2019). The idea of ​​paying attention to work and technology education has created a lot of enthusiasm in the last few decades, and many effects have been mentioned for this attention, among the most important of which results such as economic growth, job creation, individual growth, increased participation of school in providing services, improving the quality of services and activities can be mentioned (Aslani, 2023). Education of work and technology in schools helps students find an entrepreneurial mindset and expand the knowledge and skills necessary to develop the culture of work and technology in the society. Therefore, the researcher is trying to answer the question: what is the model of work and technology curriculum in secondary schools of Fars province? Theoretical Framework Curriculum Curriculum is actually the proposed educational program that shows how to lead the learner in the direction that is preferred for his growth, and relies on the value system, and the curriculum is a tool to achieve the ideals, realize goals, and fulfill educational objectives. The curriculum deals with the learning outcomes and not only with the predetermined goals but also with the results because the results - in the evaluation position - can include things other than the intended goals and results, and different people may be affected by the set of predetermined measures in different ways (Gholami et al, 2019). Work and technology education in curriculum planning Vocational training can be the main part of the curriculum with a part of the graduation course or a part of other courses. This type of education should be an integral part of all stages of education and training and should be provided through an organized and graded program. (Hashemi et al, 2019). The purpose of teaching work and technology in schools is not only to set up business and work and technology for profit; rather, work and technology is a way of life that is used in all aspects of a person's personal, organizational and social life. Students are the employees, officials, managers and entrepreneurs in the future of the country; if they become familiar with these topics, they will act better at making life and career decisions for themselves, dealing with entrepreneurs and solving their problems. Teacher-oriented education is replaced with Practice-oriented activists of work and technology; so that students become familiar with work and technology through activities and involvement (Fereydun Nezhad, 2023). Zanganeh et al, (2024) investigated the design of the curriculum model of virtual schools in the second period of secondary school in Khaf city. The results showed that school curriculum design includes 6 components: curriculum goals, curriculum content, curriculum evaluation, curriculum learning-teaching flows, curriculum strategies, degree of curriculum suitability; and the results of model fit statistics show that the obtained values for each of the indicators shows a very good fit of the model. Mortazavi Amiri et al, (2023) investigated the design of a dynamic professional learning environment based on an interdisciplinary curriculum with the approach of the effectiveness of knowledge creators in order to provide a model. The results showed that all the components of the dynamic professional learning environment in the field of interdisciplinary lesson planning were identified, and their meaningful dimension was confirmed in the research, and the model of the dynamic professional learning environment was explained based on interdisciplinary lesson planning with an effective approach of knowledge creation by examining the themes, concepts and quantitative and qualitative research. Research methodology The current research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-survey in terms of nature and method. The statistical population of this research includes 450 people from all secondary school teachers who teach in the field of work and technology, and 210 people were selected as a sample using Morgan's table. The collection tool in the current research includes a researcher-made questionnaire derived from the qualitative method, which has 4 dimensions: goals (oriented to the educational system, attention to needs assessment, mental ability of the learner, learning time); content (curiosity, meaningful learning, learner characteristics, functional ability); teaching method (problem solving method, work unit (project), small groups, demonstration method); and evaluation (increasing skills, academic progress, increasing job skills, communication skills). Research findings The reliability of the research was checked and confirmed using Cronbach's alpha criterion in SPSS software. Lisrel software was used to fit the conceptual model of the research. The research findings showed that according to the values ​​of standard coefficients and significant t coefficients, it can be said that the goals and content component (β = 0.63) has a significant role in the model, and the teaching and evaluation method component (β = 0.22) has a significant role in the program model of curriculum work and technology in secondary school. All the indicators are very favorable, and the model has a good fit with the data, indicating that there is a linear relationship between the variables. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of investigating the presentation of the curriculum model of work and technology in secondary schools of Fars province. The results of this research are in agreement with the results of Zanganeh et al, (2024), Mortazavi amiri et al, (2023), Mastali et al, (2023), Rajaei (2023), Eisner (2022), Gholamiyan & Farashbandi (2022), Aslan et al, (2021), and Kusumaningtyas et al, (2018). Mortazavi amiri et al, (2023) showed that all the components of the dynamic professional learning environment in the field of interdisciplinary curriculum planning were identified, and the model of the dynamic professional learning environment was explained based on interdisciplinary lesson planning with an effective approach of knowledge creation by examining the themes, concepts and quantitative and qualitative research. According to the present research, the following suggestions are presented: - Teachers ask students to express their experiences in different issues and share them. For this purpose, some parts of the class's time should be allocated to share the experiences and opinions of the students. - Teachers' theoretical and specialized knowledge should be evaluated, and sufficient and complete reports should be provided to school principals and assistants every semester. This should be done by internal evaluators in schools.

management

Analysis and standardization of technical skills indicators of junior secondary school teachers

Volume 7, Issue 1, Spring 2025, Pages 376-393

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.491610.1449

Farzad Eskandari Nasab, Khadijeh Abu Al-Maali Al-Husseini, Fariborz Dortaj, Fariborz Bagheri

Abstract The aim of this research is to analyze and Normalize technical skills indicators of junior high school teachers. The present research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-contextualization in terms of method. The statistical population of the research includes all junior high school teachers in the four districts of Karaj in 2021, from which a sample of 329 teachers was selected. The sampling method is cluster random method. A researcher-made questionnaire was used to collect information. SPSS and AMOS software were used to analyze the data. The findings indicate that each component of the teachers' technical skills questionnaire, which includes: consulting skills, teaching and classroom management skills, evaluation skills, and information and communication technology skills, has a desirable internal consistency. Therefore, it was concluded that each of the items has the necessary power to measure the components of teachers' technical skills, and each of the components has an acceptable power to measure the more general factor, namely teachers' technical skills.
Introduction
Since education is the most important tool for achieving advanced scientific development, teachers must also face this reality like other groups (Ramírez Montoya et al, 2021). The rapid changes in contemporary life necessitate the need for up-to-date and technological education and preparation to face, accept or reject, and coordinate with changes in various dimensions of life (Ali Ahmadi, 2016). Therefore, the success of any educational system depends more than any other factor on the knowledge and skills of its teachers, and they must update their knowledge throughout their professional lives (Zaragoza et al, 2021). To achieve a desirable and purposeful education, it is necessary to provide targeted activities with a deep insight and by obtaining fully specialized qualifications based on comprehensive and professional studies, taking into account various aspects of knowledge, skills and new achievements of science and technology and using new tools and methods. To realize these activities and programs, a general, continuous and comprehensive effort is needed from various factors in the educational system so that the above complex can achieve its goals more and have a positive and greater impact on improving the quality of education (Elhami et al, 2023).
Teachers' skills and competencies depend on having a combination of types of competencies that are influenced by teachers' individual capabilities and competencies, and include educational competencies, personal competencies, professional competencies, and social competencies (Ababaf et al, 2018), some of which are the teacher's mastery of subject knowledge and are considered fundamental competencies and skills (Murray et al, 2015). Some are behaviors and performance that direct competencies and skills towards models (Mehralizadeh, 2018). In this regard, one of the skills required in these areas is communication, which requires the use of communication skills. Communication skills are those skills through which individuals can engage in interpersonal interactions and the communication process. That is, the process through which individuals share their information, thoughts, and feelings through verbal and non-verbal exchange (Hamedi Nasab & Asgari, 2018). Therefore, the present study seeks to evaluate this research issue, which is: how to analyze and standardize the technical skills indicators of junior high school teachers?
Theoretical framework
Teachers' technical skills
The effectiveness of teachers depends on having a combination of technical skills. Some of these teaching skills are influenced by the individual capabilities and competencies of teachers (Altan et al, 2018). Although there are many common technical and specialized skills that should be pursued by setting the right goals, categorizing them in different dimensions, drawing a roadmap, and under the shadow of effectiveness and efficiency, teachers with skills must have the ability to use and correctly select these techniques. Using and adapting different types of skills creatively and creating basic programs using technical skills are requirements for a teacher. Some experts believe that if education is to progress, education professionals, especially teachers, who have extensive interaction with learners, must change. Also, their knowledge and information, cognitions, attitudes, skills, and working methods must change (Ramezani & Amini, 2022).
Molina-Moreno et al, (2024) investigated the analysis of personal competencies in teachers. Their results showed that activities aimed at strengthening teachers' personal competencies have a positive impact on areas such as job satisfaction, professional commitment, emotional management, and stress reduction, which have a favorable effect on students. However, the effectiveness of these interventions may vary depending on the study design and individual characteristics of the participants.
Khalifelo et al, (2024) investigated the impact of teachers' classroom management skills on the teaching-learning process. They showed that teachers' classroom management skills significantly affect the teaching-learning process of students. Teachers with strong classroom management skills can create a suitable and orderly learning environment that increases students' concentration, participation, and motivation. These skills also help teachers manage instructional time more effectively and prevent it from being wasted. As a result, effective classroom management by teachers will lead to improved academic achievement of students. In general, teachers' classroom management skills have a significant impact on the teaching-learning process of students. These skills help teachers to create an orderly and constructive environment in the classroom, manage instructional time effectively, increase student motivation and participation, and ultimately lead to improved academic achievement. Therefore, developing and strengthening classroom management skills in teachers should be considered a priority in order to make the teaching-learning process in schools more effective.
Research Methodology
The present research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-contextualization in terms of method. The statistical population of the research includes all junior high school teachers in the four districts of Karaj in 2021, from which a sample of 329 teachers was selected. The sampling method is cluster random method. A researcher-made questionnaire was used to collect data.
Research findings
SPSS and AMOS software were used to analyze the data. The findings indicate that each component of the teachers' technical skills questionnaire, which includes: consulting skills, teaching and classroom management skills, evaluation skills, and information and communication technology skills, has a desirable internal consistency. Therefore, it was concluded that each of the items has the necessary power to measure the components of teachers' technical skills, and each of the components has an acceptable power to measure the more general factor, namely teachers' technical skills.
Conclusion
The present study was conducted with the aim of analyzing and normalizing the indicators of technical skills of junior high school teachers. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Molina-Moreno et al, (2024), Khalifelo et al, (2024), Rezaei et al, (2023), Hoshyar et al, (2023), Rezazadeh et al, (2023), Azarboueh & Nastiezaie (2022), Kalantaripour & Modiri Khameneh (2021), Namaziandost et al, (2021), Talebi Khansari (2020), and Vilcaste (2019). Khalifelo et al, (2024) showed that teachers' classroom management skills significantly affect the teaching-learning process of students. Teachers with strong classroom management skills can create an appropriate and orderly learning environment that increases students' focus, participation, and motivation. These skills also help teachers manage instructional time more effectively and prevent it from being wasted. Consequently, effective classroom management by teachers will lead to improved student achievement. Overall, teachers' classroom management skills have a significant impact on students' teaching-learning process. These skills help teachers create an orderly and productive classroom environment, manage instructional time effectively, increase student motivation and participation, and ultimately lead to improved academic achievement. Therefore, developing and strengthening classroom management skills in teachers should be considered a priority in order to make the teaching-learning process in schools more effective.
It is suggested that, considering the importance of teachers' influence on students and considering that knowledge and skills can be acquired, learned, and transferred, there is a need to seriously discuss and examine the characteristics and methods of training teachers in order to develop and enhance their competence, so that more justified principles and programs can be developed for training competent teachers who are up-to-date and compatible with rapid developments. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Education Management

The mediating role of creative self-efficacy in the relationship between organizational intelligence and organizational agility of teachers

Volume 6, Issue 2, Summer 2024, Pages 387-408

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2024.462883.1381

Abbas Gholtash

Abstract The purpose of this research was to explain the mediating role of creative self-efficacy in the relationship between organizational intelligence and organizational agility. This research was applicable in terms of purpose, and correlational in terms of nature and method. The statistical population of this research includes all primary teachers in Sarchehan, whose number was more than 160. Using Morgan's table and stratified random sampling, 113 people were selected as the sample size. The data collection tool was Zhang's organizational agility questionnaire, Karoski's et al,.'s creative self-efficacy, and Albrecht's organizational intelligence questionnaire. To analyze the data, the significance test of Pearson's correlation coefficient and simple regression analysis as well as hierarchical regression by Baron-Kenney method were used. The findings showed that creative self-efficacy can be predicted by organizational intelligence. Organizational agility can be predicted by organizational intelligence. Organizational agility can be predicted by creative self-efficacy. Creative self-efficacy plays a significant mediating role in the relationship between the variables of organizational intelligence and organizational agility.
Extended abstract
Introduction
Agility is called the organization's ability to face unexpected changes (Akkaya, 2021). There are various variables that make an organization become an agile organization, one of them is self-efficacy, which was first proposed by Bandura. Creative self-efficacy affects the actual power of the person when facing challenges by determining the beliefs of a person about his power to influence situations. Self-efficacy employees can easily hunt environmental opportunities and create an agile organization (Mirzazadeh, 2021). Another variable considered in this research is organizational intelligence. Organizational intelligence refers to the capacity of an organization as a whole to collect information, innovate, produce knowledge and act effectively based on the knowledge it has produced (Af Malmborg, 2021). Despite extensive research in the field of organizational intelligence and organizational agility, there are significant gaps in previous researches. Most of these researches have investigated each of these components separately and paid less attention to the mediating role of creative self-efficacy. Also, few studies have been conducted in the field of primary education, especially in less developed areas such as Sarchehan. This indicates the need for more comprehensive and focused research on the interactions between these components in these specific environments. Investigating these gaps and trying to fill them can lead to a better understanding of how to improve organizational agility by enhancing creative self-efficacy and organizational intelligence. Therefore, the main problem of the present research is raised as follows: Does creative self-efficacy play a mediating role in the relationship between organizational intelligence and organizational agility of elementary school teachers in Sarchehan city?
 Theoretical framework
Agility
Organizational agility refers to a combination of flexibility, agility and speed. This structure is defined as the organization's ability to respond to changes and maximize opportunities (Ridwandono & Subriadi, 2019). An agile organization combines organizational processes and people with up-to-date technology to meet customer needs for providing quality services and products in a short and appropriate time (Tarba et al, 2023). Agile organizations can be influenced by the creative self-efficacy of their employees. Creative self-efficacy is a term that refers to the ability of people to use creativity and innovation in order to achieve goals and solve various problems. This concept includes a combination of two important features, i.e. self-efficacy and creativity. Self-efficacy means believing in one's ability to perform tasks and face challenges, while creativity refers to the ability to generate new ideas and find different solutions to existing problems (Jalali and Heydarifard, 2020). The history of creative self-efficacy dates back recent decades, because during this period, attention to the needs of a dynamic and advanced society and the needs of the labor market has increased more than ever (Puente-Diaz et al, 2024).
Creative self-efficacy:
The term creative self-efficacy is derived from the term and theoretical context of self-efficacy introduced and defined by Bandura (1997). Bandura defines self-efficacy as "an individual's belief that he can function successfully in a specific environment." Accordingly, we define creative self-efficacy as a person's belief in their ability to produce creative results in a specific environment or in general.
Bandura claims that self-efficacy is a strong condition for creative performance, because self-efficacy increases motivation that prioritizes weight and emphasis on one's own thinking and action (Brockhus et al, 2014). Therefore, individual motivation stimulates two aspects; first, choosing a specific behavior; and second, following that type of behavior. There are other concepts with similar meaning, such as self-image, self-esteem and self-confidence. All of these concepts are related to people's overall self-image, but creative self-efficacy differs insofar as it relates to specific creativity self-efficacy, which, we hypothesize, is different from general self-efficacy; a person's overall belief. The ability to successfully cope with the demands of different tasks in different domains was proposed by Shaw et al, (2021). More theoretical considerations about the relationship between self-efficacy and creativity are proposed by Ford [1996], who considers self-efficacy as a key motivational component in his model of defined individual creative action (Karofsky et al, 2016).
Organizational intelligence:
Organizational intelligence is a new concept in the field of management organization and 21st century literature. Karel Albreckt explained this concept in 2002 in the book Power of Mind at Work. Albrecht defines organizational intelligence as the talent and capacity of an organization in the movement of its mental power and the concentration of this mental power in realizing the mission of the organization. According to Albrecht's law, under the title of group stupidity, it can be stated that organizations, in addition to threatening their competitors and their environment, also move towards harming themselves (Nasabi, 2008). Karl Albrecht, in order to succeed in business, refers to having three factors: smart people, smart teams, and smart organization (Abazari, 2006, p25). In relation to organizational intelligence, different definitions have been proposed by many experts, some of them are mentioned below.
Halal considers organizational intelligence to be the result of five subsystems of organizational structure, culture, stakeholder relations, knowledge management, and strategic processes (Halal, 2007).
Research methodology
This research was applicable in terms of purpose, and correlational in terms of nature and method. The statistical population of this research includes all primary teachers in Sarchehan, whose number was more than 160. Using Morgan's table and stratified random sampling, 113 people were selected as the sample size. The data collection tool was Zhang's organizational agility questionnaire, Karoski's et al,.'s creative self-efficacy, and Albrecht's organizational intelligence questionnaire. To analyze the data, the significance test of Pearson's correlation coefficient and simple regression analysis as well as hierarchical regression by Baron-Kenney method were used.
Research findings
The findings showed that creative self-efficacy can be predicted by organizational intelligence. Organizational agility can be predicted by organizational intelligence. Organizational agility can be predicted by creative self-efficacy. Creative self-efficacy plays a significant mediating role in the relationship between the variables of organizational intelligence and organizational agility. The indirect effect of organizational intelligence on organizational agility through creative self-efficacy is 0.118. In fact, with a unit increase in organizational intelligence in the presence of creative self-efficacy, organizational agility increases by 11.8 percent.
Conclusion
The findings showed that organizational intelligence has a direct and significant effect on creative self-efficacy. This research finding is in line with the results of Ostvarzabarjadi et al, (2017) and Darabeygi and Eslamieh (2015). In explaining these findings, it can be said that organizational intelligence helps teachers to have a deeper understanding of the organizational environment and the needs of their students. This ability allows them to make quick and effective decisions that lead to increased organizational agility. Also, the findings showed that organizational agility can be predicted by organizational intelligence. This research finding is in line with the results of Perkayti et al, (2023), Kiani et al, (2016), and Shiri et al, (2016). In explaining these findings, it can be said that organizational intelligence includes the organization's ability to collect and analyze information efficiently. These abilities help teachers make better decisions and respond quickly to environmental changes and students' needs. Quick and accurate decision-making processes increase the organizational agility of teachers. Based on the research results, the following practical suggestions are provided:
- The creation of working groups and cooperation teams between teachers provides the possibility of exchanging ideas, experiences and creative solutions, and increases creative self-efficacy and organizational agility.
- Using new technologies such as robotics, virtual reality, educational websites and educational software can improve educational processes and stimulate teachers' creativity and innovation.
 

management

Investigating the effects of e-learning environment on collaborative learning and academic self-efficacy in Payame Noor University students

Volume 7, Issue 2, Summer 2025, Pages 394-413

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.509901.1487

Nasrin Heidarizadeh, Javad Jahan

Abstract The aim of this study is to investigate the effects of electronic learning environment on collaborative learning and academic self-efficacy in students of Payame Noor University. The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, quantitative in terms of its implementation method, and descriptive-correlational in terms of its nature and method. The statistical population of the study includes all students of Payame Noor University in Kermanshah in the academic year 2023-2024, of which 250 people were selected and studied by purposive sampling. To collect data, the participatory learning questionnaire (Stephen Cho and Bowley, 2007), the academic self-efficacy questionnaire (Jinks and Morgan, 1999), and Watkins et al. (2004) e-learning were used. SPSS and Smart PLS software were used to analyze the data. The results show that the e-learning environment has a significant relationship with collaborative learning (0.05, P-Value ≤ 9.69, t = 0.572β =), academic self-efficacy (0.05, P-Value ≤ 9.45, t = 0.555β =); and the e-learning environment improves collaborative learning and academic self-efficacy. The e-learning environment, with the opportunities and resources it provides to students, enables them to improve their learning by using these components, form broader relationships and interactions, and have greater satisfaction with education.
Introduction
The development of information technology has led to many changes in various fields, including education. Under the influence of these conditions, education and technology have merged, and e-learning has emerged as a powerful tool for teaching and learning, and with a variety of modern smart technologies, it has expanded to access learning resources and has had an impact on learning and teaching methods (Al-Fraihat et al., 2020), which has led to changes in teaching and learning approaches and, consequently, changes in teaching and learning methods (Luka, 2018). Accordingly, educational organizations play an important role in the growth and expansion of e-learning. Given that most universities and higher education institutions use e-learning, the development of information technology in educational systems, especially e-learning, is not just a choice, but an inevitable necessity that is considered an effective factor in the reform of educational systems (Khorasani et al., 2012).
In today's world of teaching and learning, there is more emphasis on active and learner-centered learning rather than subject-centered or instructor-centered methods. One type of active learning method is collaborative learning. In this method, small heterogeneous groups work together to achieve a goal. In the group process, the interaction of group members creates opportunities for important experiences, including the ability to ask, explain, criticize, and give examples. Members of collaborative learning groups grow both in terms of knowledge and learning skills and in terms of establishing interaction and social skills during the learning process (Day & Salsali, 2010). In a collaborative learning environment, students have opportunities to interact with each other to achieve their common goals and to progress both academically and socially. Through interactions, students learn to ask for clarification on issues, present their ideas, clarify disagreements, and generate new understandings and inferences (Ke & Carafano, 2016).
Zimmerman (2000) points out that the construct of self-efficacy is multidimensional; therefore, its effect size varies according to the domain of demands. Accordingly, some researchers have emphasized that the assessment of the construct of self-efficacy should be done in a context-dependent manner; therefore, some researchers emphasize that in academic situations, measuring academic self-efficacy is more important than general self-efficacy. Academic self-efficacy refers to the ability of a student to successfully complete academic tasks. Some studies have shown that in academic situations, academic self-efficacy has a greater impact on academic outcomes than more general measures of self-efficacy (Nezhadasadi & Porshafei, 2012). Considering the above, in this study we seek to answer the question: What are the effects of the e-learning environment on collaborative learning and academic self-efficacy in Payam Noor University students?
Theoretical Framework
E-Learning Environment
E-learning environment refers to a space in which digital technologies are used to deliver and manage learning processes. These environments can include websites, online learning platforms, educational software, and other digital tools that allow learners to access educational content, interact with the teacher and other learners, and track their progress (Tarkhan & Mostafavi, 2020).
Collaborative Learning
Collaborative learning is an educational approach in which students work together in groups and interact with each other to learn new concepts and solve problems. In this method, group members achieve more effective and deeper learning by sharing their knowledge and experiences (Ghorbani et al., 2024(.
Academic self-efficacy
Self-efficacy, as one of the motivational variables, causes an individual to spontaneously strive in the environment and achieve their efficacy beliefs through intrinsic motivation (Afangideh, 2022).
Nezhad Asadi & Safarzadeh (2023) studied the design of a desirable virtual learning model based on academic self-efficacy and self-regulated learning strategies mediated by academic adaptation. In a study, they showed that in order to increase academic self-efficacy and self-regulated learning strategies on students' desired e-learning, it is possible to focus on strengthening academic adaptation.
Wei et al., (2023) studied the identification of the role of motivation, perceived learning support, learning participation, and self-regulated learning strategies. They reported that self-regulated learning strategies have a positive and significant effect on learners' perceived learning outcomes from online courses.
Research Methodology
The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, quantitative in terms of implementation, and descriptive-correlational in terms of nature and method. The statistical population of the study includes all students of Payam Noor University of Kermanshah in the academic year 2023-2024, of which 250 people were selected and studied by purposive sampling. To collect data, the participatory learning questionnaire (Stephen Cho and Bowley, 2007), the academic self-efficacy questionnaire (Jinks and Morgan, 1999), and Watkins et al. (2004) e-learning were used.
Research findings
SPSS and Smart PLS software were used to analyze the data. The results obtained show that the e-learning environment has a significant relationship with participatory learning (0.05, P –Value ≤ 9.69, t = 0.572β =) and academic self-efficacy, (0.05, P –Value ≤ 9.45, t = 0.555β =); and the e-learning environment improves participatory learning and academic self-efficacy. The e-learning environment, with the opportunities and resources it provides to students, allows them to improve their learning by using these components, form broader relationships and interactions, and have greater satisfaction with education.
Conclusion
The present study aimed to investigate the effects of the e-learning environment on collaborative learning and academic self-efficacy in Payam Noor University students. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Nezhad Asadi & Safarzadeh (2023), Wei et al. (2023), Babaei parsheh & Mosadeghi Nik (2022), Alamolhoda & Zeinali (2022), Khodamoradi et al. (2022), Firuzi et al. (2021), Portokoli et al. (2020), and Tarkhan & Mostafavi (2020). Portokoli et al. (2020) showed that factors such as content, interaction, technology, instructor, service quality, design, perceived ease of use, personalization, perceived usefulness, learner, perceived value, and self-efficacy were the most important factors affecting e-learner satisfaction. In the interview section, content design principles, learner, implicit consequences, attention to learning-related approaches, and the role of the instructor had the greatest role on e-learner satisfaction, respectively. Educational technologies eliminate geographical and educational limitations and bring learners and instructors closer to each other over time and space. Therefore, by reducing time and space limitations, the e-learning environment increases educational and social ties which can increase the field for elevating collaborative learning. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Education Management

Presenting a Model for Developing Organizational Citizenship Behavior in Iraqi Secondary School Teachers

Volume 6, Issue 4, Winter 2025, Pages 397-417

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.492221.1451

Maha Mohammed Abbas AL-KHATEEB, Kobra Emami Rizi, MUNA MOHAMMED ABBAS AL-KHATEEB, Narges Saeidian Khorasgani

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to present a model for developing organizational citizenship behavior in Iraqi secondary school teachers. The research method is applicable in accordance with its purpose, and its method is qualitative and data-based. The statistical population consists of 15 secondary school teachers and experts related to the subject, selected through theoretical sampling, and the selection of samples continued until theoretical saturation. The data collection tool is a semi-structured interview. For data analysis, the data-based method and Atlas ti8 software were used, and open, axial, and selective coding stages were used to identify and classify the main and sub-categories. The findings showed that teachers' organizational citizenship behavior includes key dimensions such as organizational cooperation, professional development, respect and values, commitment and responsibility, educational innovation, honesty and feedback, well-being and mental health, encouragement of academic growth, and discipline and adherence to principles. These dimensions are presented as a comprehensive model and are proposed as a framework for strengthening these behaviors. The present study shows that strengthening organizational citizenship behavior in teachers not only leads to improving the educational environment and increasing the motivation of teachers and students, but also has a positive impact on the overall performance of the educational system. Introduction Today, the completely changing conditions prevailing in organizations have increased competition in them, which makes the need for their effectiveness in such conditions more evident than ever before. This refers to the generation that is referred to as organizational soldiers, and these employees are undoubtedly the distinguishing feature of effective organizations from ineffective ones; that is, employees who tend to go beyond the formal requirements of their jobs, which is called organizational citizenship behavior, and has received increased attention from managers and organizational officials in recent years (Rezazadeh, 2019). Organizational citizenship behavior is one of the new concepts of organizational behavior management that emphasizes the extra-role behaviors of employees and managers and plays a fundamental and decisive role in the organizational process and transforming the traditional and static environment into a dynamic and efficient environment. Therefore, if successful and unsuccessful organizations take steps to create organizational citizenship behavior, their organizational efficiency and productivity will increase, and this will improve their performance compared to competing organizations (Zareatn Dolatabadi et al, 2022). Since organizational citizenship behaviors directly affect the quality of education and student learning outcomes, examining these behaviors and identifying the factors affecting them can help improve educational systems. As a result, more research in this field can lead to constructive changes in educational environments and lead to an overall improvement in the state of education worldwide. Therefore, the researcher seeks to answer the question: what is the model for developing organizational citizenship behavior in Iraqi secondary school teachers? Theoretical Framework Organizational Citizenship Behavior Organizational citizenship behavior refers to a set of voluntary and discretionary behaviors that are not part of an individual's formal duties but are performed by the individual and improve organizational tasks and roles and the growth and development of organizational performance (Alwi et al, 2021). Choong & Peng Ng (2024) examined the shaping of teachers' organizational citizenship behavior through self-efficacy and trust in colleagues: the moderating role of collective efficacy. The results indicate that trust in colleagues has a positive relationship with organizational citizenship behavior and teacher self-efficacy. In addition, teacher self-efficacy and organizational citizenship behavior are also positively related. Furthermore, the relationship between trust in colleagues and organizational citizenship behavior is partially mediated by teacher self-efficacy. In addition, collective efficacy significantly moderates the path between teacher self-efficacy and organizational citizenship behavior, but not between trust in colleagues and organizational citizenship behavior. Mousavifard (2024) investigated the effect of intellectual capital and strategic leadership on organizational citizenship behavior with the moderating role of professional ethics of employees in the General Directorate of Education of Kermanshah Province. The findings showed that intellectual capital has a significant and positive effect on organizational citizenship behavior by 66 percent. Strategic leadership predicted changes in organizational citizenship behavior by 46 percent; also, the moderating role of professional ethics of employees between intellectual capital and strategic leadership with organizational citizenship behavior was confirmed, with the moderating rate of this variable being 5 percent and 3.2 percent, respectively. The results showed that intellectual capital has a greater effect on organizational citizenship behavior than strategic leadership. Therefore, it is necessary to pay more attention to intellectual capital in order to improve organizational citizenship behavior in the organization. Research Methodology The research method is applicable due to its purpose, and its method is qualitative and data-based. The statistical population consists of 15 secondary school teachers and related experts selected through theoretical sampling that continued until theoretical saturation was obtained. The data collection tool is a semi-structured interview. Research findings For data analysis, the data-based method and Atlas ti8 software were used, and open, axial, and selective coding stages were used to identify and classify main and sub-categories. The findings showed that teachers' organizational citizenship behavior includes key dimensions such as organizational collaboration, professional development, respect and values, commitment and accountability, educational innovation, honesty and feedback, well-being and mental health, encouragement of academic growth, and discipline and adherence to principles. These dimensions are presented as a comprehensive model and are proposed as a framework for strengthening these behaviors. The present study shows that strengthening organizational citizenship behavior in teachers not only leads to improving the educational environment and increasing the motivation of teachers and students, but also has a positive impact on the overall performance of the education system. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of presenting a model for developing organizational citizenship behavior in Iraqi secondary school teachers. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Choong & Peng Ng (2024), Mousavifard (2024), Behkesh & Behkesh (2024), Ghanbari et al, (2023), Nguyen Iran (2023), Ghanbari & Ahmadi (2022), Zarean Dolatabadi et al, (2021), and Hadipur (2019). Behkesh & Behkesh (2024) showed that organizational citizenship behavior is a constructs that has been of interest for a long time and the subject of much research. Given the specific conditions of the primary school, teachers of primary school have the most important responsibility. Teachers of this level have special duties to increase productivity and, as a result, the success of students in school. We have explained the importance of organizational citizenship behaviors, the characteristics of organizational citizenship behaviors, and its dimensions. An effective teacher is a teacher who can play a positive role in the intellectual and moral development of students. In order to make progress in education and training, primary school teachers must have high organizational citizenship behaviors. According to the results of the research, the following suggestions were made: One of the most important suggestions is that schools and educational centers should focus on strengthening cooperation and positive interaction between teachers and other members of the teaching staff. For this purpose, holding team-building workshops and training programs to improve communication skills and promote a spirit of cooperation can play a significant role in strengthening organizational citizenship behavior. Also, supporting teachers by providing continuous learning and professional development opportunities such as training courses, conferences, and study groups can help improve teaching performance and interpersonal communication in schools.

management

Designing a general employee management model with an emphasis on performance management

Volume 6, Issue 3, Autumn 2024, Pages 356-378

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2024.477239.1416

Maryam Nasiri, Ameneh Firozabadi, Sanjar Slajagheh, Mahdi Mohamad Bagheri

Abstract Abstract The purpose of this research is to design a general management model of employees with an emphasis on performance management. The current research is applicable in terms of purpose, mixed in terms of implementation (qualitative-quantitative), and descriptive-survey in terms of nature. The participants in the qualitative part include 13 professors and experts in educational management and education managers, sampling by a targeted method, and the statistical population in the quantitative part includes 300 people from all the education and training staff of district one of Kerman, 187 of whom were selected through the Cochran formula by simple random sampling method. The research collection tool is a semi-structured interview and a researcher-made questionnaire. To analyze the data in the qualitative part, the data-based method was used; and in the quantitative part, SPSS and PLS software were used. The data were analyzed in the qualitative part by open, central, and selective coding; 111 open codes (concepts), 19 central codes (dimensions and components), and 6 selective codes (main categories) were counted. The findings of the qualitative section showed that the main and core categories in the form of six dimensions of causal conditions, central phenomenon, contextual conditions, intervening conditions, strategies, and consequences were upgraded to a higher abstract level and finally the research paradigm model was presented. In the quantitative section, the general management model was approved. Extended abstract Introduction Today, due to the fierce competition in the economy and the development of people's and organizations' awareness of finance and investment, capital markets have received more attention. On the other hand, some people are looking for the satisfaction of investors, and for this reason, they try to provide high quality products and services with low costs to the market. Based on this, performance review with emphasis on acceptable and diverse financial indicators as well as their classification based on priority can be of particular benefit to investors (Zolfaghari, 2015). Performance management is one of the most important topics emphasized by shareholders, managers and creditors; considering the development of capital markets, investors always want to know the success rate of managers in using their capital. Accordingly, financial ratios are the most important indicators that inform them about the company's financial status (Lin et al, 2020). One of the indicators of today's success is the existence of an efficient performance management system that continuously provides performance feedback to different levels of company management (Almatrooshi et al, 2016). With increasing competition in the field of production and services, organizations need to identify effective factors to improve their performance management (Liu et al, 2018). Performance management, in its new concept, is a cycle that helps managers, after setting goals and planning about the performance and behavior of employees under their supervision at the beginning of the evaluation period, to evaluate the amount and quality of program implementation and the achievement of goals at the end of evaluation period, and through rooting and analysis of satisfactory and unsatisfactory behaviors and performances and continuous application of this cycle, provide the basis for improving the performance and upgrading the behavior of employees (Abolalaei, 2010). Therefore, this research seeks to investigate the issue: what model can be designed for the general management of employees with an emphasis on performance management? Theoretical framework Employee performance management Performance management consists of two words: management and performance. Management has always been defined as doing work with others, promoting things through others, the process of planning, organizing, leading and controlling. Performance is also, in Mo'in Persian Glossory, synonymous with the result of work, amount of work, result or product. In the official definition of performance management, Daniels says: it is a practical data-oriented management system that consists of 3 main elements: measurement, feedback, and positive reinforcement. One of the common and constant demands of all managers is to improve the performance and continuous improvement of employees' behavior. When employees behave appropriately, and have desired and satisfactory performances: managers are also successful and run their organizations successfully. Performance management means measuring performance, but with the aim of simultaneously developing and improving employees and the organization in such a way that increasing the productivity of employees and work groups by acquiring skills and increasing their commitment and motivation leads to the development and growth of the organization (Khoshvaghti, 2016). The management style of martyr Haj Qassem Soleimani The first indicator of Haj Qassem Soleimani's management model is expertise. We have a duality called expertise and commitment. These are also complementary. There have been many debates. These are not opposites. It is even in quotes and hadiths. Expertise means professional knowledge and skill. Haj Qassem Soleimani was an expert in the field of military and security. In addition to being a scientist and at the same time, he was a skilled person in the field of security and military. He was even a professional diplomat. This is an important indicator. All managers of the country should have this. The second indicator is commitment. In our Islamic Republic, our emphasis is on heart and practical faith in the holy ideals of the system, governorship, and commitment to sacred religious laws. All these were perfectly present in Haj Qasim Soleimani. He never fell short of these ideals. He was a soldier of Islam. This means the peak of commitment. The third indicator is that he was tireless and hardworking. This should be of concern to managers. Farhadi et al, (2022) conducted a research under the title of the components of the management of the individual performance of the prevention police. Based on the research conducted for the management of individual performance, 6 components (self-evaluation, individual improvement, individual characteristics, individual spirituality, familiarity with expectations from employees, and professionalism), and 30 indicators were identified. Ahmadnejad (2022) conducted a research under the title of explaining the leadership model of martyr Qassem Soleimani. The result of the research showed that the model obtained from the analysis of the data is based on the personality traits of Martyr Soleimani as follows: Personality traits: faith in God, ethics, sacrifice and self-sacrifice, self-mastery. Functional characteristics: sociability, political man, expertise and commitment to work; which summarizes the results obtained about the basic themes. Research methodology The current research is applicable in terms of purpose, mixed in terms of implementation (qualitative-quantitative), and descriptive-survey in terms of nature. The participants in the qualitative part include 13 professors and experts in educational management and education managers, sampling by a targeted method, and the statistical population in the quantitative part includes 300 people from all the education and training staff of district one of Kerman, 187 of whom were selected through the Cochran formula by simple random sampling method. The research collection tool is a semi-structured interview and a researcher-made questionnaire. Research findings To analyze the data in the qualitative part, the data-based method was used; and in the quantitative part, SPSS and PLS software were used. The data were analyzed in the qualitative part by open, central, and selective coding; 111 open codes (concepts), 19 central codes (dimensions and components), and 6 selective codes (main categories) were counted. The findings of the qualitative section showed that the main and core categories in the form of six dimensions of causal conditions, central phenomenon, contextual conditions, intervening conditions, strategies, and consequences were upgraded to a higher abstract level and finally the research paradigm model was presented. In the quantitative section, the general management model was approved. Conclusion The current research was conducted with the aim of designing a general management model of employees with an emphasis on performance management. The results of this research is aligned with the results of Farhadi et al, (2022), Ahmadnejad (2022), Karimi Giglo (2021), Fuladi (2021), Udhayanan et al, (2021), Leviäkangas (2020), Liu et al, (2020), Mohammad Zaheri (2020), Yap et al, (2022), Alavian (2022), and Audenaert et al, (2021). Ghasemi (Ghasemi, 2022) confirmed the impact of performance management on job performance and job attachment at the individual level (Yap et al, 2022). The consequence of the existence of good performance management is loyalty and maximum use of employees' knowledge. According to the results of the research, the following suggestions are provided: Due to the importance of performance management leadership in the planning structure of the education system, it is suggested that a fixed performance evaluation center be established in the Ministry of Education in order to investigate this area. It is suggested that the objectives and the short and medium term programs of the education system be introduced through different platforms to the employees so that a common perspective is formed for the purpose of knowledge exchange among them.

Education Management

Design and Validation of Curriculum Evaluation Scales for Undergraduate Students of Elementary Education at Farhangian Universityabstract

Volume 7, Issue 1, Spring 2025, Pages 394-411

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.500024.1469

Manizhe Irannejad, Ali Asghar Mashinchi, Mukhtar Ranjbar

Abstract The aim of the present research is to study the evaluation scales in curricula for Farhangian University students. The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, mixed (qualitative-quantitative) in terms of its implementation method, and descriptive-survey in terms of its nature and method, and is an exploratory research type. The statistical population in the qualitative part of the research included 20 experts selected based on purposive sampling. The statistical population in the quantitative part of the research included 450 of all secondary school teachers in Hormozgan province selected based on the Cochran formula and the type of stratified and cluster sampling. The Delphi technique and the model fit assessment questionnaire were used. The Delphi technique was used in the qualitative part of the data analysis, and the Spss-V23 and Lisrel-V8.8 software were used in the quantitative part. The results of the research showed that the components of the model of the evaluation scales of Farhangian University students' curricula are in 5 dimensions and 16 components, including the dimensions of logic and goals (3 components), content and learning activities (3 components), the role of the teacher and materials and resources (4 components), grouping and assessment and evaluation (3 components), and place and time (3 components). Also, considering the difference in the means, which are positive values, it was concluded that the status of the components was generally in a desirable state but slightly above the average. In addition, the results of the validation of the model showed that the adaptation, comprehensibility, generalizability, and controllability of the model are valid in the opinion of experts and have been confirmed with 99% confidence.
Introduction
Education and training, as an educational institution that is responsible for teaching science and citizenship education, must pay attention to all dimensions of human existence. However, a look at the history of Iranian education shows that the Iranian education system operates purposefully in the educational and cognitive dimension, and other dimensions of human existence have either been forgotten, or if they have been seen, they are not very significant and purposeful; while the most important goal of education is to discover the inner strengths of each individual, and to help them identify their mental and practical abilities (Moussapour, 2022). The concept of curriculum has undergone many changes and developments throughout its short history. Until the early twentieth century, the concept of curriculum did not go beyond its traditional and limited framework, which was limited only to the subject matter. However, since the early twentieth century, due to the importance and role of education and the development of educational research, the traditional concept of curriculum has undergone many changes, and its newer concept, namely the individual and social competence of learners and the achievement of educational goals, has been taken into account (Yarmohammadian, 2022). This is why most education professionals agree that: today, a curriculum or roadmap should be more than just information or a list of materials and topics to be studied. It should include all the theoretical and practical experiences necessary to be successful in achieving educational expectations and goals (Baal, 2022). However, curriculum planning can be prescriptive or descriptive, or both. Prescriptive definitions provide us with what “should” happen, and often take the form of a plan, an imaginary design, or some kind of masterful vision of what needs to happen. Similar to prescriptive curricula, prescriptions are those that pharmacies churn out for patients; in fact, we do not know how many of them are followed by patients. The best estimate is that most are not followed. This is particularly true of the prescribed curriculum for schools where the teacher, like the patient, ultimately decides whether to follow the curriculum version or not. In essence, the designer suggests, the teacher arranges the tasks (Tural, 2022). Accordingly, the present study examines the evaluation scales in curricula for Farhangian University students and seeks to answer the question: What are the evaluation scales in curricula for Farhangian University students?
Theoretical Framework
Curriculum
The word curriculum in our country's education is a new word that has been used by different people based on the different meanings derived from this word (Etslander, 2021). The term curriculum, in terms of lexicography, has its roots in the Latin word currere, which means a racetrack or a field for running. Curriculums, like a racetrack with a defined beginning and end, require a clearly defined beginning, end, and path. The second characteristic that can be inferred from the word curriculum - given its etymology - is that, like obstacles placed on the racetrack and become increasingly difficult to overcome, curricula also become progressively more difficult (Mehrmohammadi, 2024).
Rahpeyma et al, (2024) studied the presentation of the work and technology curriculum model in the secondary school of Fars province schools. The research findings showed that according to the values ​​of the standard coefficients and the significance coefficients of t, it can be said that the objectives and content component in the model has a significant role and the teaching and evaluation method component has a significant effect on the work and technology curriculum model of the secondary school. All indicators are at a very desirable level and the model fits the data well, indicating that there is a linear relationship between the variables.
Zanganeh et al, (2024) studied the design of the virtual school curriculum model in the second year of secondary school in Khaf city. The results showed that school curriculum design includes 6 components: curriculum objectives, curriculum content, curriculum evaluation, learning flows, curriculum teaching, curriculum strategies, and curriculum suitability. The results of the model fit statistics show that the values ​​obtained for each of the indicators indicate a very good fit of the model.
Research methodology
The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, mixed (qualitative-quantitative) in terms of its implementation method, and descriptive-survey in terms of its nature and method, and is an exploratory research type. The statistical population in the qualitative part of the research included 20 experts selected based on purposive sampling. The statistical population in the quantitative part of the research included 450 of all secondary school teachers in Hormozgan province selected based on the Cochran formula and the type of stratified and cluster sampling. The Delphi technique and the model fit assessment questionnaire were used.
Research findings
The Delphi technique was used in the qualitative data analysis and the Spss-V23 and Lisrel-V8.8 software was used in the quantitative part. The results of the research showed that the components of the model of the evaluation scales of Farhangian University students' curricula are in 5 dimensions and 16 components, including the dimensions of logic and goals (3 components), content and learning activities (3 components), the teacher's role and materials and resources (4 components), grouping and assessment and evaluation (3 components), place and time (3 components). Also, considering the difference in the means, which are positive values, it was concluded that the status of the components was generally in a desirable state but slightly above the average. In addition, the results of the model validation showed that the adaptation, understandability, generalizability, and controllability of the model are valid in the opinion of experts and have been confirmed with 99% confidence.
Conclusion
The present study aimed to investigate the evaluation scales in curricula for Farhangian University students. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Rahpeyma et al, (2024), Ashrafi Soltan-Ahmadi et al, (2024), Zanganeh et al, (2024), Amini Harandi (2023), Gulo (2023), Mastali et al, (2023), Morata (2022), and Motamedinia & Jamalianzadeh (2021). Rahpeyma et al, (2024) showed that according to the values ​​of the standard coefficients and the significance coefficients of t, it can be said that the component of objectives and content in the model has a significant role and the component of teaching method and evaluation has a significant effect on the curriculum model of secondary school work and technology. All indicators are at a very desirable level and the model has a good fit with the data, indicating that there is a linear relationship between the variables.
Considering the subject of the research, it is suggested: Since the degree of desirability or validity of a model as well as its explanatory power requires that they successfully pass the test of time, it is necessary that the components identified in this research be experimentally tested in educational environments by other researchers in this field for testability and ultimately in the education system, so that a more accurate and comprehensive judgment can be made regarding the validity and accuracy of these components as well as their generalizability to educational environments. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Education Management

Integrating augmented reality and virtual reality in curriculum design

Volume 8, Issue 2, Summer 2026, Pages 399-419

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.579895.1647

Aliasghar Mashinchi

Abstract The aim of this research is to integrate augmented reality and virtual reality in curriculum design. The present research is applicable in terms of its purpose, and quantitative in terms of the nature of the data, with a descriptive-analytical approach. The statistical population of the present study includes 800 teachers, university professors, curriculum designers and students of fields related to educational sciences and educational technology, of which the sample size was 264 people selected by a random sampling method based on the Cochran formula. The collection tool in the present study includes a researcher-made questionnaire. SPSS software was applied to analyze the findings. The results showed that variables such as perceived usefulness, ease of use, technological skills, quality of digital content and institutional support have a positive and significant effect on the level of integration of augmented reality and virtual reality in the curriculum. The findings also indicate that the use of immersive educational environments increases learner participation, improves understanding of complex concepts and enhances experiential learning. However, barriers such as limited infrastructure, lack of digital skills, and high equipment costs remain major challenges to the deployment of these technologies in educational settings. According to the research results, achieving effective integration of augmented reality and virtual reality requires simultaneous attention to technological, educational, and organizational factors, as well as the development of policies and operational guidelines for curriculum designers and teachers.
Introduction
In recent years, the digital transformation in educational systems has led to the recognition of emerging technologies as key tools for improving the quality of learning. Among these technologies, augmented reality and virtual reality have gained a special place in educational research due to their ability to create interactive learning environments, complex simulations, and immersive experiences (Radianti et al., 2020). These technologies allow the combination of real environments with digital elements or the creation of completely virtual environments, and in this way, they can provide learners with abstract and complex concepts in a visible and experiential way. Numerous studies have shown that the use of learning environments based on augmented reality and virtual reality can significantly increase the understanding of concepts, the motivation of learners, and their active participation in the learning process. For this reason, many educational systems in the world are exploring solutions to integrate these technologies into formal curricula (Burak & Aysegul, 2024). Despite the significant educational potential of augmented reality and virtual reality technologies, the main challenge in the field of education is not simply the use of these technologies, but how to effectively integrate them into curriculum design. As the core of the educational system, the curriculum provides a framework for determining learning objectives, content, teaching methods, and assessment methods (Sala, 2022). Therefore, if emerging technologies are introduced into the educational environment without considering the principles of curriculum design and learning theories, they may not be able to have a real and sustainable impact on learning. Many studies show that the use of immersive technologies is most effective when it is aligned with educational approaches such as experiential learning, constructivist learning, and problem-based learning; and is systematically integrated into the curriculum structure (Asoodar et al., 2024). On the other hand, studies have shown that the use of augmented reality and virtual reality in education can bring several benefits, including increasing the understanding of complex concepts, promoting practical skills, improving learners' interaction with content, and creating more realistic learning experiences. Especially in fields such as medicine, engineering, architecture, and experimental sciences, where learning based on experience and observation plays an important role, simulated environments based on virtual and augmented reality can create valuable educational opportunities (Masoumian Hosseini et al., 2025).
The aim of this study is to identify key variables affecting the successful integration of these technologies in educational environments and to examine the relationships between them through data analysis and educational modeling methods. The results of such a study can help curriculum designers, educational policymakers, and teachers to design and implement more effective strategies for using augmented reality and virtual reality technologies in the teaching and learning process and to benefit from the capacities of these technologies to improve the quality of education. Therefore, the main question of the present study is: what is the integration of augmented reality and virtual reality in curriculum design?
Theoretical Framework
Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality Technologies
Augmented reality and virtual reality technologies have been proposed as key tools in the transformation of digital learning, and research has shown that these technologies can transform learning from a passive knowledge transfer process to an interactive, exploratory, and immersive learning experience (Burak & Aysegul, 2024).
Heidar Sarlak (2025) examined the potential of using augmented reality and virtual reality technologies in improving the quality of practical jurisprudential education. The research findings show that augmented reality and virtual reality technologies have significant potential to transform practical jurisprudential education. These technologies can improve learners' understanding and learning by creating simulated environments, providing interactive experiences, and providing the possibility of practicing in virtual spaces. Also, the use of these technologies can help increase students' motivation and active participation. However, challenges such as the need for technical infrastructure, teacher training, and adapting educational content to these technologies have also been identified. This study provides solutions for the successful implementation of virtual reality and augmented reality in jurisprudence education, paving the way for future empirical studies in this area.
Ghazi et al. (2025) investigated the effect of using augmented reality and virtual reality on reverse learning, academic motivation, and cognitive performance of junior high school students in experimental science courses. The findings showed that the data distribution is normal and there is a significant difference between the mean learning and motivation scores of the experimental group after the intervention and the control group. The results indicate that the use of augmented reality and virtual reality leads to a significant increase in cognitive engagement, information retention in long-term memory, and interest in deeper learning.
Research Methodology
The present study is applicable in terms of purpose, and quantitative in terms of the nature of the data, with a descriptive-analytical approach. The statistical population of the present study includes 800 teachers, university professors, curriculum designers, and students of fields related to educational sciences and educational technology, and the sample size was 264 people selected via a random sampling method based on the Cochran formula. The collection tool in the present study includes a researcher-made questionnaire.
Research findings
SPSS software was used to analyze the findings. The results showed that variables such as perceived usefulness, ease of use, technology skills, digital content quality, and institutional support have a positive and significant effect on the level of integration of augmented reality and virtual reality in the curriculum. The findings also indicate that the use of immersive educational environments increases learner participation, improves understanding of complex concepts, and enhances experiential learning. However, obstacles such as limited infrastructure, lack of digital skills, and high cost of equipment continue to be major challenges in the path of deploying these technologies in educational environments. Based on the research results, achieving effective integration of augmented reality and virtual reality requires simultaneous attention to technological, educational, and organizational factors, as well as the development of policies and operational guidelines for curriculum designers and teachers.
Conclusion
The present study was conducted with the aim of integrating augmented reality and virtual reality in curriculum design. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Heidar Sarlak (2025), Ghazi et al. (2025), Mohammad Hasani & Ahmadi Sharif (2025), Fattahi et al. (2025), Malki et al. (2025), Junaidi Jafari & Ghanimati (2025), Seyedi (2025), Shahmohamadi et al. (2023), and Mahmudi & Karimi (2023). Seyedi (2025) showed that without a holistic approach by educational administrators to align these technologies with curricula and provide sustainable resources, the educational potential of augmented and virtual reality will not be realized. This study provides solutions for policymakers and school administrators to facilitate the process of integrating these technologies.
Finally, the results of this study show that augmented and virtual reality have significant potential to transform teaching and learning methods and can help create interactive, experiential, and student-centered learning environments. However, the full realization of this potential requires careful planning, investment in educational infrastructure, and the development of curriculum frameworks compatible with new technologies. Therefore, it is suggested that future research should develop comprehensive models for designing curricula based on immersive technologies and examine their long-term effects on the quality of education.

Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work.
Data Availability Statement
The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
AI Use Statement
The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript.
Funding
The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript.
Ethics Approval
All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

Human Resource Management

Providing a model for human resources development with an approach to employee self-development

Volume 7, Issue 3, Autumn 2025, Pages 405-427

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2025.496021.1461

Fateme mehraban, Mahmoud Ghorbani, Hamid Erfanian Khanzadeh

Abstract The aim of this study is to present a model for human resources development with an approach to self-development of education staff. It is applicable in terms of its purpose, and quantitative in terms of implementation method, and is of descriptive research type. The statistical population of the study includes 770 employees of all staff of the General Directorate of Education of Khorasan Razavi and the seven regions of Mashhad, with a sample size of 260 people selected by the stratified sampling method. A researcher-made questionnaire was used to collect data. Structural equations were used to fit the model; and Excel, Spss version 24, and PLS software were used to analyze and plot the data. The results showed that human resource development has four dimensions (career development, functional development, talent management and empowering processes) and 17 components (training, teamwork, organizational skills, career path, interpersonal relationships, communication, innovation, leadership, responsibility, flexibility, attraction, improvement, retention, meaningfulness, having the right to choose, effectiveness and participation). Also, the individual self-development model has four dimensions (creativity, learning, knowledge management and self-fulfillment) and 17 components (potential creativity, actual creativity, perceived support, individual skills, mental models, shared vision, team learning, systems thinking, perception, refinement, organization, dissemination, application, positive emotion, meaning-making and progress). As a result, managers and officials should develop appropriate training courses for human resources in education and training to maximize the effectiveness and efficiency of the organization's people, while familiarizing them with the environment and justifying them based on their needs. Also, the GOF index was obtained as 0.390, which indicates a strong and overall desirable value of the model.
Introduction
Humans have long believed, naturally or through trial and error, that it is necessary to educate and teach individuals activities in order to facilitate the performance of some tasks and obtain the desired results. Education acts as a tool that leads individuals to growth and prosperity and causes the individual and social growth of humans. In fact, the roots of all the advances and civilizations that have been eye-catching in the present era should be sought in the belief in education and its role and impact on various aspects of human life (Karimpour & Kazeruni-Shamiri, 2020). The need for education that goes beyond traditional education programs is increasingly felt, and in rigorous scientific methods; concepts such as leadership, communication, and other organizational skills that are rarely presented in research education programs should be considered. Further development and support of human resources requires explicit attention to new training programs and the support of researchers and stakeholders in the systems that aim to improve (Yano et al., 2021). Implementing human resource training and development enables individuals to effectively continue their activities in line with organizational and environmental changes and increase their efficiency and effectiveness. In a rapidly changing society, employee training is not only desirable but also an activity that every organization must consider resources for in order to always have efficient and informed human resources (Prestiana, 2021). Until recently, few people considered human resources to be the source of competitive advantage of organizations, but today it is claimed that human resources are the greatest asset of organizations and countries, and the development and growth of these human resources cannot be achieved without the development of humans (Khalilnejad & Mehri, 2016). Therefore, organizations began to train and develop, and of course, develop resources themselves. Self-development is a set of voluntary and informal activities required by the organization that employees perform to acquire and maintain the necessary knowledge and job skills, which can include activities such as reading, articles, magazines, attending conferences, obtaining certifications, etc. (Ahmadi et al., 2017). Traditionally, improving organizational performance is facilitated through three broader areas including training and development, evaluation, and program and development in the organization. It can be stated categorically that these areas are not simply human resource development concepts and only represent a part of the human resource development literature (Abili et al., 2020). On the other hand, the personal development plan is a correct tool for structuring employee learning in organizations and an appropriate and optimal strategy for individual development (Tsai et al., 2018). Therefore, in this research, we seek to answer the question: what is the appropriate model for human resource development with the approach of personal self-development of education and training employees?
Theoretical Framework
Human Resource Development
Human resource development is a set of individual and organizational actions that aim to increase the potential contribution of individuals to the organization. In new management texts, human resource development is considered a complex idea that emphasizes the processes of learning before, during, and after work (Rakhshani et al., 2020).
Personal self-development
Self-development is a self-discovery process that includes understanding skills, attitudes, and knowledge. This is an ongoing and intentional systemic process that strengthens the individual's self-confidence in realizing a plan for the future through a correct understanding of knowledge, skills, and attitudes (Verma & Agarwal, 2016).
Shariati et al. (2025) studied the identification of factors affecting employee performance management with a human resource development approach in research and technology organizations. Based on the interviews conducted, 6 dimensions of the paradigm model, 23 components, and 105 indicators were extracted. After that, according to the paired comparison questionnaire to identify the influential and influenced dimensions, it was determined that among the 23 components, the components of the workplace, laws and regulations, socio-cultural factors, human resource planning, role clarity, performance measurement, organizational climate, reward system, employee communication, training, performance evaluation, professional ethics, leadership style and motivational factors are the most influential respectively.
Gheiravani et al. (2023) studied the presentation of a smart governance model focusing on the development and training of human resources in the public sector. The results showed that all the components of smart governance in the public sector were identified and confirmed in terms of significance in the research, and by examining the themes, concepts and quantitative and qualitative research, the smart governance model focusing on the development and training of human resources in the public sector was explained.
Research Methodology
The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, quantitative in terms of its implementation method, and is a descriptive research. The statistical population of the study includes 770 employees of the General Directorate of Education of Khorasan Razavi and the seven regions of Mashhad, with a sample size of 260, selected by stratified sampling. A researcher-made questionnaire was used to collect data.
Research findings
Structural equations were used to fit the model; and Excel, Spss version 24, and PLS software were used to analyze and plot the data. The results showed that human resource development has four dimensions (career development, functional development, talent management, and empowering processes) and 17 components (training, teamwork, organizational skills, career path, interpersonal relationships, communication, innovation, leadership, responsibility, flexibility, recruitment, improvement, retention, meaningfulness, having the right to choose, effectiveness, and participation). Also, the personal self-development model has four dimensions (creativity, learning, knowledge management, and self-fulfillment) and 17 components (potential creativity, actual creativity, perceived support, personal skills, mental models, shared vision, team learning, systems thinking, perception, refinement, organization, dissemination, application, positive emotion, meaning-making, and progress). As a result, managers and officials should develop appropriate training courses for human resources in education and training to maximize the effectiveness and efficiency of the organization's people, while familiarizing them with the environment and justifying them based on need. Also, the GOF index was obtained as 0.390, which indicates a strong and overall desirable value of the model.
Conclusion
The present study was conducted with the aim of presenting a model for human resource development with an approach to personal self-development of employees. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Shak (2018), Rakhshani et al. (2019), Gholipour et al. (2018), Salamat Ahvazi et al. (2020), Salajeghe et al. (2014), and Nnadi et al. (2021).
According to the results of the study, the following suggestions are made:
Based on the research findings and identification of the dimensions of the human resource development model in the employees of the General Directorate of Education and the seven regions of Mashhad, it is suggested that managers and officials consider the organization's long-term goals and attract capable teachers by planning human resources and recruiting, justifying and training newly hired employees, selecting qualified volunteers at the beginning of the entry of human resources into the organization.
Based on the findings of the research and identification of the components of the human resources development model in the employees of the General Directorate of Education and the seven regions of Mashhad, it is suggested that managers and officials plan for human resources development by using two-way and continuous communication between the employees of the organization, and interaction between senior managers and employees in the organization. Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work. Data Availability Statement The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. AI Use Statement The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript. Ethics Approval All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

management

Examining the effect of knowledge-based leadership on organizational innovation with the mediating role of illusion of control and rationality

Volume 6, Issue 4, Winter 2025, Pages 418-438

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2023.398909.1201

davar Dirmina, Gholamhasan Shirdel, Seyyed Javad Iranban

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to understand the effect of the variable of knowledge-based leadership on organizational innovation in Sepah Bank after the merger. A descriptive-applicable research model was used in this study, its method was survey, and the statistical population was 110 managers and experts of Sepah Bank headquarters after the merger. The required sample size was selected by simple random sampling method, consisted of 87 people through Morgan table; data was selected and collected from a researcher-made questionnaire, and Likert scale was used for measurement. The statistical method used in this study was the structural modeling method based on the partial least squares approach and Smart PLS3 software. The defined hypotheses were tested and the mutual relationship between knowledge-based leadership, illusion of control, and rationality on innovation was examined. The research findings indicate that with a confidence interval of 95% and path coefficients greater than 0.4, the effect size for all independent constructs on dependent constructs is strong, and knowledge-based leadership can lead to rationality and knowledge in the organization, and if environmental signals are not paid attention to, knowledge-based leadership creates an illusion of control in the organization; and if the illusion of control is managed in the organization and knowledge-based leadership is strengthened in the organization, the organization is on the path to innovation. Introduction In today's world with a completely complex and dynamic environment, organizations need to design and implement strategies that can be used to improve their performance. The requirements that have emerged in the management literature, such as the necessities of leadership in the knowledge age and the fundamental change in approaches to organizational leadership, make it necessary to go beyond traditional perspectives. Although until recently, the discussion about knowledge management was an interesting topic in the center of thought; today knowledge-based leadership has attracted the attention of active thinkers in the field of management (Homayounfar et al, 2023). According to many researchers, a wide range of thematic literature explains the importance of knowledge-based leadership and knowledge management, and the role it plays in the competitiveness of large enterprises and small and medium-sized organizations. Organizational knowledge management capacity is rapidly becoming a vital executive skill of this era. Knowledge-based leadership is considered to be the driver of the relationship between the components of intellectual capital management of the organization, and many researchers consider intellectual capital to be the most important strategic asset in evaluating organizational performance. Therefore, contemporary management researchers often believe that the acquisition of new knowledge depends on the evolution of leadership activities, and adapts to changing organizational conditions (Safar Mohammadlou et al, 2022). Langer believes that leaders are forced to know what needs to be done for the common benefits, and that management must have a higher purpose and ask whether their decisions are good for society as well as for their company; approaches very different from past models. Therefore, rationality enables individuals and social communities to learn and behave well in specific situations in order to achieve a common advantage, without the need to consider or even pretend to be in those situations. When individuals are exposed to the empowerment bias, they feel that they have more control over their environment than they actually do (Bélanger et al, 2018). Therefore, a very important question that arises is: by mediating the two variables of illusion of control and rationality, can knowledge-based leadership affect organizational innovation? Theoretical Framework Knowledge-Based Leadership Knowledge-based leadership means guiding people through a knowledge channel; that is, organizational leaders must guide knowledge workers to learn and use knowledge and ultimately achieve overall knowledge-related goals (Qalich Lee et al, 2020). Illusion of Control “Illusion of Control” is defined as the expectation of the probability of personal success higher than the objective probability. Ilusion is defined in many sources as a kind of distortion in the senses and perceptual abilities; a strong tendency for people to believe that their activities cause things to happen, even if they have no influence on them. (Kim et al, 2014). Rationality Reason (wisdom) is defined as knowledge obtained by having many experiences in life. On the other hand, it considers knowledge as information, understanding or skill obtained from experience or education or awareness of something, and speaks of reason as insight. The word epistemology is a word derived from two ancient Greek words, namely "epistem" meaning knowledge and "logy" meaning speech or theory. The word "epistem" has been translated into English as "knowledge" and in Arabic as "science". Defining knowledge management, like knowledge itself, is difficult. Theoretical insights on how to manage knowledge are available from several disciplines such as economics, philosophy and epistemology, computer science, and sociology (Chang et al., 2015). Innovation In contemporary organizational studies, innovation is considered a panacea for organizational survival. Therefore, it seems that pursuing practical wisdom to improve organizational innovation performance is essential for the sustainability of organizational competition (Ding et al, 2019). Homayounfar et al, (2023) in the article "The Role of Knowledge-Based Leadership in Innovative Performance in the Public Sector" acknowledged: today, the success of organizations depends more than ever on gaining competitive advantage through innovative performance resulting from knowledge-based performance. Accordingly, the present study examined the role of knowledge-based leadership in innovative performance in government organizations in Gilan province. Based on the findings, the effect of knowledge-based leadership on knowledge documentation (r=0.58), the effect of knowledge-based leadership on knowledge application (r=0.39), and the effect of knowledge-based leadership on knowledge creation (r=0.41) is significant. However, the effect of knowledge-based leadership on knowledge transfer is not significant. Based on the results of the indirect paths of the research model, knowledge-based leadership has the greatest indirect effect on the innovative performance of companies through the variables of knowledge storage and transfer. Therefore, by emphasizing knowledge storage by the organization's management, knowledge transfer and innovation will increase the most. Pourrashidi, Zahra., (2021)) in the article "The Mediating Role of Knowledge Management and Organizational Learning in the Effect of Human Resource Development Activities on Employee Innovation (Case of Kerman Shahid Bahonar University Employees)" acknowledged; human resource development activities have a positive and significant effect on knowledge management. Human resource development activities have a positive and significant effect on the organizational learning of employees. Organizational learning of employees has a positive and significant effect on their innovation. Knowledge management has a positive and significant effect on employee innovation. Human resource development activities have a positive and significant effect on employee innovation. Finally, knowledge management and organizational learning have a mediating role in the effect of human resource development activities on employee innovation. Research Methodology A descriptive-applicable research model was used in this study, its method was survey, and the statistical population was 110 managers and experts of Sepah Bank headquarters after the merger. The required sample size was selected by simple random sampling method, consisted of 87 people through Morgan table; data was selected and collected from a researcher-made questionnaire, and Likert scale was used for measurement. Research Findings The statistical method used in this study was the structural modeling method based on the partial least squares approach and Smart PLS3 software. The defined hypotheses were tested and the mutual relationship between knowledge-based leadership, illusion of control, and rationality on innovation was examined. The research findings indicate that with a confidence interval of 95% and path coefficients greater than 0.4, the effect size for all independent constructs on dependent constructs is strong, and knowledge-based leadership can lead to rationality and knowledge in the organization, and if environmental signals are not paid attention to, knowledge-based leadership creates an illusion of control in the organization; and if the illusion of control is managed in the organization and knowledge-based leadership is strengthened in the organization, the organization is on the path to innovation. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of understanding the effect of the knowledge-based leadership variable on organizational innovation in Sepah Bank after the merger. The results of this research are consistent with the results of Homayounfar et al, (2023), Qalich Lee et al, (2020), Pourrashidi, Zahra., (2021), Bruno (2019), Ding et al, (2020), and Naqshbandi et al, (2018). Peter Drucker believes that knowledge is a source of template for creating competitive advantage of organizations. On the other hand, Bruno believes; knowledge and rationality provide the ability to respond to new situations (Bruno, 2019). According to the results of the research, it is recommended: Development and/or acquisition of tools and technologies in aggregating and obtaining value from customer knowledge Development and expansion of IT in aggregating and obtaining value from customer knowledge Development and management of customer knowledge base Application of knowledge sharing technologies for innovation

Human Resource Management

The effect of strategic leadership and innovative organizational climate on employees' voice with the mediating role of work ethic maturity

Volume 6, Issue 3, Autumn 2024, Pages 379-408

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2024.472021.1402

Jafar Beikzad, Maryam Razmjou

Abstract Abstract The present study was conducted with the aim of providing a structural model of the impact of strategic leadership and innovative organizational climate on the voice of employees with the mediating role of work ethic maturity in vocational universities of West Azerbaijan province. This research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-correlative in terms of method. The statistical population of the research includes 156 employees of vocational universities of West Azerbaijan province, of which 111 people were selected as a statistical sample based on Cochran's formula by stratified random sampling. The data collection tool in this research includes 4 standard questionnaires. In order to ensure the existence or non-existence of a causal relationship between the research variables and to check the suitability of the observed data with the conceptual model of the research, the research hypotheses were tested using the structural equation model and the partial least squares method (PLS3). The findings of the research showed that strategic leadership has a significant effect on the voice of employees and the maturity of work ethics; and innovative organizational climate has a significant effect on the voice of employees and the maturity of work ethics. In addition, at the 99% confidence level, work ethic maturity plays a mediating role in the impact of strategic leadership and innovative organizational climate on employee voice. Extended abstract Introduction In today's competitive environment, managing organizations by means of a strategic leadership approach is not only a good idea, but a requirement for success and sustainability in the performance of any organization (Rezaei Manesh et al, 2023). Strategic leadership involves the use of strategies. Strategic leaders can influence organizational outcomes through their personal choices (Poursadeq & Qaraei Ashtiani, 2023). On the other hand, one of the organizational factors that can make strategic leadership effective is the innovative organizational climate. Organizational atmosphere is very effective in creating dynamism and creativity of an organization, especially educational organizations that deal with people. As a result, when there is a suitable atmosphere in the organization, people are more motivated to innovate because they work in an organization that accepts creativity and innovation by facilitating a suitable and dynamic atmosphere (Roudgarnezhad, 2023). In today's business environment, employee voice is a key component for increasing organizational competitiveness because it drives innovative ideas, enables error correction, and improves competitive advantage. In addition to organizational benefits, employee voice behavior also leads to higher performance evaluations and has a positive result in professional growth (Poorghafari et al, 2023). On the other hand, in analyzing the behavior of organizations, dealing with ethics and moral values ​​is one of the requirements. The external symbol of organizations is formed by their ethical behaviors, which itself is the sum of various values ​​of moral maturity (Jafari & Ghayor Baghban, 2024). Therefore, the main question of the current research is: whether strategic leadership and innovative organizational climate are effective on the voice of employees with emphasizing the mediating role of work ethic maturity in vocational universities of West Azerbaijan province. Theoretical framework Strategic leadership: Strategic leadership is a type of leadership style that explains the behavior of top managers and includes combining strategic thinking with strategic action and transferring this achievement to a strategic path and making strategic change (Poursadeq & Qaraei Ashtiani, 2023). Innovative organizational climate: Innovative organizational climate is an atmosphere that keeps the ability to accept an opinion or behavior new to the industry, market or general environment of the organization, grow and expand creative and innovative efforts in organizations, and facilitate learning (Roudgarnezhad, 2023). Employee voice: Although the argumentative background of employee voice can be traced back to two centuries ago, the initial concept of employee voice was developed in Harishman's (1970) theory of "exit, protest, and loyalty". He stated that employees react to unpleasant situations by leaving the organization or expressing their dissatisfaction (Poorghafari et al, 2022). Maturity of work ethics: Maturity of work ethics in the organization is the key to the ethical behavior of employees. In organizations that emphasize the maturity of work ethics, employees can work professionally (Ichsan et al, 2022). Methodology The current research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-correlative in terms of method. The statistical population of the research was 156 employees of vocational universities of West Azerbaijan province. The size of the statistical sample was estimated to be 111 people based on stratified random sampling and according to Cochran's formula. The data collection tool in this research includes 4 questionnaires. The data analysis of the current research was done using the structural equation modeling method based on PLS3 software, the results of which are presented in the research findings section. Face validity was used to calculate the validity of the research tool, which was approved by professors and experts. Cronbach's alpha coefficient has been used in order to analyze the reliability of the research tool. Discussion and Results The results of data analysis showed that the path coefficient between the two variables of strategic leadership and employee voice is β=0.942; and the significant coefficients between these two variables are p=0.000 and t=29.699, which shows that strategic leadership has an effect on the voice of employees, and therefore the first hypothesis is confirmed. The path coefficient between the two variables of strategic leadership and work ethic maturity is β=0.118; and the significant coefficients between these two variables are p=0.001 and t=5.834, which shows that strategic leadership has an effect on the maturity of work ethics, and therefore the second hypothesis is confirmed. The path coefficient between the two variables of innovative organizational climate and employees' voice is β=0.168; and the significant coefficients of these two variables are p=0.000 and t=2.674, which shows that the innovative organizational climate has an effect on the voice of employees, and therefore the third hypothesis is also confirmed. The path coefficient between the two variables of innovative organizational climate and work ethic maturity is β=0.732; and the significant coefficients between these two variables are p=0.000 and t=12.449, which shows that the innovative organizational climate has an effect on the maturity of work ethics, and therefore the fourth hypothesis is confirmed. The path coefficient between the two variables of work ethic maturity and employees' voice is β=0.849; and the significant coefficients between these two variables are p=0.002 and t=4.153, which shows that the maturity of work ethics has an effect on the voice of employees, and therefore the fifth hypothesis is confirmed. Also, the results indicated that the z-value of the Sobel test in the sixth and seventh hypotheses is equal to 2.673 and 3.250, respectively, which is more than 1.96; so at the confidence level of 99%, the maturity of work ethics plays a mediating role in the influence of strategic leadership and innovative organizational climate on the voice of employees. Conclusion This research was conducted with the aim of providing a structural model of the impact of strategic leadership and innovative organizational climate on the voice of employees with the mediating role of work ethic maturity in vocational universities of West Azerbaijan province. Statistical analysis and experiment and data analysis of the current research were done at two descriptive and inferential levels and with SPSS and PLS3 statistical software; and detailed outputs were analyzed and documented based on related figures and tables. According to the findings of the research, strategic leadership has a positive effect on the voice of employees, and also the positive effect of strategic leadership on the maturity of work ethics was confirmed. On the other hand, the results of the research showed that the innovative organizational climate has a positive effect on the voice of employees. Also, the positive effect of innovative organizational climate on maturity of work ethics was confirmed. Another result of the research was that the maturity of work ethics plays a mediating role in the influence of strategic leadership and innovative organizational climate on the voice of employees. Therefore, it can be said that strategic leadership, innovative organizational climate, organizational voice, and work ethics interact together and can jointly help improve organizational performance, increase employee job satisfaction, and create a positive organizational culture. In fact, strategic leaders can strengthen the work ethics culture in the organization by formulating and promoting ethical principles and organizational values. These leaders create a good role model for employees by demonstrating ethical and responsible behaviors. On the other hand, an innovative organizational climate can lead to an increase in organizational voice, because employees in an environment that values ​​innovation and creativity are more inclined to express their opinions and ideas and adhere to more ethical behaviors.

Human Resource Management

Identification of the Dimensions and Components of Competency‑Based Human Resource Recruitment.

Volume 8, Issue 2, Summer 2026, Pages 443-464

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.501006.1470

Mohammad Ali Nikbakhsh

Abstract The purpose of this study is to identify the dimensions and components of competency-based human resource recruitment at the Islamic Azad University, Bushehr Branch. This research is descriptive-correlational and was conducted cross-sectionally in 1404 (2025-2026) among all employees of the Islamic Azad University, Bushehr Branch, totaling 270 individuals. From this population, 159 participants were selected using simple random sampling based on Cochran’s formula. Data were collected using a researcher-made questionnaire on competency-based human resource recruitment. The validity and reliability of the questionnaire were assessed at 0.91 and 0.93, respectively. Data analysis was performed using SPSS version 26 and Smart PLS version 3 software. The results indicated a significant relationship between the dimensions and components of competency-based human resource recruitment, including: factors affecting human resource recruitment, the importance of selecting and appointing competent personnel, consequences of recruiting competent personnel, mechanisms for recruiting competent personnel, indicators of competent human resource recruitment, barriers to recruiting competent human resources in the current era, and sources for recruiting competent human resources at the Islamic Azad University, Bushehr Branch. Consequently, human resources are considered the primary and most important asset of any organization; therefore, recruitment and procurement processes must be adapted to the specific characteristics of each organization and the conditions of today’s competitive market.
Introduction
Many developed countries prioritize human resources, recognizing that human capital is a nation’s primary asset and that the recruitment of effective personnel ensures their future. Forward-thinking and systematic organizations prioritize the recruitment of competent human resources. Human capital is regarded as the primary and most significant asset of any organization; consequently, human resource supply and recruitment processes must be aligned with an organization’s specific characteristics and the conditions of today’s competitive market (Campoamor-Olegario et al., 2025). Undoubtedly, human resources represent an organization’s most irreplaceable capital and asset, regardless of whether management is consciously aware of this value. Identifying, recruiting, deploying, and leveraging human resources constitutes one of the most complex functional processes in any organization (Li & Wang, 2022). Selecting competent personnel is recognized as a fundamental pillar of any organization, alongside physical and financial resources. Without competent human resources, the effective utilization of other assets is impossible; therefore, to maximize the utility of all resources, it is essential to recruit competent personnel (Mohammadi et al., 2024).
The specific duties and missions of the Islamic Azad University are educational, developmental, and research-oriented. Its deep connection with discovering, nurturing, and guiding the vast potential of talented students, as well as laying the groundwork for developing human resources while promoting a comprehensive culture, distinguishes it from other institutions. Consequently, addressing these specific requirements and needs is essential (Raeisi et al., 2024). Higher education is unique in that all its elements—from inputs to outputs—are intrinsically intertwined with human development, growth, and education. Therefore, the decision-making process regarding recruitment and the implementation of a competency-based recruitment model in higher education differ significantly from those in other organizations. Applying a “one-size-fits-all” approach or relying on temporary, ad-hoc solutions to meet needs is inappropriate in this context (Nosrati et al., 2022).
One of the eight programs defined in the administrative reform roadmap is the “Competent Human Capital Management Program,” which is based on the General Policies of the Administrative System issued by the Supreme Leader. The goal of this program is “recruiting human resources commensurate with needs, and fostering human capital excellence to utilize them efficiently toward realizing the country’s development goals” (Moazzami et al., 2022). It appears that competence acts as an umbrella term, encompassing any factor that directly or indirectly impacts job performance. In other words, competence represents a well-developed individual who possesses the comprehensive readiness required to perform a specific job (Maryani et al., 2025).
This study aims to design and delineate the dimensions and components of employee competence at the Islamic Azad University in collaboration with professional experts. The goal is to professionalize staff, enabling not only the country’s experts and practitioners to develop their knowledge and skills but also ensuring that qualified and competent individuals are selected for key university positions, thereby helping the Islamic Azad University overcome current stagnation and future challenges (Qasempour, 2025). Therefore, in light of the above, the researcher seeks to address the following question: What are the dimensions and components of competency-based human resource recruitment at the Islamic Azad University, Bushehr Branch?
Theoretical Framework
Competence
Psychologists have defined competence as a core motive, characteristic, or skill that leads to superior job performance. Marabel and Richard (1997) argue that selecting the most competent candidates requires attention to individuals’ abilities, behavioral indicators, beliefs, personality traits, attitudes, and skills. According to the definition provided by the International Board of Standards for Training, Performance and Instruction (IBSTPI), competence is defined as a set of knowledge, attitudes, and skills that enable employees to effectively perform job-related activities or job functions according to the desired standards. Spencer (1993) posits that competence is an underlying characteristic of an individual that is causally related to criterion-referenced effective or superior performance in a job or situation (Mohammadi Zaeer et al., 2025).
Mohammadi Zaeer et al. (2025) examined the identification of drivers in developing Gen Z competencies, utilizing a futures studies approach in human resources at the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology. The research findings indicated that the primary competencies required for Gen Z include innovation and creativity, communication skills, technology proficiency, time management and prioritization, cultural and social awareness, emotional intelligence, and personal development and continuous learning. These competencies served as the basis for designing various scenarios and formulating appropriate strategies for developing Gen Z human resources within the Ministry.
Qasempour (2025) investigated the impact of human resource competence and technology acceptance on HR analytics capability (Case study: Municipalities of Gilan Province). The results of this study demonstrated that human resource competence and technology acceptance have a positive and significant effect on human resource analytics capability.
Research Methodology
The present study is descriptive-correlational in nature and was conducted cross-sectionally in 1404 (2025) among all employees of the Islamic Azad University, Bushehr Branch. The total population consisted of 270 employees, of whom 159 individuals were selected using simple random sampling based on Cochran’s formula. Data were collected using a researcher-developed Competency-Based Human Resource Recruitment Questionnaire. The validity and reliability of the questionnaire were assessed as 0.91 and 0.93, respectively.
Research Findings
The data were analyzed using SPSS version 26 and SmartPLS version 3. The results demonstrated a statistically significant relationship among the dimensions and components of competency-based human resource recruitment at the Islamic Azad University of Bushehr Province. These dimensions and components included:
· Factors influencing human resource recruitment
· The importance of selecting and appointing competent personnel
· Outcomes of recruiting competent personnel
· Mechanisms for recruiting competent personnel
· Indicators of competent human resource recruitment
· Barriers to recruiting competent personnel in the contemporary era
· Sources of competent human resource recruitment
Accordingly, human resources represent the primary and most important asset of any organization. Therefore, human resource supply and recruitment processes must be aligned with each organization’s specific characteristics and the conditions of today’s competitive labor market.
Conclusion
The present study was conducted with the aim of identifying the dimensions and components of competency-based human resource recruitment at the Islamic Azad University, Bushehr Branch. The results of this research are consistent with the findings of Mohammadi Zaeer et al. (2025), Qasempour (2025), Foucrier and Wiek (2025), Karami Moghaddam and Vishlaghi (2025), Hadian et al. (2025), Abidi et al. (2024), Čopíková et al. (2024), Safarloo et al. (2024), Butson et al. (2023), and Bekhit et al. (2023). Foucrier and Wiek (2025) demonstrated that there is a correlation between the individual and social competence of managers and their management effectiveness. Furthermore, a significant correlation was found between all variables concerning the dimensions of managers’ competencies (individual and social) and their effectiveness. However, no significant correlation was observed between managerial skills, personality traits, and managers’ attitudes and insights regarding effectiveness, and the impact prioritization for each sub-index of the variables was also determined.
Based on these findings, it is recommended that administrators at the Islamic Azad University, when implementing competency-based human resource recruitment, pay special attention to: creating a consultative environment, utilizing negotiation power for conflict resolution, avoiding negative competition, upholding ethics in interactions with subordinates, serving the public, avoiding ostentation, practicing patience and kindness, maintaining honesty and truthfulness, demonstrating decisiveness and boldness, promoting contentment and simplicity, fulfilling promises, ensuring consistency between words and actions, and utilizing persuasive and inspiring communication.

Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge all individuals, institutions, and organizations that provided scientific, technical, administrative, or advisory support throughout this research and the preparation of this manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial, personal, professional, or institutional conflicts of interest relevant to this work.
Data Availability Statement
The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
AI Use Statement
The authors declare that no generative artificial intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, writing, or editing of this manuscript.
Funding
The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other financial support were received during the conduct of this research or the preparation of this manuscript.
Ethics Approval
All procedures performed in this study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible institutional and national research committee.

The effectiveness of classroom management skills training on classroom psychosocial climate and teacher’s self-efficacy

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 14-32

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2022.325680.1092

Farzaneh Azarboueh, Naser Nastiezaie

Abstract Abstract
The Purpose of this research was to investigate the effectiveness of classroom management skills training on classroom psychosocial climate and teacher’s self-efficacy. A quasi experimental design was employed with pretest, posttest and control group. The population of this study included all new teachers employed in Zabol city (Sistan and Baluchestan province) in the academic year 2021-2022. The sample consisted of 30 teachers which were randomly selected in two groups of 15 experimental and control groups. The data collection instrument was questionnaires of classroom psychosocial climate of Fraser et al., and teachers' self-efficacy of Techanan-Mooran et al., that all participants completed as the pre-test. Then, the relationship intra-individual skills training were conducted in the experimental group for eight sessions (60 minutes). Finally, the posttest was completed by both experimental and control groups. The univariate analysis of covariance was used to analyze the data. The findings indicated that classroom management skills training has a positive and significant effect on classroom psychosocial climate and teacher self-efficacy. Therefore, classroom management skills training should be considered as one of the prerequisites for the teaching profession for novice teachers.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Teacher self-efficacy is described as his judgment about his abilities to make positive results for students' learning and engage them in educational affairs (Jessica et al, 2021). Self- effective teachers create an optimal psychological-social climate for learners. The classroom psychological-social climate means social communication template among classmates and relation with teacher and general form of teaching and training. (Soldozi, 2020) The classroom psychological-social climate can be enriched by cohesion, it can be disciplined, assignment-based, challenging and striving or competitive (özüdoğra.2020). If teachers don't manage the classroom properly, they can't control teaching-learning process and they don't make a suitable climate for learning. (Jafari et al., 2017) The effective management is considered to be one of the most important issues for teachers, especially for novice ones will be more complicated (Flower et al., 2017). Since novice teachers are worried about creating a suitable environment for learning and class management, they can not conveniently conduct whatever they have learned from academic training, as a result they always feel a sense of failure and inefficiency (Hajitabar Firouzjaee, 2020). Here, the project's results help teachers especially novice ones to manage and control the class effectively by learning the classroom management skills and creating a psychological-social climate for students. In this way they will promote their self-efficacy in teaching too. So the main issue of the project is to survey the effect of training class management skill on teacher's self-efficacy and create a psychological-social climate in class.
Theoretical framework
The classroom management includes teaching management, personnel management and behavior management (Emmer et al., 1980). The classroom management styles are introduced in this way; non-intrusive, interventional and interactively (Glickman & Tamashiro, 1982). The best management style is a management in which limitations and expectations are accounted, and presented in a simple and intelligible language, by means of proper methods and devices for training (lm et al., 2019). Techanan-Mooran et al, (1998) describe teacher self-efficacy as his/her judgment about his/her abilities to create positive outcomes for students learning and involvement in education even with problematic and unmotivated students. They are divided into three subscales "student involvement ", "teaching methods", and "classroom management "Teachers with high self -efficacy design their educational goals and try to use new method to overcome the challenges they face and achieve their goals (Ross.2002). Teachers with self efficacy are more skillful in organizing education, asking questions, explaining, giving appropriate feedback to students in difficult situations continually and keeping students active in their homeworks (Chan.2008). Teachers who feel more self sufficient, can provide more opportunities for their students to progress (Skaalvic & Skaalvic, 2007). Friser et al., (1987) state that the classroom climate and situations are created by school, teachers, classmates and other school agents. Psycho-social environment influence on student’s activities, classmate orientation, teacher orientation, school orientation, behavior, self-efficacy, learning empowerments, self-concept, success and schooling achievement, emotional and social development, class leadership style, teacher's fatigue and quality of school life (Fraser, 1981).
Akyar et al (2022) discovered that there is a relationship between the class management skills and the students' self-regulative guidelines (self-monitoring, self-evaluation, self-enhancement).
Fathi et al (2021) discovered that in spite of the effect of self-efficiency and the teacher's acceptance of the job-fatigue, the teacher's self-efficiency is more predictive in their job-fatigue.
Veisi et al (2021) discovered that class management authority sources (specialty, encouragement, punishment, and resourcefulness) are able to predict the teacher's style of teaching.
Research methodology
A quasi experimental design was employed with pretest, posttest and control group. The population of this study included all new teachers were employed in Zabol city (Sistan and Baluchestan province) in the academic year 2021-2022. The sample consisted of 30 teachers which were randomly divided in two groups of 15 experimental and control. The data collection instrument was questionnaires of classroom psychosocial climate of Fraser et al., and teacher self-efficacy of Techanan-Mooran et al., that all participants completed as the pre-test. Then, the classroom management skills training were conducted in the experimental group for eight sessions (60 minutes). Finally, the same questionnaire was completed by both experimental and control groups. In order to analyze the data, descriptive statistics (mean and standard deviation) and inferential statistics (univariate analysis of covariance) were used by SPSS21.
 
Research findings
The first finding show that the mean of classroom psychosocial climate in the post test of experimental group is significantly higher than that of control group (Sig=0/002, DF=27&1, F=11.134). Based on the first hypothesis of research (classroom management skills training has a positive and significant effect on class psychosocial climate) it is confirmed that the rate of this effect will be 0.292.
The second finding shows that the mean of teacher's self-efficacy in post test relating to experimental group is significantly higher than that of control group (Sig=0/001, DF=27&1, F=40.410). Based on this hypothesis of research (the classroom management skills training has a positive and significant effect on teacher's self-efficacy) it is confirmed that the rate of this effect will be 0.599.
Conclusion
This study was conducted to investigate the effectiveness of classroom management skills training on the psychosocial climate of teachers' overall self-efficacy. The results showed that management skills training has a positive and significant effect on the psychosocial climate of the classroom and teachers' self-efficacy. This finding is consistent with the results of studies (Browne, 2013, Shobe, 2003, Kerssen-Griep & Witt, 2012, Lewis et al., 2008, Nakamur, 2000, Abu-Tineh et al., 2011, Stronge, 2018). Explaining this finding, it can be said that teaching classroom management skills causes teachers to teach classroom rules to students, to apply the rules in a coherent and fair manner among students, to act preventively and proactively against inappropriate student behaviors, involve students in the process of creating and maintaining rules and procedures, spend more time on teaching, and waste less time on distractions, and know when to change daily activities or when there is a need to intervene to avoid behavioral problems, to be willing to be exposed to problems when problems arise so that they can eliminate them; they consciously reduce their physical or mental distance from students resulting in an attractive, task-oriented, and organized class. In these classes, the relationship between teacher and student is positive and based on mutual respect, and educational expectations from students are clarified, and a suitable structure is provided to meet the expectations. As a result, they lead the psycho-social climate of the class to the desired climate and have a higher sense of self-efficacy. According to the findings of this study (the positive effect of classroom management skills training on the psychosocial climate of the classroom and teacher self-efficacy), it is suggested to education planners to design a program to teach classroom management skills in the form of workshops, brochures or books for teachers.
 

Structural modeling of the effect of manager's management skills on teachers' job satisfaction

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 32-52

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2022.327496.1097

hoda arabi makiabadi, Elham Heydari

Abstract The purpose of this study is to investigate the effect of manager's managerial skills on teacher's job satisfaction. The present study is applicable in terms of purpose and descriptive-correlative in terms of nature and method of data collection; and is specifically based on structural equation modeling. The statistical population of the study was primary school teachers and principals in Shiraz in the academic year 1399-1400, 773 people (690 teachers and 83 principals), of which 244 people were selected as the teacher sample size, based on Krejcie and Morgan table and by simple random sampling method. In this study, two questionnaires including the standard management skills questionnaire of Katz (1974) and Minnesota job satisfaction were used. Findings showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between managerial skills of school principals and teacher's job satisfaction. The results also showed that the human skills component has the most power in relation to teacher's job satisfaction.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Successful managers must have specific techniques, methods and knowledge relevant to their field of work, as well as general knowledge and expertise in various fields. Effective managers must also be equipped with human or people skills related to coordination with individuals, self-awareness, understanding of others, motivation, leadership and ability to develop employees. But most managers, especially managers of government agencies, have little human and technical skills and pay more attention to perceptual skills (Zakavati, 2016: 240). Among the issues facing schools in selecting principals, selecting competent principals according to the criteria and components necessary to hold this position and role is important (Mohammadi, Abadi & Fallahzadeh, 2021: 70). There is a lot of evidence that confirms the effect of specialized training on improving the performance of technical managers of organizations (Navid Adham & Shafi'zāde, 2020: 42).
By using the individual and professional competencies of teachers, implementing programs with a clear vision and setting understandable and practical goals, the educational administrators can help improve educational activities, and review and increase school productivity. In addition, educational administrators should evaluate the effectiveness and efficiency and the achievement of educational goals by continuously evaluating the teaching and educational activities of the school and use the appropriate opportunity to review educational programs (Abdullah, 2019: 22). Another task of educational administrators is to pay attention to the interests and desires of teachers, and to provide appropriate conditions and facilities to increase the satisfaction and desire to do organizational work. One of the effective ways to motivate, set and assign specific and achievable goals is to recognize different individual and organizational needs and to coordinate teachers' behavior with school goals (Navid Adham & Shafi'zāde, 2020: 47). Given the above, the main issue of the research is: what effect do managers 'managerial skills have on teachers' job satisfaction?
Theoretical Framework
If we want to have a dynamic and advanced education, its administrators must necessarily change, that is, their knowledge and information must be updated and their technical, perceptual, human and communication attitudes and skills must be developed. Paying attention to this will have many consequences and blessings, one of which is to increase the satisfaction of teachers. In case of increasing teachers' satisfaction, the quality of education, the efficiency of the school system, saving educational costs and the optimal use of time and educational facilities, and etc. will increase, and in general the efficiency and effectiveness of the educational system will increase (Adli & Motallebi Varkani, 2018: 33).
Robert Katz has observed three skills in the field of administrative behavior. Robert Katz's three skill trends all emphasize what one does (Marshall, 2015: 51). These skills include technical skills, human skills and perceptual skills. What managers become familiar with during training courses is actually a kind of technical skill. Courses such as finance, planning, construction plans, recruitment, curriculum planning, purchasing, and the like are taught to educational administrators from the beginning. Technical skills are both easy to teach and easy to learn, and once applied, their learning can be clearly assessed. The ability of a manager as a member of the group to work effectively, to create collective efforts within the group he leads or manages, is called human skill. The difference between human skill and technical skill is working with people (human skill) and working with objects (technical skill). Perceptual skill means the ability to see the organization as a whole. In other words, knowing how the various tasks of the organization are interdependent and how changing one part of the organization affects other departments and units (Eslamieh & Davoudi, 2014: 113)
Zavvar et al, (2021) in a study, examined the role of managers 'creativity in mediating the relationship between participatory management and their social responsibility with teachers' job satisfaction and showed that participatory management and managers' creativity have a direct and significant effect on teachers' job satisfaction even though social responsibility of managers has no direct and significant effect on teachers' job satisfaction; and the role of creativity was confirmed as a mediating variable.
Hadavand, (2020) also evaluated the educational effectiveness of specialized project management courses in a study using the Kirk Patrick model. The evaluation results showed that there is a close relationship between the expected results and the defined goals, which confirms the effectiveness of the course.
research methodology
The research method is descriptive-correlative in nature and applicable in terms of purpose. The statistical population of the study consisted of 773 teachers and principals of primary schools in Shiraz in the academic year 1300-1499 (690 teachers and 83 principals). The sample size for teachers was 247 based on Krejcie and Morgan table. In order for all members of the statistical sample related to teachers to have an equal chance of being selected, a simple random sampling method was used. The questionnaire of Katez, (1974) for the managerial skills variable, and the questionnaire of (MSQ) for job satisfaction were used to collect related data.
Research Findings
In order to test the research hypothesis, structural equation modeling of structural equation model-finding method with the help of SPSS software for inferential statistics was used. Then regression was used to test the hypotheses with pls software for confirmatory and content factor analysis as well as the effect of factors, and the results showed that management skills with a coefficient of 0.824 have a significant effect on job satisfaction. The t-statistic for this coefficient is 401/576 and its value is more than the significant threshold of 1.96. Therefore, the main hypothesis of this study is that the significant effect of managers 'management skills on teachers' job satisfaction is confirmed. The results also showed that the path coefficient of the effect of technical, perceptual and human skills on job satisfaction is 0.241, 0.264 and 0.559, respectively. The t-statistic for these coefficients is 5.271, 2.016 and 5.631, respectively, which is greater than the significance threshold of 1.96. Therefore, the sub-hypotheses of this study confirm the significant effect of technical, perceptual and human skills on teachers' job satisfaction.
Conclusion
The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of managers 'managerial skills on teachers' job satisfaction. The results of this study are consistent with the results (Dehghaan Marvasti, 2017) and (Marshal, 2015); their findings show that principals used to be selected solely as school principals, but today school principals are responsible for classroom instruction, learning processes, staff development, curriculum changes, individual and specific school plans, executive plans, and most importantly, actions and decisions of school security, and the role of principals can be emphasized as a factor in teacher satisfaction and improving teacher performance. The more school principals have managerial skills at the technical level, the more professional dependence of teachers will increase. Research findings (Wang & etal, 2018) and (Zavvar & etal, 2021) showed that managers should have an adequate understanding of their role, which includes effective administrative services, monitoring the improvement of teachers' teaching methods, continuous monitoring of compliance with objectives. educational, supervising curriculum planning, the duty of supervising and taking care of affairs and activities for the correct implementation of programs, solving internal and external problems of the school, providing educational technology in schools, creating coordination among staff, supporting staff and teachers and creating a positive and effective organizational atmosphere and culture in the school. According to the present study, it is suggested to the managers of Shiraz education departments to provide the necessary ground to increase the job satisfaction of teachers by holding in-service courses to improve the technical skills of the principal. Since human skill means having the ability and power of discernment to create an environment of understanding and cooperation and to do work by others; School principals are encouraged to know themselves more than anything else, to be aware of their strengths and weaknesses, to be aware of the impact of their words and actions on others, and to be able to provide a safe and acceptable environment for teachers to cooperate.

The relationship between goal orientation and academic self-concept with enthusiasm for school with the mediating role of students' academic persistence

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 53-71

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2022.316798.1085

narjes malekian, samira pali

Abstract Abstract
The present study was conducted with the aim of investigating the relationship between goal orientation and academic self-concept with enthusiasm for school with the mediating role of students' academic persistence. This research is applicable in terms of its purpose and descriptive-correlative in terms of data collection method. Statistical community of school students included 1767 elementary girls' schools in Rahim Abad city, and 251 people were selected as a statistical sample with the help of random cluster sampling. The research data was collected through a questionnaire (Wang et al., 2011; Martin and Marsh, 2008; Elliott and McGregor, 2001; Li Yu and Wang, 2005). SPSS and Lisrel software were used in data analysis. The research findings indicate that goal orientation and academic self-concept have a direct and indirect positive relationship with enthusiasm for school. There is a positive and significant relationship between goal orientation, academic persistence and enthusiasm for school. There is a positive and significant relationship between academic self-concept and academic persistence and enthusiasm for school. Academic persistence plays a mediating role in the relationship between goal orientation and academic self-concept with enthusiasm for school. The results showed that by improving academic self-concept and improving goal orientation, it is possible to increase academic persistence and increase students' enthusiasm for school.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
School is very important in the lives of children and teenagers, and they spend a long time in school; therefore, the level of their interest and passion for school and investigating the factors related to passion for school will be important (Karababa, 2020). The persistence of students makes them adjust their academic problems and develop their abilities by creating motivation and enthusiasm in themselves (Rabiei, 2016). Such students tie their persistence to academic enthusiasm, because persistence in the academic process makes students identify and solve unexpected problems easily. This causes enthusiasm in them to continue their education (Hoferichter & etal, 2021). One type of inference that can be made about students' motivations is the goals they adopt for studying and then adjust and adapt the amount of effort they put in to achieve those goals (Balali, 2017).
The experience of success creates a positive self-concept in students, and successive failures create the impression that they are worthless, weaker and more incompetent than their classmates, which creates a negative self-concept in the students (Wu et al, 2021). Academic self-concept refers to a student's perception or idea of ​​his/her competence in relation to school learning, which affects academic progress and is simultaneously affected by it, and it seems that self-concept and academic performance have a two-way relationship (Tayebi & Mohammadi, 2019).
According to the mentioned materials, the main problem of the research is whether there is a relationship between goal orientation and academic self-concept with enthusiasm for school with the mediating role of academic persistence of female students of elementary school in Rahim Abad city?
Theoretical Framework
Tyler (1976) considers goal orientation to include a part of knowledge, attitude and skills that help people effectively meet their needs (Lin et al, 2022).Academic self-concept refers to mental representations of one's abilities in school and educational environments or representations related to academic progress. In other words, academic self-concept refers to a person's self-evaluation of the domain and special academic abilities (Eslami & et al, 2020). Academic persistence refers to the student's ability to overcome problems and obstacles and challenges that usually occur in the academic life of most students, such as low grades, exam pressure, difficult assignments, and feedback on teacher-student relationships, competition, and loss (Rabiei, 2016). Enthusiasm for school refers to the quality of effort that students spend on targeted educational activities to directly contribute to achieving desired results. Academic enthusiasm is a multidimensional construct consists of various behavioral, cognitive and motivational components (Yeung, 2022).
Fartash (2021), in a research on the relationship between education and parents' goal orientation with motivation, self-concept and academic self-efficacy of adolescent girls. The results showed that parents' education has a direct and positive effect on academic self-efficacy, control expectations and children's verbal self-concept. Parents' functional orientation has a positive and direct effect on students' external motivation, but it does not have any significant role on their internal motivation. Parental functional orientation has a positive effect on children's academic self-efficacy and academic self-concept through the mediation of external motivation.
Green et al, (2021) conducted a study titled "The relationship between academic motivation, academic self-concept and enthusiasm for school with academic performance". The results of the research showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between academic motivation, academic self-concept and enthusiasm for school with students' academic performance.
Methodology
The research method is descriptive-correlative in nature and applicable in terms of purpose. The statistical population of the research was made up of 1767 girls' elementary school students in Rahim Abad city, of which 251 people were selected as the research sample by random cluster sampling. To collect data related to the variable of passion for school, the questionnaire (Wang et al, 2011) with 10 questions; and for the variable of academic persistence, the questionnaire (Martin & Marsh, 2008) with 4 questions; and for the variable of goal orientation, the questionnaire (Alyot & Mac Grigor, 2001) with 9 questions; and for the academic attitude variable, the questionnaire (Li u & Wang, 2005) with 15 questions; and it was used based on a 5-point Likert scale (completely agree to completely disagree).
Discussion and Results
In order to investigate the research hypothesis and data analysis, SPSS and Lisrel software were used, and the results showed that goal orientation and academic self-concept have a direct and indirect positive relationship with enthusiasm for school. Students who analyze their educational conditions and have a coherent plan for their lessons can better show perseverance against the problems they face and will show more persistence. There is a positive and significant relationship between goal orientation and academic persistence and students' enthusiasm for school. Students who have plan for their lessons can acquire the desired educational results among other students. There is a positive and significant relationship between academic self-concept, academic persistence and enthusiasm for school. Students who have high academic persistence try to do their best during the class. Academic persistence plays a mediating role in the relationship between goal orientation and academic self-concept with enthusiasm for school. Students who try to pay more attention in learning the lessons during the teaching in the classroom can better educate the materials. The results showed that by improving academic self-concept and improving goal orientation, academic persistence can be increased and cause an increase the enthusiasm for school. Students who can cope with school problems such as bad grades and negative feedback about their work can better align their academic plans with academic goals.
 
Conclusion
The present study was conducted with the aim of investigating the relationship between goal orientation and academic self-concept with enthusiasm for school with the mediating role of students' academic persistence. The results of this research are consistent with the results of research findings (Rahmati, 2020); (Green et al., 2020); (Fathi, 2018); (Gorbani, 2014) and (Skaalvik, 2020); People who have higher academic self-concept than other students are more eager to go and stay in school and avoid frequent absences in school. The most important characteristic of academic self-concept is that academic self-concept can be learned and acquired over time, and teachers play an important role in the formation of students' academic self-concept. Based on this, it can be said that higher academic self-concept will improve the conditions of enthusiasm for school.
According to the current research, it is suggested that the new approaches and concepts of positive psychology be used in schools in a way that, by identifying as many effective factors as possible on the goal orientation, a better understanding of the causes and correlations of this phenomenon can be obtained based on which, it is possible to benefit from the positive consequences of goal orientation in the academic future of students through educational planning and counseling. It is recommended for school teachers to use active, exploratory and learning-oriented teaching methods and to teach lessons in a practical and applied manner as much as possible so that specialization becomes the main goal of learning. This will improve the goal orientation in students.
 

Investigating the factors affecting the job motivation of the employees of the Islamic Azad University of Kashmar branch based on Herzberg's theory of health-motivational factors

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 72-89

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2022.330280.1101

Reza Besharati

Abstract The present study was conducted with the aim of investigating the factors affecting the job motivation of employees of the Islamic Azad University of Kashmar branch based on Herzberg's theory of health -motivational factors. In this descriptive and analytical research, 90 people out of 100 official and contract employees of Islamic Azad University, Kashmar branch participated in the academic year 2018-2019. In order to investigate the factors affecting the job motivation of employees, a researcher-made questionnaire based on Herzberg's theory was used, and after confirming its validity and reliability, the research data was obtained using spss-21 software in the form of frequency distribution and Pearson variance and correlation analysis. The results of the research showed that the most important factors affecting employees' job motivation were "job security and stability" and "level of salary" in the field of health factors, and "nature of work" and "growth and progress" in the field of motivational factors, and the effect of health factors in creating career motivation is more than motivational factors.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
The perception, attitude and needs of people to work in every organization are different from each other. Therefore, the management of the organization must have a real, correct and logical understanding of the people of the organization in order to be able to use them to achieve the goals and objectives of the organization by creating appropriate motivation (Asefzadeh, 2018), as far as the human force does not have acceptable job motivation. Other activities of the organization will not have the necessary results and outcomes, providing the necessary motivation to do the work and paying attention to the motivational forces of employees is one of the most important and at the same time the most complicated tasks of organizations (Muslimi et al, 2017).
Providing career motivation in organizations has various benefits such as innovation, gaining customer satisfaction, competitive advantage, etc. (Atefi, 2017), it is important to know what factors affect the motivation, commitment and retention of employees in the organization (Suttikun et al. al, 2018), therefore, every organization should adopt the necessary policies and guidelines to improve employee motivation (Atefi, 2017). Lack of job motivation of employees, irresponsibility and lack of effective work is one of the most obvious work situations in Iran (Taleghani, Davoodi, 2017).
According to the mentioned materials, the main problem of the research is: what are the effective factors on the job motivation of the employees of the Islamic Azad University of Kashmar branch based on Herzberg's theory of health-motivational factors?
Theoretical Framework
Different theories and methods have been presented to motivate employees. One of the important theories in this field, which also forms the structure of the current research, is Herzberg's motivational theory. The factors creating job-satisfaction were called motivational factors, and the factors whose supply do not necessarily lead to satisfaction, were called health factors by Herzberg. These two categories of factors are known as Herzberg's two-factor theory of motivation (Lutans, 2021). Health factors are mainly related to the "job environment and context, not the job itself". These factors include: salary and other types of employee benefits, administrative policies and regulations governing the working environment, personal relationships with partners, supervisors and subordinates, job guarantee, working environment conditions, supervision and monitoring. Motivational factors are related to the essence and nature of the job (work content) and have a positive effect on morale, efficiency, and productivity. According to Herzberg, motivational factors are: recognition and appreciation, nature of work, career success, responsibility, growth and development (Iran Nejad, 2022).
Ganjali (2020) in a research in the field of designing a motivational model for non-academic employees of Imam Sadiq University (a.s.) concluded that the priorities of university managers to motivate employees in order of priority are: paying bonuses to employees based on merit, development Professionalism of employees and job guarantee, employee-favored behavior of officials and development of personal characteristics of officials.
The research of Mehrabian et al, (2020) at Gilan University of Medical Sciences showed that the level of motivation and satisfaction of employees in all investigated areas including management, supervision, communication, physical conditions of the workplace, psychological conditions and job guarantee, promotion opportunities And personal growth and salaries and benefits is at the average level, and only in the area of ​​satisfaction with the work environment, has been at the optimal level.
Methodology
The current research is applicable in terms of its purpose and descriptive-survey in terms of data collection method, which was conducted in order to investigate the factors affecting the job motivation of employees of the Islamic Azad University of Kashmar Branch based on Herzberg's theory. The statistical population in this research included all the employees who were employed by the university in official and contractual ways in the academic year 2018-2019, so the total sample size was 100 people, which made up all the members of the research community, and after the distribution of questionnaires 90 people completed them. In order to collect data related to research variables, a researcher's questionnaire was used, which includes three parts; 4 questions related to individual characteristics in the first part; 44 question to examine the opinions of employees regarding the factors affecting their job motivation in the second part; and at the end of the questionnaire, three open-ended questions are asked, two of which question the factors affecting the highest and lowest levels of job satisfaction, and the last question has been asked from research units.
Discussion and Results
In order to investigate the research hypothesis and data analysis, SPSS 21 software was used and the results showed that in examining the relationship between the factors affecting job motivation and individual characteristics of employees, the results of the Pearson correlation test showed that there was a positive and significant correlation (586/ r=0) between age and health factors (P-value=0.001) and also between age (r=0.857) and motivational factors (P-value=0.001). The results of the analysis of variance showed that there is a significant difference between the two sexes in terms of health (P-value=0.001) and motivational factors (P-value=0.007), which means that in men, the score of health and motivational factors is more than that in women. There is a significant difference in terms of health factors (P-value = 0.003) and content (P-value = 0.001), that is, the score of health and motivational factors in people with education higher than diploma is higher than the score of health and motivation factors for people with diploma education and lower. There is a significant difference between the type of employment in terms of motivational factors (P-value = 0.001), in official employees, the score of motivational factors is higher than that of contract workers (P-value = 0.001).
Conclusion
This research was conducted with the aim of investigating the factors affecting the job motivation of employees of the Islamic Azad University of Kashmar branch based on Herzberg's theory of health-motivational factors. The results of the research showed that the most important factors affecting the job motivation of employees in the field of health factors were "job security and stability" and "rate of salary" and in the field of motivational factors "nature of work" and "growth and development", and the effect of health factors in creating job motivation is more than that of motivational factors. The results of this research are in agreement with the findings of Ganjali (2020), Ghanbari et al, (2014), Pourmiri et al, (2011), Sotoudeh (2013), Dadashzadeh et al, (2013), Shigli et al, (2011). The results of examining the relationship between the factors affecting job motivation and the individual characteristics of employees showed that the scores of contextual and motivational factors in men were higher than in women, and in employees with higher than diploma education, it was higher than in employees with less than diploma education. Also, the score of motivational factors in official employees was higher than that in contract people. These findings are contrary to the results of the study of Asgarian (2012), which did not observe any significant difference between the motivational and health factors with the level of education, background and employment status in the statistical population, (Azizi, 2015). Pourmiri et al, (2011) have also reported in their studies that there is a significant difference between the job motivations of employees according to the type of employment; in expressing these differences, it can be said that the motivational factors of the work environment can be different in organizations and time for different reasons.
According to the findings of this study, it is suggested to increase the financial payments to the employees according to the needs of life, performance and education; and to formulate the necessary rules by the central organization of the university in order to ensure that the employees are covered by the labor law and have sufficient support in the legal authorities, and have job security. Employees should be dealt with based on their merits, records and performance, and political and ethnic relations should not play a role in promoting or demoting their administrative ranks, and people should benefit from sufficient opportunities for career and academic advancement.

Examining the level of identity and academic well-being and their role in reducing academic procrastination of students

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 90-107

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2022.340381.1116

forouzan sharifi, haideh ashouri

Abstract The purpose of this research is to investigate the level of identity and academic well-being and their role in reducing academic procrastination of students. The research method was descriptive-correlative in nature, and applicable in terms of purpose. The statistical population of the research was made up of 6225 secondary school students of Ramsar city. The sample size of the research was 188 people, which was obtained by random cluster sampling. In order to collect data, the standard questionnaires of academic identity by Vaz and Isaacson (2008), academic well-being by Pieternin et al. (2014) and academic procrastination by Sulmon and Rothblum (1989) were used. Their validity was confirmed by academic experts and their reliability was also confirmed through Cronbach's alpha coefficient test. In order to analyze the data, the structural equation technique was used, accompanied by Lisrel statistical software and Spss statistical software. The research findings showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between academic identity and academic well-being. There is a negative and significant relationship between academic identity and academic procrastination. There is a negative and significant relationship between academic well-being and academic procrastination. The results of the research indicate that academic well-being plays a mediating role in the relationship between academic identity and academic procrastination of students. On the other hand, the component of successful identity has had the greatest impact on academic well-being and academic procrastination of students.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Researchers pointed that when people consider their duties unpleasant, attempt procrastination. Since academic procrastination includes postponing a lesson until the night before test, which ultimately leads to the academic failure, it is probable to be in relation with the other inabilities in learning in students (Moradi et al, 2016). Academic well-being is one of important and effective variables in academic performance. It is derived from the theoretical basis of positive-view psychology, and those who behave depressively and have negative emotions such as anger, distress, and grief more than others are subject to the academic failure and leaving the school(jahani et al, 2018).
Findlow (2012) considers the academic identity as the most important factor in academic performance and motivation to advance. Academic identity can be considered as an effective individual factor in occurrence of academic procrastination (Samimi et al, 2017). Academic identity is the process of everybody's sensible respond to his/her academic situation; whether he/she should study or not? Which way he/she should take, and thus search for his/her academic identity. If such an identity in a person, there will be some sense for movement and success in different aspects of education (Tran et al, 2017).
According to the mentioned materials, the main discussion of this research is that if there is any relationship between the academic identity and academic procrastination of the students along with emphasize on the moderating role of academic well-being of the high school students in Ramsar city.
Theoretical Framework
Academic procrastination is one of the behavioral problems that has a very high prevalence and is one of the variables related to the academic status of students. Procrastination is described as a lack of self-regulation and the tendency to delay what is necessary to achieve a goal. One of the manifestations of procrastination is the emergence of the characteristic or attribute of procrastination in school environments, which is called academic procrastination (Ghadampour et al. et al., 2020).
Academic identity is a reflection of the types of competences, autonomy, purposefulness, efficacy beliefs, and the experience of common emotions that teenagers have in classrooms with their peers and teachers, and its characteristic is how to act in academic fields (Frick & Brodin, 2020).
The academic well-being of students depends on their overall satisfaction with the level of fulfillment of their expectations (Davoodi Beilandi, 2017). Degarmo & Martinez (2006) consider academic well-being to have components such as the ability to do school assignments, satisfaction with education, and academic enthusiasm (Hietajärvi et al, 2019).
(Rashvandi & Ashouri, 2022) investigated the relationship between information literacy and teaching quality of teachers with academic well-being with the moderating role of students' study strategies. The research findings showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between teachers' information literacy and students' academic well-being. There is a positive and significant relationship between the quality of teachers' teaching and students' academic well-being. There is a positive and significant relationship between teachers' information literacy and students' academic well-being with the moderating role of study strategies.
Shalian (2021) in a research investigated the relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic well-being, emphasizing the mediating role of academic adjustment in first secondary girls' schools of Kashmer city. The results of the research indicated that there is a positive and significant relationship between teachers' communication skills and students' academic adjustment and academic well-being. There is a positive and significant relationship between students' academic adjustment and their academic well-being.
Methodology
The research method is descriptive-correlative in nature and applicable in terms of purpose. The statistical population of this research included secondary school students of Ramsar city in the academic year of 2001-2014, with the number of 6225 people. In order to determine the size of the statistical sample, due to the large size of the statistical population, two schools were randomly selected and one class was selected from each school, which includes seventh to twelfth grade classes. A total of 12 classrooms were selected with a total of 188 students. To collect data related to the academic identity variable the questionnaire of Vaz & Izakson, (2009) with 40 questions; for academic well-being variable the questionnaire of Piternin et al, (2014) with 11 questions; and for academic procrastination variable the questionnaire of Solmon & Rasblom, (1989) with 15 questions were used; based on a 5-point Likert scale (completely agree to completely disagree).
 
Discussion and Results
SPSS and LISREL software were used to investigate the research hypothesis and analyze the data, and the results showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between academic identity and academic well-being, and there is a negative and significant relationship between academic well-being and academic procrastination, and There is a negative and significant relationship between academic identity and academic procrastination, and academic well-being plays a mediating role in the relationship between academic identity and academic procrastination.
Conclusion
The current research was conducted with the aim of investigating the level of identity and academic well-being and their role in reducing academic procrastination of students. There is a positive and significant relationship between academic identity and academic well-being. Students are trying to get the best grades for studying and their planned goals. They are not worried about their lessons because they study it at home after every class teaching and they are trying to do their best in the classroom (Dugas et al, 2020). There is a negative and significant relationship between academic well-being and academic procrastination. In the explanation of this finding, it can be said that students who only dream about getting their grades procrastinate and refuse to do their homework. There is a negative and significant relationship between academic identity and academic procrastination. We can point to two factors, one is the difference in the tools used and the other is the role of the goals of the country's education system and public culture in the field of paying attention to emotions and feelings (Flecknoe et al, 2017). Academic well-being plays a mediating role in the relationship between academic identity and academic procrastination. Students who do not have a correct and stable academic identity do not have the necessary concentration when doing school assignments, and are always nervous and hot-tempered. They will quickly become nervous and upset when dealing with problems and lose the power of thinking. These findings are consistent with the results of Was et al, (2018), Ozer & Akgun, (2018), Komarraju & Dial, (2019), Rashvandi & Ashouri, (2022), (Rahimi & Farhadi, 2017), and (Luzón, 2018).
According to the present research, it is suggested that the trainings appropriate to the conditions of the development of processes or new services for students should be taken into consideration, it also suggested the use of advanced and modern structures such as team structures in different parts of the school for the participation of teachers and administrators together to help each other during the time when people have problems in doing their organizational work. At the same time, the trustees of education, especially teachers and school counselors, should try to create a happy and positive environment in the school so that students experience more intimacy and by holding educational workshops based on positive psychology, they can institutionalize the concepts of academic well-being.
 

Human Resource Management

Analyzing the dimensions and components of organizational culture based on normative and individual variables in the managers of education headquarters in Tehran province

Volume 5, Issue 3, Autumn 2023, Pages 124-154

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2023.412540.1238

mohammad bermeh, Mohammad Naghi Imani, Saeed Alizadeh, Babak Nasiri, Reza Sourani

Abstract The purpose of the current research is to analyze the dimensions and components of organizational culture based on normative and individual variables in the managers of education headquarters in Tehran province. According to its purpose, the research method is applicable; and in terms of execution method, it is qualitative, descriptive-exploratory; and in terms of its nature, it is among foundation data research. The statistical population of this research includes 12 experts who are well-informed and proficient in the subject of research in the field of management and have a valid scientific background in this field. Sampling method used in this research was non-random purposeful. The method of data collection is referring to documents, semi-structured interviews and questionnaires. For data analysis, Atlas ti software was used to code the interviews. The results showed that in the normative dimension, there are 10 categories: organizational justice, work maturity, ambiguity avoidance, external supervision, decision-making, job promotion, masculinity or feminism, concentration (power distance), customer orientation, productivity with 57 indicators; and in the Individual dimension also has 10 categories: sense of belonging, responsibility, individual creativity, communication, participation (teamwork), identity, self-control, motivation, conflict, interaction in 61 indicators and in 6 categories that include causal conditions, communication conditions, background factors, intervener factors, strategies, consequences were identified.
Extended abstract
Introduction
Just as people in the society have certain beliefs, values ​​and behaviors that represent their personality; organizations also have common assumptions and basic beliefs that shape their culture. Culture has been defined as the set of spiritual achievements of a nation. Culture is a human invention and made by human hands. This finding reflects the existence and identity of a society (Mirza Mohammadi, 2021). Organizational culture is the personality of the organization and it is considered as the basic infrastructure for transformation and change, and managers should understand its relationship with national culture and strive for organizational cohesion by taking advantage of its strategic role. Organizational culture is an interwoven set of basic assumptions, common inferences and collective wisdom that is formed in the context of previous experiences and findings in facing internal or external issues and serves as a guiding light and an invigorating source plays a role in shaping the behavior of employees and architecture of the present and future of the organization (Mohammadiyan & Shahsavari, 2019).
Education is a continuous activity, comprehensive and for everyone, which leads to human growth and development, cultural enrichment and the excellence of society, and therefore, innovation should always be created in it. In other words, education is not specific to an exclusive period and time of life and has no time limit, so it must always be renewed and updated (Safaei et al, 2020). For organizational innovation, development and transformation, one of the important organizational conditions that must be considered in policies and implementation of programs is related organizational culture. The author's many years of experience in executive affairs shows that lack of paying attention to organizational culture has not always led to the desired results of innovation, development, organizational transformation and change in organizations (Hamzeh & Hamzeh, 2016). An organizational culture able to respond to environmental changes can lead to optimal organizational performance.
According to the above materials, the researcher asked the main question: what are the dimensions and components of organizational culture based on normative and individual variables in the managers of education headquarters in Tehran province?
 
Theoretical Framework
Organizational Culture
Culture is a set of customs, standards and individual and social behaviors; therefore, while culture is the effect of many parts of religious views, it is also considered the cause of many conditions and situations. Due to the progress of communication tools and the ever-increasing expansion of their use in many social phenomena and developments, the role of culture has become far greater than in the past; in such a way that culture now plays a decisive role at the domestic, regional and international levels and is one of the tools that governments use to achieve their goals and objectives; in this way, cultural dominance is not a new phenomenon. Cultural policy in the general and customary sense includes a set of goals, principles, priorities and executive policies (Mirza Mohammadi, 2021).
Normative and individual variables
In the conceptual definition of norms, most sociologists are more or less unanimous that norms (forms) are the rules of social behavior that guide a person in social actions. Observing these patterns and rules of behavior expected by the society's culture, and avoiding them is punishable (Khabbaz Yazdiha et al, 2020).
Zebardast et al, (2022) investigated the relationship between the transformational leadership factors of educational group managers on the effectiveness of university faculty members through organizational culture. The results showed that the relationship between transformational leadership style of managers and organizational culture was significant and the mediating variable of organizational culture has a significant effect on the relationship between transformational leadership style and the effectiveness of faculty members. It can be said that transformational leadership does not have a direct and significant effect on effectiveness in the final research model. However, transformational leadership affects the effectiveness of faculty members through organizational culture.
Yusefi et al, (2022) investigated the impact of individual and normative variables on ethical leadership. The results of the research show that value, job satisfaction, motivation, personality, creativity, components were individual components, and organizational communication, organizational culture, organizational structure, decision-making styles, roles and expectations, goals and strategy were normative components that had a significant impact on ethical leadership.
Research methodology
This research is applicable in terms of purpose, qualitative in terms of execution method: descriptive-exploratory type, and data-based in terms of its nature. The statistical population includes 12 experts and specialists who are well-informed and proficient in the subject of research in the field of management, and have a valid scientific background in this field. Non-random purposeful sampling method is used to determine the samples and determine the experts.
Research findings
Three types of coding were used to analyze the data obtained from the interview as well as theoretical foundations, which are: open coding, axial coding and selective coding. For analysis, Atlas ti software was used to code the interviews. The results showed that in the normative dimension, 10 categories were identified: organizational justice, work maturity, ambiguity avoidance, external supervision, decision-making, job promotion, masculinity or feminism, concentration (power distance), customer orientation, productivity with 57 indicators; and in the individual dimension also 10 categories: sense of belonging, responsibility, individual creativity, communication, participation, identity, self-control, motivation, conflict, interaction in 61 indicators, and in 6 categories that include causal conditions, communication conditions, background factors, intervener factors, strategies, consequences.
Conclusion
The present research was conducted with the aim of analyzing the dimensions and components of organizational culture based on normative and individual variables in the managers of education headquarters in Tehran province. The results of this research are correspond with the results of Turki et al, (2021), Eimani et al, (2021), Van Dung HA (2020), Yusefi et al, (2020), Mohebbi et al, (2023), Zebardast et al, (2022). Mohebbi et al, (2023) showed that in educational organizations, organizational culture plays an important role in producing teamwork culture and achieving the benefits of the process of participation and collaboration. Educational systems have a special place according to their goals and mission, the most important of which is the training of efficient human resources for other institutions of society; and universities are the most important and key educational organizations that, in addition to training human resources, respond to the social needs for the acquisition and dissemination of knowledge and technology.
According to the results obtained in three dimensions, the following suggestions are presented:
- The motivation of managers to create team and collaborative activities should be improved. The opportunity to grow, develop and acquire new effective professional skills and knowledge for managers should be provided for the managers. The conditions of sustainable competitive advantage should be designed. The ground for continuous improvement of organizational intelligence in order to realize the learning organization should be prepared. Individual development and strengthening positive behaviors of managers should be considered. By creating a positive organizational atmosphere, the cooperative structure of the organization should be strengthened. Agility of the organization structure according to the suitability of the job and competence of the people and increasing the efficiency and effectiveness of the rules and regulations by simplifying matters should be considered. By supporting individual values ​​and de-stressing people, internal motivation and sense of belonging to the organization should be improved. Influence in decision-making and implementation by delegating authority should be considered. The position of managers in the organization should be changed to facilitator and leader. Try to create an active, effective and sustainable teaching and learning environment. Macro vision, goal setting, strategic planning and management, foresight, future research and future-recording and problem solving ability should be taken into consideration as important points for choosing staff managers.
 

Education Management

Analysis of the Relationship between Knowledge Management and Scientific Creativity with the Mediating Role of Intellectual Capital among Literature Students

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 130-147

https://doi.org/10.22034/jmep.2026.227073.1006

Hojatollah Esmaeilnia Ganji

Abstract Extended Abstract
Abstract
     The purpose of this study is to examine the relationship between knowledge management and scientific creativity with the mediating role of intellectual capital among students of literature. This research was conducted using a descriptive–correlational approach and structural equation modeling. The statistical population consisted of 130 literature students, from whom a sample was purposefully selected and examined. Standardized questionnaires on knowledge management, intellectual capital, and scientific creativity were employed to measure the research variables. The findings indicated that knowledge management has a positive and significant effect on scientific creativity, and intellectual capital also exerts a considerable influence on scientific creativity. Moreover, the results revealed that knowledge management has a substantial impact on intellectual capital, and intellectual capital plays a strong and significant mediating role in the relationship between knowledge management and scientific creativity. Accordingly, a significant portion of the effect of knowledge management on scientific creativity is transmitted through the enhancement of human, structural, and relational capital. These results suggest that improving the mechanisms for knowledge creation, sharing, and application within the university environment, along with strengthening intellectual capital, can foster greater scientific creativity among literature students. The findings of this study are consistent with the results of previous domestic and international studies and highlight the importance of knowledge management and intellectual capital in the development of scientific creativity.
Introduction
Scientific creativity, as one of the fundamental components of knowledge production and cultural development, plays a decisive role in determining the quality of universities’ scientific outputs. In the field of humanities—and particularly in literature—scientific creativity is not limited to innovation in research methods or the production of scientific works; rather, it encompasses the ability to reinterpret concepts, critically reread texts, and offer new approaches to literary analysis. Therefore, understanding the factors that can foster scientific creativity among literature students is essential for enhancing the academic level of universities and expanding the capacity of literary research (Taheri Barmaei et al., 2020).
One of the most important of these factors is knowledge management—a systematic process through which knowledge is created, stored, shared, and applied (Azimi et al., 2020). Universities and educational settings can foster scientific creativity only when the knowledge management cycle functions effectively within them. Knowledge management not only facilitates students’ access to reliable sources but also, by providing interactive platforms, creates opportunities for idea exchange, the emergence of new insights, and collective learning (Rahnaward Ahan & Mohammadi, 2009).
However, knowledge management alone is not sufficient. Its effectiveness largely depends on another factor that has recently gained substantial attention: intellectual capital.
Intellectual capital refers to a set of intangible assets such as specialized knowledge, skills, experiences, communication competencies, organizational culture, and structural capital—elements that can directly and indirectly enhance academic and research performance (Ozkan et al., 2017). In the academic environment, a rich human capital base, supportive structures, and effective social relationships can provide the foundation for transforming existing knowledge into new creativity. Hence, intellectual capital may play a mediating role in the relationship between knowledge management and scientific creativity—meaning that knowledge management can enhance scientific creativity only when the knowledge is absorbed and converted into value within an enriched framework of intellectual capital (Ali Mohammadi et al., 2020).
Theoretical Foundations of the Study
Knowledge Management
Universities, as centers for the production and dissemination of knowledge, require mechanisms that enable them to manage existing knowledge in a systematic manner. In this regard, knowledge management helps students not only access scientific resources but also share their knowledge with others, benefit from each other’s experiences, and ultimately generate new ideas. Knowledge management processes typically include knowledge creation, knowledge storage, knowledge sharing, and knowledge application, each of which can play an important role in developing individuals’ scientific capabilities (Hebibi et al., 2019).
Among literature students, knowledge management can be facilitated through studying diverse sources, participating in academic discussions, utilizing academic databases, and interacting with professors as well as fellow students. Such processes can lead to a deeper understanding of literary texts and theories. Ultimately, these activities may contribute to the development of novel ideas and the enhancement of scientific creativity.
Scientific Creativity
Scientific creativity refers to the ability to generate new and valuable ideas, theories, or solutions within scientific domains. This concept is considered one of the key drivers of scientific advancement and the development of knowledge. Scientific creativity typically emerges from the interaction among knowledge, cognitive skills, intrinsic motivation, and a supportive environment (Bahramzadeh, 2019).
In the field of humanities—and particularly in literature—scientific creativity often manifests through proposing new interpretations of literary texts, presenting innovative perspectives in literary criticism, or integrating different theoretical frameworks for the analysis of literary works. Students who possess a higher level of scientific creativity tend to demonstrate a greater capacity to present original viewpoints and conduct innovative research.
Various factors can influence scientific creativity, including the educational environment, access to academic resources, scholarly interactions, and the extent of knowledge sharing among individuals. In this regard, knowledge management can provide a platform through which students become familiar with diverse ideas and perspectives, thereby enhancing their creative capacities (Munir, 2016).
Intellectual Capital
In today’s knowledge-based economy, intangible resources play a more significant role than physical assets in creating value and sustaining competitive advantage. One of the most important of these intangible resources is intellectual capital, which is defined as a combination of knowledge, skills, experiences, relationships, and organizational structures that contribute to value creation and performance improvement.
The concept of intellectual capital first attracted researchers’ attention in the late twentieth century and gradually became one of the key constructs in the fields of knowledge management and human resource management. In academic and university settings, intellectual capital not only enhances scientific productivity but also provides a fertile ground for the emergence of creativity and innovation (Hosseini, 2019).
Intellectual capital generally refers to intangible assets manifested in the form of individuals’ knowledge, organizational structures, and communication networks. Unlike physical capital—which is visible and directly measurable—intellectual capital is non-material in nature, and its value lies in its capacity to generate knowledge, solve problems, and foster innovation.
In organizations, particularly within universities, intellectual capital serves as a crucial driver of educational quality improvement, research development, and knowledge production. For this reason, many scholars have identified intellectual capital as one of the most strategic resources in knowledge-based organizations (Jalalian, 2019).
Research Methodology
This study is applied in purpose and descriptive–survey in method. The statistical population consists of literature students at Islamic Azad University, Tehran Branch. From this population, a purposeful sample of 130 students was selected, and the research questionnaires were distributed among them.
The data collection instrument used in this study was a standardized questionnaire. To test the research hypotheses and validate the conceptual model, Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was employed using the Partial Least Squares (PLS) method and the Smart PLS software.
The PLS approach, which is variance-based, was selected because it imposes fewer restrictions compared to covariance-based SEM techniques such as LISREL or AMOS. Its primary advantage lies in requiring a smaller sample size while still providing reliable results for complex models. Therefore, considering the study’s relatively limited sample and the exploratory–confirmatory nature of its conceptual model, PLS was deemed the most appropriate method for data analysis.
Research Findings
Intellectual Capital → Scientific Creativity
The path coefficient of 0.653 and the t-statistic of 5.55 indicate that intellectual capital has a very strong and positive effect on scientific creativity. In other words, as the level of students’ intellectual capital (comprising human, structural, and relational capital) increases, their level of scientific creativity rises significantly. This path coefficient underscores the substantial impact of this variable on the outcome.
Research Findings
Knowledge Management → Scientific Creativity
The path coefficient of 0.305 with a t-statistic of 2.64 indicates that knowledge management also has a positive and significant effect on scientific creativity; however, the strength of this effect is lower than that of intellectual capital. This result suggests that the ability to create, store, share, and apply knowledge can enhance scientific creativity, but its independent effect is moderate.
Knowledge Management → Intellectual Capital
The very high path coefficient of 0.785 along with a t-statistic of 13.60 demonstrates a very strong and significant relationship between knowledge management and intellectual capital. This finding indicates that knowledge management is one of the most influential factors in strengthening students’ intellectual capital. In other words, improving knowledge management processes significantly enhances students’ knowledge base, structural resources, and academic interactions, which together constitute intellectual capital.
Indirect Effect of Knowledge Management on Scientific Creativity through Intellectual Capital
The path coefficient of 0.513 with a t-statistic of 5.64 indicates that knowledge management, beyond its direct effect, exerts a highly significant indirect effect on scientific creativity via intellectual capital. Notably, this indirect effect is stronger than the direct effect of knowledge management on scientific creativity.
Therefore, intellectual capital functions as a powerful mediator in this relationship, implying that a substantial portion of the impact of knowledge management on scientific creativity is transmitted through strengthening intellectual capital.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings of this study indicate that knowledge management and intellectual capital play a significant role in explaining students’ scientific creativity, and the relationships among the examined variables are statistically significant. The results show that intellectual capital has a positive and relatively strong effect on scientific creativity. This suggests that as students’ levels of knowledge, skills, experiences, and academic interactions increase, greater opportunities are created for the emergence of novel ideas and creative scientific output. In academic environments, intellectual capital can serve as a foundation for fostering critical thinking, exchanging perspectives, and developing innovative approaches to scientific analysis. Therefore, strengthening the components of intellectual capital—particularly human and relational capital—can effectively enhance students’ creative capabilities.
Moreover, the results demonstrate that knowledge management has a positive and significant effect on scientific creativity. This finding implies that processes such as knowledge creation, storage, sharing, and application can facilitate the generation of new ideas and scientific innovation among students. When students operate in environments that encourage knowledge exchange, access to academic resources, and intellectual interaction, the likelihood of scientific creativity increases.
The findings also reveal that knowledge management exerts a very strong and significant effect on intellectual capital. This indicates that improving knowledge management mechanisms leads to the enhancement of human, structural, and relational capital within the university context. Under such conditions, existing knowledge is more effectively organized and transferred, thereby strengthening individuals’ intellectual and academic capacities.
One of the most important findings of this study is the confirmation of the mediating role of intellectual capital in the relationship between knowledge management and scientific creativity. The results show that knowledge management not only has a direct effect on scientific creativity but also contributes to its enhancement indirectly through the development of intellectual capital. In fact, a substantial portion of the impact of knowledge management on scientific creativity is transmitted through intellectual capital. This suggests that while knowledge management provides the infrastructure for access to and exchange of information, the transformation of knowledge into creative ideas largely depends on the level of intellectual capital among individuals and the quality of the academic environment.